Madfish Grill Menu - Sarasota, FL

What to do when a shabby bank ‘out East’ gets put on the Sarasota market? Restore it. And then? Fill it with locally sourced Caribbean and Creole flavors and transform it into the first locally owned, mom and pop seafood restaurant in the neighborhood. Then — as a final note — name it something a little outlandish like Madfish Grill.

Converted bank is an informal choice for locally sourced classic & contemporary seafood & steaks. Based on 891 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery

Madfish Grill 34233

Address:
4059 Cattlemen Rd, Sarasota, FL 34233

Phone: (941) 377-3474

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Saturday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Sunday	11 AM–8 PM
Monday (Labor Day)	11:30 AM–9 PM Hours might differ
Tuesday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11:30 AM–9 PM
Friday	11:30 AM–9 PM

MFG Party Platters
20 Wings	$34.90
30 Wings	$47.90
50 Wings	$74.90
6 Eggrolls	$19.90
12 Eggrolls	$35.90
18 Eggrolls	$53.90
24 Eggrolls	$67.90
Pulled Pork Priced per pound + side BBQ sauce	$16.90
Baby Back Ribs (Full Rack) dry rubbed ribs, house smoked, basted with our sweet & spicy BBQ sauce + an extra side of BBQ sauce!	$18.90
Smokehouse Sides 12 oz. container (feeds 2-4 people)… baked beans, cole slaw, black beans & rice, side sliced brioche buns (2 each)	$4.90
Cuban Night 4 half Cuban sandwiches, 12 oz each of black beans & rice, 1 large 4059 salad + 4059 dressing	$34.90
Build Your Own Tacos (12) lightly blackened mahi, lettuce, pico de gallo, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack + rice & black beans	$48.90
Retail
Hat	$18.00
Wine Cup	$18.00
Wine Glass	$8.00
Tall Cup With Straw	$18.00
T-Shirt QD or Cotton	$24.00
Holiday Shirt	$28.00
Long Sleeve Shirt	$30.00
Sweatshirt	$45.00
Dinner Menu
Jumbo Shrimp Cocktail House-made cocktail sauce and a wedge of lemon-priced per piece!	$2.90
Bacon & Eggs Deviled Eggs made w/ love + spicy sriracha drizzle	$6.90
Housemade Egg Rolls jerked chicken, rice, black beans, cilantro, cheese + guava jelly, avocado crema	$11.90
Jerk Glazed Wings jerk glazed chicken wings + creamy herb sauce(we apologize for the temporary price increase during the wing shortage)	$14.90
Coconut Shrimp Appetizer (5) coconut-crust + Guava Jelly	$14.90
Bang Shrimp Appetizer crispy wild-caught shrimp + sriracha bang sauce	$11.90
Chicken Potstickers fried artisan dumplings, gochujang aioli & soy drizzle	$9.90
Bourbon Glazed Shrimp Five bacon wrapped jumbo shrimp + sweet bourbon glaze	$13.90
Lobsterscargot Norway lobster meat, mushrooms, herb butter and topped with melted Swiss cheese.	$14.90
Ricotta Impastada creamy smooth whipped ricotta spreadblistered tomatoes, rosemary sea salt, local honeypraline pecan debris + grilled baguette	$12.90
Charred Brussel Sprouts miso glazed, exvoo, sea salt + sriracha aioli	$9.90
Shrimp & Lobster Cake Our famous crab cake recipe reimagined! Tender lobster & sweet shrimp cake + remoulade	$16.90
Parmesan Truffle Fries the ultimate indulgence… parmesan, garlic, white truffle oil sea salt, parsley + herb aioli	$9.90
BLT Wedge	$8.90
Side Madhouse Salad	$6.90
Side Caesar Salad	$6.90
Small Kale Caesar Salad Baby kale with creamy Caesar dressing, parmesan and house-made croutons.	$8.90
Side 4059 Cuban Salad	$7.90
Mangospacho
Vegetarian Black Bean & Rice
Drunken Lobster Bisque Sherry wine infused + basil oil
Crab & Corn Chowder
Blackened Gulf Grouper Sandwich lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar, brioche bun + fries (seasonally available)	$21.90
The Ultimate Cuban pressed ham, pork, swiss cheese, mustard, pickles + freshly baked cuban roll & fries	$15.90
Blackened Mahi Tacos spicy mahi, lettuce, pico, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack, rice & beans	$16.90
The Key West Fish Sandwich crunchy tempura battered scrod, cuban roll, lettuce, tomato, onion + fries	$16.90
