Upscale, intimate bar & restaurant serving steaks & seafood, plus beer, wine & cocktails. Based on 882 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
3667 WI-42, Fish Creek, WI 54212
Phone: (920) 868-3532
Website: http://alexandersofdoorcounty.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 4–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 4–8:30 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Manny
With Easter traffic, my group had made reservations, and thankfully the hosts could fit two additional last-minute guests (don’t try to do this). We were seated promptly and without any issues. We all were exceptionally pleased with the service and quality of the fare. From the salad bar, breakfast bar, and dessert tables. Scrumptious and flavorful are two words to illustrate how the brunch tasted! Delighted with the service, from prompt refills, dish removal, and bill/check delivery. Everyone was professional, and no mishaps or lack of assistance was observed. We will return here in the future to try other days, breakfast, lunch, and dinner!
… more
Dmitriy Fridlyand
A good fine dining place. Atmospheric, good selection of food and wines for the area. Depending on choices, expect $50+ per person. The food is worth it though. Stuffed mushrooms and white fish were the best to my taste. Service was excellent. Reservation is recommended on the weekend. We came around 5.30 on Sunday and the place was crowded when we left at 7.
… more
Trucking With kingfish (Trucking with kingfish)
Everything here was top shelf, the servers flew thru the dining room with amazing speed and no water glass went dry, the baked Brie was something I’ve never encountered before and now I wonder why, the cherry bbq salmon was complex the salmon was tender the bbq was tangy and the cherry was sweet all three flavors were blended well yet still stood out it was something I never would’ve thought to make but I’m glad someone did and I was able to try it out, bottom line I would gladly go back
… more
Patricia Katzman
We are back! Staying in Door County for 1 week & so glad to be able to eat at our favorite restaurant again. Beautiful time of year to still be able to enjoy the Christmas lights. Started out with a cocktail & friendly service by Elliott. Warm French bread arrived at our table soon after being seated. We had our favorite,outstanding, Escargot as our appetizer. Decided to share the King Cut Prime Rib which was cooked medium to our liking. The mixed green Salad was perfect. Our entree came with a side of Au Graten Potatoes & mixed String Beans. Service was impeccable & friendly by our server Gabby. We are from Appleton & It is always a treat to be able to enjoy a night out at Alexanders.
… more
Tiona Terry
This place is outstanding. The bartenders, the server, the food- all of it is excellent. I’ve been going here for over 20 years, and it never disappoints! My favorites are the Bri puff pastry, the delicious crustini bread, and the warm decadent chocolate cake.
… more
Bryce Heth
This place is incredible. From the food, to the service, to the cocktails, we could not have been more impressed. We did the Valentine’s Day special which included appetizers, a salad or soup, an entrée, a drink and a dessert and felt the value was awesome. We will be back for special occasions!
… more
Drew
We went to Alexander’s for our anniversary and were sincerely delighted. From the absolutely exceptional attention and service from Juana, to the exquisite quality and accuracy of our orders, a second to none experience. The server assistant in the section was also quite skilled and efficient, assisting the server both with service and turning tables rapidly.
… more
Karlie
Was able to get a reservation after trying to call multiple times (this seems to be a common issue with other posts). The host, (older man with an accent) was not friendly on the phone or very friendly in person.
… more
Chad Smith
I have to say that this was my favorite dining experience ever. Everything was outstanding, the wife and I are already discussing how we could get back up there for dinner.
… more
Robyn P.
The environment is beautiful. It was a bit loud but a beautiful place with amazing service. The food was also amazing. My husband and I both had steaks and were not disappointed. It was one of the best steaks I’ve had in wisconsin. I would definitely recommend going by if you have a chance. You will not be disappointed.
… more
… View more