Founded in 2000, Nestico’s Restaurant is known for a friendly, cozy ambiance with long time professional service staff, and consistently great food. We take pride in our ability to combine old favorites and unique new dishes for a fresh and always evolving wonderful experience. Join us!
Welcoming eatery puts twists on Italian dishes & offers diverse wines & a small-plate bar menu. Based on 573 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
412 N Main St, North Syracuse, NY 13212
Phone: (315) 458-5188
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–8:30 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jason Shealey
Great family atmosphere. Lots of people talking and laughing and enjoying good food. My chicken and pasta was delicious. Super juicy and tender. Drinks from the bar also a hit. The waitress was busy but still had a great, friendly attitude. Food also came out timely
… more
Erica Slater
Nestico’s is a great family owned local Italian/American restaurants. The staff is always super friendly and most night you can find the owner Peter helping out wherever he can. They have a variety of dishes available including a small specials menu that changes often. The food is always good and they are always accommodating to food allergens or changes when requested. They also have a cozy bar with a few tables and two large TV’s for watching sports. Available during nicer weather is a small patio for outside dinning as well. If ever in the North Syracuse area this is a must stop place for a great casual and cozy experience.
… more
christine sabourin
Enjoyed an amazing dinner with friends tonight at this wonderful restaurant. The owner is present and walks around checking on all of the patron’s experience. The food is incredible and the sauces…wow! We will definitely be back!!!
… more
Joyce Deyulio
The pleasant young lady who served us was very pleasant. We ordered the battered haddock. Upgraded to sweet potato fries and the gingered salmon with rice. The later gluten free. Don’t think that I have ever had a bad meal here.
… more
Shane VanHorn
Nestico’s is the perfect place to stop for a great dinner or a drink. They have a wide variety of selections for any type of cuisine you may be looking for. Some great appetizers, including my favorite, French Onion Soup. They also have off menu specials, which expand even more off their standard menu. Their Sauerbraten is a nice option, but served only specific times. Finish off the meal with a delicious creme brulee or one of their other desert options.
… more
Todd French
We had some out of town guests come to visit. They wanted a family style atmosphere and Italian. Nestico’s fits the bill. The food and service is great. We’ve been many times and they never disappoint.
… more
CarS
Four of us visited Nestico’s for the very first time on a recent Friday evening. We were seated quickly because the party ahead of us must have left. The menu was large and had many offerings from classic Italian dishes to rack of lamb which one of us had. Our waitress answered all our questions with ease and she was extremely knowledgeable about each dish we inquired about. A bottle of water and a tall glass of ice resided on our table for filling and refilling our water glasses. We all thought this was a great idea and surely must save the waitresses time and the patrons frustration from having to ask for refills all the time. The other 3 dishes ordered were veal parm, delmonico steak and spaghetti pie. All the dishes were very good and I should mention that the dishes that came with a side vegetable had a bonus in that the vegetables were cooked perfectly. No mushy overcooked veggies here! We’re planning on visiting again soon to try more delicious offerings.
… more
Kelsey Cesari
Negative stars if that were an option. We ordered to go, took the food home and the order was completely incorrect. We asked for gf pasta due to allergy, a $1.50 up charge, and chicken on Alfredo, $7 upcharge. We live over a half hour away, when we called the owner informed us we would need to bring the food back in to “verify the order was incorrect.” When we stated we didn’t live in the area, we were informed this is the only option to correct or refund for our food. So instead of refunding us $8.50, they have lost a customer for life. Great customer service…
… more
MB
Was a very good spot 20 years ago, but not so much anymore. It’s basically olive garden+ at fine dining prices. Not really sure why this has over a 4 star rating. My girlfriend’s cup was stained and filthy looking. Not that it was actually dirty, the glass was just old and plastic. This is a 25 dollar a meal place at a minimum, you’d think they could afford glass. We received 2 warm but frozen and heat in the oven garlic knots, our apps were basically buy frozen and toss in sauce after the oven, and my scallops and asparagus were drenched in a lemon butter sauce that tasted like they bought a packet from Wegmans and mixed it in water, not to mention the scallops were tiny. This isn’t Italian food and there’s plenty of places in Syracuse that do it so much better than here, go somewhere else.
… more
Lisa Bersani
Waitress was amazing! Food was very good and had plenty to bring home extra for the next day.
… more
… View more