Plant Based Burger 6 oz vegan patty, lettuce, tomato, onion + balsamic dressed greens. (gluten-free with no bun)	$16.90
Bang Lobster BLT crispy fried lobster, spicy bang sauce, bacon, lettuce & tomato + toasted sliced brioche	$18.90
Butcher’s Block Burger Chargrilled fresh ground beef from The Butcher’s Block on 17th St. (tell Scott that we sent you!)…. choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche bun + fries	$15.90
28 Day Dry Aged Burger 1/2 pound dry aged Brasstown Farms ribeyeshort rib burger, amish cheddar, brioche bunpecan wood bacon, frizzled onion	$18.90
Maine Lobster Roll 1/4 lb chilled lobster, lettuce, mayo, celery, griddled new england brioche roll, tartar + fries	$26.90
House Brined Corned Beef Reuben we use Ben’s Grandma Bridie’s recipe to produce our house made corned beef sliced thin and piled high with Swiss, sauerkraut, 1000 island, grilled marble rye + side	$16.90
Thai Salmon Bowl seared salmon, thai peanut sauce, chilled soba noodles, cilantro + sweet & spicy slaw	$17.90
Poke Tuna Bowl diced sushi-grade tuna, spicy hawaiian poke sauce, jasmine rice + avocado	$17.90
Bang Shrimp Bowl crispy wild gulf shrimp, bang sauce, fried rice, asian vegetables + cilantro	$16.90
Quesadilla Chopped Salad corn, tortilla strips, black beans cheddar-jack cheese, pico de gallo, avocado ranch, honey-balsamic vinaigrette, chopped romaine + cheese quesadilla	$12.90
Sarasota Kale Salad kale, strawberries, chevre, candied pecans + balsamic vinaigrette with your choice of protein	$14.90
St. Croix Shrimp Salad our cult favorite! coconut shrimp, greens, mango, pineapple, yuca, blue cheese crumbles + mandarin dressing	$19.90
Mad Thai edamame, onions, peppers, carrots, fried egg, cilantro, toasted peanuts + spicy panang peanut sauce, rice noodles
Large 4059 Cuban Salad iceberg, ham, swiss, parmesan, tomato, green olives, cuban vinaigrette	$12.90
Hand Battered Fish & Chips wild caught domestic cod, fries, tartar sauce & lemon	$18.90
Pan Seared Cod wild-caught cod, fresh lemon, olive oil & butter sauteed spinach + mashed potatoes	$21.90
Sweet Bourbon Glazed Salmon roasted Atlantic salmon, sweet bourbon glaze + broccoli & mashed potatoes (Gf without bourbon sauce)	$25.90
Grouper Chimichanga Gulf grouper, jasmine rice, chipotle crema, cheddar-jack, wrapped in a soft flour tortilla, smothered with lobster sherry cream, pico de gallo + choice of side	$22.90
Lobster & Shrimp Cakes two decadent lobster & shrimp cakes pan fried, our signature remoulade sauce on the side with jasmine rice + broccoli	$26.90
Filet Medallions Trio of pan seared filet medallions, mashed potatoes + broccoli	$27.90
Coco Mac Chicken pan-fried coconut-macadamia crusted chicken mango-chili sauce, jasmine rice + broccoli	$19.90
Martha’s Vineyard Chicken sauteed chicken breast, goat cheese-citrus beurre blanc, grape tomatoes, spinach,broccoli + jasmine rice	$19.90
8oz Filet Mignon chargrilled 8oz beef tenderloin, mashed potatoes + broccoli	$42.90
Peking Chicken amazingly juicy, roasted half chicken, sticky honey-soy beer glaze, jasmine rice + broccoli	$20.90
Cheshire Heritage Pork house brined center cut heritage pork loinmashed potatoes + broccoli	$22.90
Prime Tomahawk Ribeye (Bone-In) 36oz bone in prime Angus ribeye, caramelized vidalia onion, mashed potatoes + broccoli	$69.90
Ravioli Martinique hand made lobster ravioli topped with sauteed shrimp, bay scallopstomato-basil cream + parmesan	$32.90
Todd’s Curry Glazed Salmon pan seared, curry sauce glazed , served with broccoli & mashed potatoes -Todd, a Sarasota local and long time regular customer created this amazing sauce.	$26.90
Side-Homemade Chips Served with creamy-herb aioli dip on the side	$3.90
Side-Edamame Rice	$3.90
Side-Black Beans And Rice	$2.90
Side-Mashed Potatoes	$3.90
Side-French Fries	$3.90
Side-Cole Slaw	$2.90
Side-Plantains	$6.90
Side-Grilled Asparagus	$5.90
Side-Jasmine Rice	$2.90
Side-Steamed Broccoli	$3.90
Side-Sauteed Spinach	$3.90
Side-Dilled Carrots	$3.90
Side-Frizzled Onion Strings Onion strings hand dredged in flour and crispy fried to order	$3.90
