Based on 281 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
20 Sherman Hill Rd, Woodbury, CT 06798
Phone: (203) 263-8020
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–9:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–9:30 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Zachary Redin
My girlfriend ordered 2 pizzas and arrived in the pickup window timeframe. Pizzas weren’t ready which wasn’t a problem as it was assumed the pizzas would come out hot and fresh. In the 5 minute drive home the pizzas were cold and so soggy with grease that you couldn’t pick them up. Even with reheating the crust wouldn’t crisp up. Half of one pizza completely fell apart.
… more
Moira McSweeney
Carlito’s food was delicious! The waitstaff could not have been better. They were friendly and courteous! The atmosphere was classic little Italy! I was there for a wedding shower. Will definitely make dinner reservations!
… more
Michael Aldo
Solid Italian menu with all the favorites. Dishes were prepared very well with above average potion sizes. Good staff friendly and attentive. Our new regular spot for home style Italian.
… more
Joesh Zurotis (Joesh)
This was my one and only trip to Carlito’s of Woodbury. An absolute disappointment. The staff was awkward and unsociable, the food was sub par and expensive and the overall experience left much to be desired.
… more
Gin Burke
I enjoyed a nice dinner here with friends, the food and service was good and we liked the ambience. I had the Cavatelli con Pollo with a salad, with a very good Italian dressing. The table dinner rolls came out piping hot and fresh and were delicious. The sauce on the pasta had a little too much oil and was a little bland for my taste, but overall a pleasant experience. My friends both liked their entrees.
… more
Karen Lampiasi
Carlitos is a favorite place of our family to enjoy their warm inviting atmosphere, excellent meal choices, warm oven-baked rolls and wine. The service is excellent!!
… more
Travis
Don’t know why this place is rated so high.. food is ok. Red sauce is terrible and watery. Appetizers are mostly seafood selections. I seem to try this place once every year or so for past 4-5 years and I am still disappointed every time. Servers seem to judge the younger customers that don’t seem to have that Woodbury money in their pockets.
… more
Evan Seide
I’m not a fan of writing bad reviews, but this restaurant really disappointed me.
… more
Ryan Maccione
Very disappointed. Hostess wasn’t very friendly. She just walked us to the table. Someone dropped off bread which was good but plates, silverware and napkins would be helpful. Had to ask when someone else passed by about 5 mins later. I ordered calamari. I was looked and tasted like it was cooked in old fryer oil and then just dumped on the plate. One tiny piece of lemon. Absolutely zero effort to make something great and they took it upon themselves to charge me for the family portion ($22). Total disappointment. My son ordered a kids portion of spaghetti with butter ($18). WOW thats ridiculous. Wife order short ribs. We’re really not sure what they served her but nothing close to short ribs. It was like old pot roast and very tough. Finally, our daughter order ravioli. They were all stuck together as if it was pre-cooked and/or frozen together. The drinks were good. I don’t think we will ever return.
… more
Luke Chang
Welcoming and clean restaurant. Waitress was good . Service was good. Food was great . Parking was fine. I would definitely recommend this place.
… more
… View more