Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available. Based on 741 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
2993 S 25th St, Fort Pierce, FL 34981
Phone: (772) 465-6525
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
BuildaLoonLlc
I ordered $42 worth of food and noticed hair was inside the food. Called and complained a worker asked if it came from my house so my husband drove the fries back up there. Spoke to the “manager” Mike. Mike sent me a text message to my personal phone w the picture of my address saying a police report was filed and if any pictures are posted he’s pressing charges. I feel threatened for an employee/manager to text my personal phone and send a screenshot of my address outside of ordering food. Mike drives a Corvette. I’m calling the police and making a report. Goodfellas Pizza 2993 S 25th St, Fort Pierce FL 34981 If there was an option to give zero stars and make a review I wouldn’t have given them 1 star. Scary and creepy to think that your address that you give a restaurant will screenshot it and send it around for person purposes.
… more
Juke Chandavong
Ate here with my wife. Initially I didn’t want to stop here because it was in fort Pierce but hunger got the best of me. My wife has a meat allergy so I’m very careful about where she eats. Cross contamination can be dangerous for her. She ordered a cheese pizza and it was delicious, no cross contamination. I ordered the Philly cheese steak with jalapeños. It was the best Philly cheese steak I’ve had in a long time. I give 5 stars. Good music was playing while we were there, nice touch.
… more
maria jones
I had delivery and it was cold it was an hour and a 1/2 late and I had a climb farm there was only a little sauce in the bottom a. Little sauce on the top. The ZD was overcooked and the girl said I could cook something else for you? Why would I do that I cannot trust them as she had like an attitude so? I would never order from them again thank you.
… more
Tammy More
For the past few weeks I have been getting delivery from Goodfella’s Pizza and the food and delivery have been above and beyond expectation. This is one of the only restaurants that really know how an Antipasto is supposed to be made. Thank you!
… more
Bigg Cleve
I eat a Goodfellas quite a bit, is really close by my job. Tonight when I call the place my order for lunch I order a chef salad, when I ride the chef salad was a small chef salad and I wanted a large surf salad. I told Lisa the cashier that I wanted to make it a large chef salad, she handed my salad back to Sarah and walked away. I walk by the door and I happened to look up and see Sarah making my salad. She took my original salad and dumped it into the bigger container. She then picked up anything that didn’t land in the container and put it on top. All of this was done bare handed, she them wiped her hands on her apron. Went to the meats and cut it up and put it on my salad. As she was walking myself out to the counter I asked her could I please look at it first. Lisa snatched it from her and said I will handle this, I told her it looks like she just sloppily piled everything on top. Lisa rudely stated ” all she did was add more lettuce, that’s all a bigger salad is”. I said really and she said yes. I asked could I take a picture of the salad and she said sure. I then told her I would not be purchasing it. Lisa reply was “ok”. I may be one person but I will be sure to share my experience with everyone I know.
… more
Matrix Man
Really cozy spot to catch all ur wings & pizzas needs. Friendly customer quick service & the price is right!
… more
B Rad
Would have rated food higher, but the crust was burned. Overall, the pizza was good but would have been better if baked correctly
… more
Nicole Mullen
At 3:50 pm your delivery driver in a silver car cut out into traffic obstructing two lanes while blowing his horn while making a dangerous illegal you turn which could have killed someone. Absolutely awful
… more
Bernard Freeman Sr
Ordered 12pc hot wings & fries for $22. I was only a few mies away and it Took over an hour for them to get here. I ordered a lil crispy. They came swimming in the hot sauce so much so that the bag was soaked the mess leaked out on my bed, the floor & the table. Then weren’t good either & delivery guy actually asked for a tip. They actually deserve a zero.
… more
Shonta Richards
The food is pretty good. Delivery is always on time and the drivers are nice and polite. We’ve tried pretty much everything from pizza to salad to fries and we didnt have any complaints. Goodfellas is our 2nd go to for pizza!
… more
… View more