Side-Truffle Fries	$5.90
Side- Onion Rings (4)	$5.90
Fresh Catch
Mahi Mahi	$26.90
Gulf Red Grouper	$32.90
Chilean Seabass	$38.90
Cod	$21.90
Whole Belly Clams ipswich whole belly clams + fries with tartar sauce and coleslaw	$34.90
Hogfish	$36.90
Lobster Tail 5oz coldwater lobster tail
Atlantic Salmon
Lunch Menu
Pick Any 2 Pairings – Pick Any 2 – no sides included	$11.90
4059 Salad iceberg, ham, swiss, parmesan, tomato, green olives, cuban vinaigrette
MFG Chicken Cobb Salad fried chicken, bacon, pico de gallo, boiled egg, cheddar-jack, lettuce + honey mustard vinaigrette (Gf when ordered with grilled chicken)	$16.90
Asian Chicken Salad lettuce, cabbage, carrots, bell pepper, cilantro, edamame, wontons, sesame seeds, chicken + spicy thai peanut dressing	$16.90
Quesadilla Chopped Salad corn, tortilla strips, black beans cheddar-jack cheese, pico de gallo, avocado ranch, honey-balsamic vinaigrette, chopped romaine + cheese quesadilla	$12.90
Sarasota Kale Salad Grilled chicken breast, baby kale, candied pecans strawberries, chevre + balsamic dressing	$16.90
Kale Caesar baby kale, parmesan cheese, caesar dressing, house-made croutons	$12.90
St. Croix Shrimp Salad our cult favorite! coconut shrimp, greens, mango, pineapple, yuca, blue cheese crumbles + mandarin dressing	$19.90
Chicken Salad Plate chicken salad, celery, tomato crown + fresh fruit	$15.90
Poke Bowl diced tuna, spicy poke sauce, warm jasmine rice + avocado	$17.90
Thai Salmon Bowl seared salmon, thai peanut sauce, chilled soba noodles, cilantro + sweet & spicy slaw	$16.90
Bang Shrimp Bowl crispy wild gulf shrimp, bang sauce, fried rice, asian vegetables + cilantro	$16.90
The Chicken Mad Thai Bowl pad thai rice noodles, naturally raised chicken, edamame, onions, peppers, carrots, fried egg cilantro, toasted peanuts + spicy panang sauce	$15.90
Soup Of The Day
Mangospacho
Vegetarian Black Bean & Rice
Drunken Lobster Bisque Sherry wine infused + basil oil
Crab & Corn Chowder
Maine Lobster Roll our New England heritage-1/4 pound chilled lobster, mayo, celery & lettuce, griddled split top brioche roll + fries	$26.90
House Brined Corned Beef Reuben Using Ben’s grandma Birdie’s recipe to produce use house made corned beef sliced thin and piled high with Swiss, sauerkraut 1000 island, grilled marble rye + fries	$16.90
MADcuban pressed ham, pork, swiss cheese, mustard, pickles + freshly baked cuban roll	$13.90
Turkey Rachael turkey breast, swiss cheese, coleslaw, russian dressing + grilled rye bread	$14.90
The Key West Fish Sandwich crunchy tempura battered scrod, cuban roll, lettuce, tomato, onion + fries	$16.90
Blackened Grouper Sandwich gulf grouper, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar + brioche bun	$19.90
Bang Lobster BLT crispy fried lobster, spicy bang sauce, bacon, lettuce & tomato + toasted sliced brioche	$18.90
Butcher’s Block Burger Chargrilled fresh ground beef from The Butcher’s Block on 17th St. (tell Scott that we sent you!)…. choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche bun + fries	$14.90
28 Day Dry Aged Burger 1/2 pound dry aged Brasstown Farms ribeyeshort rib burger, amish cheddar, brioche bunpecan wood bacon, frizzled onion	$17.90
Plant Based Burger 6 oz vegan patty, lettuce, tomato, onion + balsamic dressed greens. (gluten-free with no bun)	$15.90
MadFish Cobia Burger Perfect for the warmer weather…our Open Blue cobia burger is sustainably raised, has more Omega 3 acids than salmon & is arguably the most delicious burger on this menu!Brioche bun, kosher dill tartar saucelettuce, tomato, onion	$16.90
Blackened Mahi Tacos spicy mahi, lettuce, pico, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack, rice & beans	$14.90
Bang Shrimp Tacos fried shrimp in a spicy bang sauce, lettuce, pico, cilantro slaw, chipotle aioli, cheddar-jack, rice & beans	$14.90
Crispy Chicken Tacos Crispy fried chicken thigh, lettuce, avocado crema, pico de gallo, cheddar-jack, rice & beans	$12.90
Fish N Chips hand-battered & fried + fries and tartar
Caribbean Eggrolls chicken, rice, black beans, cilantro, cheese + guava jelly, avocado ranch	$11.90
Our Famous Quiche & Fruit
Build Your Own Omelette two eggs + choice of 3: cheddar-jack, swiss, gouda, tomato, mushroom spinach, bacon, ham or turkey + wheat toast & fruit	$12.90
Side-Black Beans And Rice	$2.90
Side-Cole Slaw	$2.90
Side-Edamame Rice	$3.90
Side-Dilled Carrots	$3.90
Side-Grilled Asparagus	$6.90
Side-Homemade Chips Served with creamy-herb aioli dip on the side	$3.90
Side-Jasmine Rice	$2.90
Side-Plantains	$6.90
Side-French Fries	$3.90
Side-Fruit	$3.90
Side-Sauteed Spinach	$3.90
Side-Broccoli	$3.90
Side-Truffle Fries	$5.90
Sunday Brunch (10:30am-2pm)
The American Benedict poached eggs, english muffin, pecan wood bacon, tomato + hollandaise sauce	$12.90
Black Forest Eggs Benedict poached eggs, english muffin, bavarian ham, + hollandaise sauce	$12.90
Mediterranean Omelette fresh eggs, spinach, blistered tomatoes, goat cheese + toast	$13.90
Three Little Piggies Omelette fresh eggs, sausage, country ham, bacon, smoked gouda, scallion + toast	$13.90
Huevos Rancheros two fried eggs, crispy corn tortillas lettuce, pico de gallo, black beans, cheese + home fries, fruit or cheddar-jack grits	$12.90
Classic Ham And Swiss Omelette ham & swiss + toast and side	$13.90
The Hippy Omelette egg whites, spinach, portabello mushroom, blistered tomatoes, smoked gouda, basil + toast	$13.90
Breakfast Burrito fluffy eggs, sausage, cheddar jack & pico de gallo wrapped in a warm flour tortilla + salsa & sour cream	$13.90
Almond Crust French Toast crunchy almond-cinnamon crust breakfast syrup, bacon or sausage	$11.90
Homemade Belgian Waffle made to order, warm & fluffywhipped cream, breakfast syrup+ bacon or sausage	$11.90
Chicken And Waffles fried boneless chicken, scandinavian sugar waffle, pecan wood smoked bacon, hot honey drizzle	$14.90
Lobster And Shrimp Cake Benedict house made lobster and shrimp cake, poached eggs, English muffin + pesto hollandaise + side	$18.90
Breakfast Tacos Flour Tortillas, Scrambled Eggs, Bacon, Cheddar, Pico De Gallo, Sour Cream, Salsa + Avacado	$14.90
Three Cheese Quiche & Fruit decadent homemade three cheese quiche + fresh fruit	$11.90
Shrimp & Lobster Quiche lobster, shrimp & fresh spinach baked in our signature quiche recipe + fruit	$16.90
Deconstructed Salmon Platter pastrami style smoked salmon, tomato, caper, pickled onion, fresh cucumber, tender greens, cream cheese + everything bagel	$16.90
Scramble Bowl Scrambled eggs, bacon, cheddar cheese over home fries, sausage gravy, scallion + toast	$12.90
Southern Comfort Breakfast Two eggs your style, scratch biscuit, sausage gravy grilled ham steak + cheddar-jack grits	$12.90
Myakka Benedict Poached eggs over scratch biscuits, sausage gravy, tomato & pecanwood bacon	$12.90
Southern Shrimp & Grits garlicky sauteed shrimp, jalapeno, tomato, onion & cilantro served over warm grits	$16.90
Avocado Toast mashed avocado, sea salt, xvoo, pickled onions, rye toast points (add eggs + $3)	$9.90
Pancakes Made to order, Warm and Fluffy, Breakfast Syrup + Bacon Sausage	$12.90
Tina’s Waffle Sweet & Savory… Bacon-Pecan Praline Crumble, Salted Caramel Drizzle +Whipped Cream	$14.90
Side Biscuits & Gravy (2) two warm biscuits + home made sausage gravy	$6.90
Maine Lobster Roll 1/4 lb chilled lobster, lettuce, mayo, celery, griddled new england brioche roll, tartar + fries	$26.90
MADcuban pressed ham, pork, swiss cheese, mustard, pickles + freshly baked cuban roll	$12.90
Large 4059 Cuban Salad iceberg, ham, swiss, parmesan, tomato, green olives, cuban vinaigrette	$12.90
The Key West Fish Sandwich crunchy tempura battered scrod, cuban roll, lettuce, tomato, onion + fries	$16.90
Butcher’s Block Burger Chargrilled fresh ground beef from The Butcher’s Block on 17th St. (tell Scott that we sent you!)…. choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche bun + fries	$15.90
Blackened Grouper Sandwich gulf grouper, lettuce, tomato, onion, tartar + brioche bun	$19.90
Plant Based Burger 6 oz vegan patty, lettuce, tomato, onion + balsamic dressed greens. (gluten-free with no bun)	$16.90
House Brined Corned Beef Reuben Using Ben’s grandma Birdie’s recipe to produce use house made corned beef sliced thin and piled high with Swiss, sauerkraut 1000 island, grilled marble rye + fries	$15.90
Fish N Chips hand-battered & fried + fries and tartar
Bang Lobster BLT crispy fried lobster, spicy bang sauce, bacon, lettuce & tomato + toasted sliced brioche	$17.90
St Croix Shrimp Salad coco mac shrimp, greens, mango, pineapple, yucca chips, bleu cheese crumbles + mandarin ginger dressing	$19.90
Salmon Sarasota Salad grilled salmon, kale, strawberries, chevre, candied pecans + balsamic vinaigrette	$22.90
Corned Beef Tater Kegs (4) Served with reuben sauce	$4.90
Taco Tuesday (all day)
TT-Margarita house margarita with corazon blanco, agave + fresh lemon & lime	$5.90
Rita’s Sangria house-made red sangria, brandy, fresh fruit + rocks	$9.90
TT-Chips & Salsa thin, crispy corn tortilla + homemade salsa	$4.90
TT-Guacamole & Chips crispy tortilla chips with homemade guacamole (includes a small salsa, too)	$10.90
Chips & Queso Blanco Dip thin, crispy corn tortilla chips + queso!	$10.90
MadTacos (2 Taco Minimum Per Person) choose any 2 of the following: $5.90 each(made with flour tortillas…corn tortillas are upon request)The OG (Mahi)-seasoned mahi, chipotle aioli, cilantro slaw, shredded lettuce, cheddar jack + pico de galloCarnitas-authentic slow cooked pork carnitas, cilantro, onion + jalapenoChicken Tinga-pulled chicken thigh stewed in mildly spicy tomato sauce with onion + shredded lettuceCarne Asada-diced tenderloin, guacamole, Mexican spices, chopped onion + cilantroPork Al Pastor-tender pork, fresh pineapple, cilantro + pickled red onionCrispy Chicken-crispy fried chicken thigh, lettuce, avocado crema, pico + cheddar jack*Bang Shrimp-spicy fried shrimp, spicy bang sauce, chipotle aioli, cilantro slaw, shredded lettuce, cheddar jack + pico de gallo
Burrito Grande rice, black beans, cheddar jack, sour cream, pico de gallo, guacamole + choice of protein	$14.90
Rice Bowl rice, black beans, pico de gallo, sour cream, cheddar jack cheese, guacamole + choice of protein	$14.90
Quesadilla flour tortilla stuffed with cheddar jack cheese, green onion & sour cream and salsa + choice of protein	$14.90
Flan Creamy custard + caramel sauce	$9.90
MAD Italiano (after 4pm wed only!)
Italian Salad iceberg, cucumber, tomato, pepperoncinishredded mozzarella + house italian vinaigrette	$5.90
Maditaliano Mussels one pound-white wine, roasted garlic cream + parsley	$10.90
Garlic Bread Sticks (5) soft bread sticks, warm garlic-herb butter + marinara dipping sauce	$6.90
Pepperoni Pizzetta crispy flatbread, garlic, pepperoni, mozzarella cheese + red sauce	$9.90
Spaghetti And Balls giant house made meatballs, Grandma’s Sunday sauce, spaghetti + parmesan cheese	$14.90
Tortellini Florentine tender cheese tortellini, spinach, blistered tomatoes, creamy alfredo + parmesan cheese	$15.90
Chicken Parmesan breaded chicken thigh cutlet, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese + spaghetti	$16.90
Salmon Piccata tender cuts of salmon, lemon caper sauce jasmine rice + broccoli	$17.90
Veal Parmesan breaded veal cutlet, marinara sauce, mozzarella cheese + spaghetti	$19.90
Shrimp Scampi sauteed shrimp, garlic, butter, wine, lemon, blistered tomatoes, fresh herbs + spaghetti(Gf over jasmine rice)	$18.90
Bete Noir a classic flourless dark chocolate cake, white chocolate drizzle + raspberry sauce	$7.90
Rita’s Tiramisu Martini vanilla vodka, amaretto, Kahlua	$14.90
NY Cheesecake served with fresh berries	$9.90
Tiramisu mascarpone cream, espresso soaked lady fingers topped with cocoa powder	$9.90
Burger Night (available after 4PM Thursday only!)
House Fried Pickles Deep fried pickle chips with a side of creamy chipotle dip	$7.90
Warm Pretzels & Beer Cheese soft pretzel sticks + beer cheese	$11.90
Hand Battered Onion Rings (5) Zesty petal sauce	$7.90
Blue Cheese Chips house potato chips, blue cheese fondue, balsamic glaze drizzle + scallions	$9.90
Cheese-A-Saurus Doesn’t get cheddar than this!White american +cheddar jack crusted bun	$10.90
Siesta Burger sliced avocado, tomato, red onion, + green goddess aioli	$11.90
Cowboy Burger smoky bbq, cheddar, bacon, frizzled onions	$12.90
The GOAT blackberry preserves, goat cheese + caramelized onions	$12.90
Black & Bleu blackened, with blue cheese, chipotle ranch + frizzled onions	$12.90
Jalapeno Popper white american, bacon jam + house pickled jalapenos	$12.90
Rueben Burger swiss cheese, sauerkraut + 1000 island dressing	$12.90
Surf + Turf topped with bang bang lobster	$16.90
MadFish Cobia Burger Perfect for the warmer weather…our Open Blue cobia burger is sustainably raised, has more Omega 3 acids than salmon & is arguably the most delicious burger on this menu!Brioche bun, kosher dill tartar saucelettuce, tomato, onion	$16.90
28 Day Dry Aged Burger 1/2 pound dry aged Brasstown Farms ribeyeshort rib burger, amish cheddar, brioche bunpecan wood bacon, frizzled onion	$18.90
Plant Based Burger 6 oz vegan patty, lettuce, tomato, onion + balsamic dressed greens. (gluten-free with no bun)	$16.90
Butcher’s Block Burger Chargrilled fresh ground beef from The Butcher’s Block on 17th St. (tell Scott that we sent you!)…. choice of cheese, lettuce, tomato, onion, brioche bun + fries	$15.90
Hand Battered Chicken & Chips beer battered cuts of chicken breast, fries + tartar sauce	$16.90
Irish Salmon In Cream Sauce tender cuts of salmon baked in foil with fresh herbs & light cream sauce over fettuccini	$17.90
Dessert & Coffee
Bete Noir a classic flourless dark chocolate cake, white chocolate drizzle + raspberry sauce	$9.90
Creme Brulee Classic vanilla bean	$9.90
Key Lime Pie A quintessential Florida favorite graham cracker crust + whipped cream	$9.90
Chocolate Bourbon Pecan Pie To die for secret recipe + whipped cream	$9.90
Abuela’s Housemade Flan decadent, creamy custard + caramel sauce	$9.90
Crispy Bread Pudding Bites Challah bread, lightly fried with vanilla bean ice cream, whipped cream + salted caramel	$10.90
Homemade Brownie Batter Lava Cake warm molten chocolate cake, vanilla ice cream + whipped cream	$10.90
Happy Hour Daily
Well Drinks
Select Draft Beer
House Wine
Wine, Beer & Spirits
Ruffino, Prosecco, Italy
Vueve-Clicquot Yellow Label, Champagne
Cava Brut, CVNE, Spain
Stella; Moscato, Italy
Rioja Blanco Seco, Monopole Viura, Spain
Pinot Grigio, Capasaldo
Riesling, Chateau St Michelle, California
Kim Crawford, Marlborough, New Zealand
Brancott, New Zealand
Kendall Jackson, California
J Lohr, Monterey
Sonoma Cutrer, Russian River
Unoaked, Sylvaine & Alaine Normand, France
Rose, Gris De Gris, France
Malbec, Catena, Argentina
Merlot, Alexander Valley, CA
Red Zinfandel, Seghesio, Sonoma, CA
Red Blend, 22 Pirates, Central Coast
Meiomi, California
La Crema, Sonoma
Williamette Valley Vineyards, Oregon
Row Eleven, Russian River the unanimous favorite new red wine for our staff!
Bread And Butter, Napa Valley
Beringer, Knights Valley
Hall, Napa Valley
Silver Oak, Alexander Valley
Austin Hope, Paso Robles Bob & Kelly’s new favorite!!
Falcone, Paso Robles	$65.00
Graham’s, Ruby Port	$9.90
Fonseca, Bin No 27 Ruby Reserve	$10.90
Sandeman’s 20 Yr Tawny Port	$13.90
Seasonal Mule- Red & Blue Berry blue-raspberry vodka, ginger beer, lime & fresh bluberries	$12.90
Rita’s Sangria house-made red sangria, brandy, fresh fruit + rocks	$10.90
Lavendar Bramble gin, house infused lavender syrup, fresh lemon, muddled blackberries & mint + rocks	$14.90
Empress French 75 Empress pea flower gin, lemon juice, simple syrup, prosecco + sugar rim	$14.90
Jade Cocktail coconut rum, melon liquor + pineapple king cube	$14.90
Pina Colada Cooler Malibu rum, coconut water, pineapple juice + rocks	$14.90
Blood Orange Martini cathead bitter orange vodka, fresh blood orange juice + cranberry served up	$14.90
Blueberry Lemon Drop Martini Frankly lemon-basil vodka, muddled blueberries, house made blueberry simple + sugar rim, served up	$14.90
MADcosmo cathead bitter orange vodka, cointreau, fresh lime + cranberry	$14.90
Citrus Spritzer citrus vodka, prosecco, elderflower liquor, fresh lemon + ice	$14.90
Classic Espresso-Tini vanilla vodka, borghetti coffee liquor + fresh brewed espresso	$14.90
Watermelon Jalapeno Margarita fresh watermelon, jalapeno syrup, tequila blanco, fresh lime, ice + sugar rim	$14.90
Ranch Water Casamigos Reposado, soda water + lime	$14.90
As The Fish Turns bourbon, sake, ginger liquor, orange bitters + king cube	$14.90
Chocolate Old Fashioned bourbon, orange & chocolate bitters, king cube + chocolate dipped orange slice	$14.90
Key-Lime Pie Martini fresh key lime juice, vanilla vodka, Liquor 43, cream + graham cracker crust	$14.90
Cherry Blossom-Tini sake, cranberry juice, Cointreau, fresh lime + orange bitters	$14.90
Strawberry Shortcake-Tini Bailey’s strawberry cream, birthday cake vodka, cream + fresh strawberries	$14.90
Circus City IPA	$7.25
Turbid 7 New England IPA	$7.25
Blue Point Toasted Lager	$6.00
Prosecco On Tap-Glass	$6.90
Michelob Ultra	$6.00
Bud Light	$6.00
Stella Artois	$7.25
Sailfish Tag And Release Amber	$7.25
Blue Moon Belgian Wheat	$6.75
Corona	$6.50
Corona Light	$6.50
Guinness	$8.00
Newcastle	$7.00
Sam Adams	$7.00
Yuengling	$6.25
Bud	$6.00
Dragon Stout	$6.75
Coors Light	$6.00
Miller Lite	$6.00
Angry Orchard Gluten-Free Cider	$6.25
Beck’s NA	$4.25
Family Night Take Out Only
Taco Tuesday Kit (Available Tuesday Nights Only) eight flour tortillas with toppings on the side: lettuce, cheese, cilantro slaw, pico de gallo, salsa, sour cream, avocado ranch & chipotle sauce. Choice of protein: Pork Carnitas OR Chicken Tinga	$39.00
Pub Burger Kit (Available Thursday Nights Only) Four char-grilled pub burgers, Amish cheddar, brioche buns + lettuce, tomato, pickle, onion and fries -OR- steamed broccoli (must select one temperature)	$39.00
Cuban Night (Only Available Monday – Thursday Nights) our famous family meal is back! 2 cuban sandwiches, plantains, black bean soup with rice & 4059 salad	$39.00
Pasta Wednesday ( Available Only Wednesdays) Choice of Chicken Parmesan OR Spaghetti & Meatballs ORSpaghetti & Marinara for 4Italian Salad for 44 Breadsticks	$39.00
Family Style Egg Rolls Jerk chicken, cheddar-jack, rice, black beans and cilantro + guava jelly and avocado ranch on the side (1/2 dozen)	$24.00
Family Style MadHouse Salad (Bread Not Included) tomatoes, pepitas, yuca chips + mandarin ginger dressing	$20.00
Family Style Caesar Salad (Bread Not Included) garlic croutons, shaved parmesan, creamy dressing	$20.00
Family Style 4059 Salad (Bread Not Included) iceberg, ham, swiss, parmesan, tomato, green olives, cuban vinaigrette	$26.00
Family Style Mashed Potatoes(After 4pm)	$12.00
Family Style Jasmine Rice	$8.00
Family Style Broccoli	$12.00
Family Style Asparagus	$20.00
Bread Loaf & Bread Dip dozen	$10.00
Kids Menu
Kid Popcorn Shrimp Six fried shrimp + one side	$10.90
Kids Fish Tacos Two fried fish tacos with shredded lettuce cheese & sour cream + one side	$10.90
Kids Filet grilled tenderloin medallions (2)	$18.90
Kids Hamburger Fresh ground chuck, cooked well done + one side	$9.90
Kids Chicken Fingers Deep fried breaded chicken + ranch or honey mustard & one side	$9.90
Kids Grilled Cheese American cheese on toasted wheat bread + one side	$7.90
Kids Hand Battered Fish & Chips Wild-caught domestic scrod, fries + tartar sauce	$9.90
Kids Mac And Cheese The classic – Kraft mac and cheese	$7.90
Kids Mac And Chicken Classic Kraft mac and cheese topped with a diced chicken breast	$10.90
Kids Pasta	$7.90
Kids Atlantic Salmon Or Cod grilled or tempura fried + one side dish
Coca Cola	$3.49
Sprite	$3.49
Mr. Pibb	$3.49
Lemonade	$3.49
Shirley Temple	$3.49
Cranberry Juice	$3.90
Orange Juice	$3.90
Apple Juice	$3.90
Pineapple Juice	$3.90
IBC Root Beer	$3.90

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Amber Sanchez

I recently tried out Madfish Grill for the first time and was exceptionally pleased with the experience. I was wondering if I would find anything I like, as my children are the seafood lovers and I am not. Our server, Joe, suggested that I try their flat iron steak and I was quite pleased with the seasoning and it came cooked medium rare, just as I had requested. I also was delighted to see that truffle fries were on the menu, which seems to be a rare find. They came with a dill sauce that was to die for. The broccoii was brilliantly seasoned and cooked perfectly. To top it all off the bread came with a unique fresh garlic and olive oil dip which teased my tasted buds. Joe suggested some delicious desserts for my kids and they made a special ending to our visit. I will be sure to return again anytime we visit the Sarasota area

… more

Kristine Fitts

I met two girlfriends for an Al fresco dinner on a Thursday night. The weather was perfect to sit outside on the patio. Our server was Joe who was friendly and attentive. Right before dusk, the flies showed up but Joe turned on the fans and away they went. I loved their wine list. Far more interesting than most other area restaurants I’ve visited. The menu was good but that’s where the one star deduction comes from. I prefer more healthy vegetable options. The bathroom was immaculate (always a good sign) and the ambiance was easy going. I will definitely return.

… more

Yuniam Santana

Food was good. We were sitting at the bar area and it was a Friday night so the service was a little slow at some points but good. Servers were eager to please and pleasant despite being busy. It wasn’t noisy as some other places may be when at the table tops by the bar.

… more

Tammy Ranney

Any day is a good day for happy hour at MFG. Rita’s latest and greatest concoction, the skinny piña colada on the rocks. Delicious! Light and vibrant with coconut water. Ben and Company always aim to please with innovative and rotating menus and seasonal cocktails. Great menu and great staff. We love the Madfish Grill.

… more

Sarah Brockie

This place is absolutely amazing❤️

… more

The Oculist

Went here with my grandmother and was expecting another mediocre Florida seafood experience. Every other restaurant I have been to down there does not know how to cook fish, shrimp, anything really. NOT this place. The fish is always flaky and juicy and fresh tasting. The vegetables are perfect. Everything tastes and feels perfect. I haven’t had drinks here, but I imagine they are good as well. I can’t recommend enough. Whatever they are doing, they are doing it right.

… more

Liz Fisher

I may have reviewed it already, but it deserves repeating. This is a gem of a place. When I asked the manger which platform to post my review he said they were busy enough. I know that could sound wrong to some, so to clarify, it was 5 pm on Wednesday and the place was packed. Food is very good with fresh seafood and original dishes. If you’re traveling, it’s a short hop off of I 75.

… more

DANZA1147

Came here at 615 pm and left at 750 pm. My wife and I were here on vacation and are Hispanic. I felt like we were discriminated against. They took for ever to take our order. They never bought are food out. When we asked for the check, all of a sudden our food was ready. I’m confused because everyone was getting they’re food. Yeah, Kevin was rude, the rudest person I ever met. I believe he said “these people” which sucks because we were excited to try this place.

… more

Depot Village

One of our favorite restaurants to go to on our way to the Drum Circle at Siesta Key, we highly recommend the chicken wings!

… more

Kimberly Bolton

I’m 50/50. I’ve only been for brunch FYI. I went to brunch for a regular brunch about a year ago and it was AMAZING! Best Grits and continuous mimosas I’ve ever had. We decided that based on that experience we would do the Mother’s Day Brunch. This was not as good unfortunately. Service was scarce. Our “appetizer” of deviled eggs was more of a desert because we had to remind them of that order twice and they arrived after our main courses. I ordered the chicken and waffle. The chicken was the same as my child’s chicken strips (kids meal) and the waffle was over cooked and dry. The pickles on the side were plain not special hamburger pickles. The grits were amazing though..

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Madfish Grill Menu – Sarasota, FL

Hours

Menu

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions