Based on 74 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
508 Old Toll Rd, Madison, CT 06443
Phone: (203) 421-2577
Website: http://jamesmadisonhouse.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–11 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–11 PM |
Photo Gallery
Reviews
J Willow
Went there 1st time and last time.. we sat at the bar, since no one greets you when you walk in. The bartenders ignored us after we got out drinks and closed the menus, had to ask them if was could order food. My chicken with a basil cream sauce was horrible, so rubbery and the cream sauce was broken and separated into butter and what looked like cottage cheese. I was very hungry so I chewed threw 1 piece and ate the COLD mashed potatoes,. So sad what the broccoli had NO seasons not even salt and pepper.. I see now why they are always hiring a saute cook on Craigslist,. Not the best spot to hire a cook. The bartenders were busy brown noising 3 locals they both spent all there time with them chatting about booze and wine, what a joke. We never got asked how our food was because they know it sucked, we also had to ask for the bill about 20 minutes after we pushed our plates towards the bar edge. Some lady came out and poured herself a bunch of wine,. Right to the top, not like the 1/2 glasses they sell. Must of been a owner, anyway she looked at my 1/2 eaten dinner and me but never asked if something was wrong.. Closing soon!!!!!!!!.
… more
Bubbys Daughter
Stopped in to check out the new house & grab a bite to eat. Tried the garlic steak & cheese sandwich which was great. We sat at the huge horseshoe shaped bar, it felt kind of like Cheers with Kris-Ann shaking it up behind the bar. Great experience. We’ll be back!
… more
Dan Zapix
Came here with a group of friends for lunch. The person working was friendly and accommodating. Food was decent and everyone enjoyed theirs. My only complaint would be that it was a bit dark, but it get the impression it’s more focused on being a bar with a menu than restaurant with a bar. In 2023, that’s understandable. Would definitely go back.
… more
lumpum
If you can find a table on certain days you’ll be lucky. Ya the food is awesome. Top notch for a bar. When there is a band or musical act, there is absolutely zero chance for a conversation. Way to loud and not enough places to avoid it.
… more
Robin Desjardins
Incredible food, bar and staff! I love the James Madison House!
… more
terhi alford
These guys really knocked it out of the park! As someone whose been, “in the industry”, for 20+ years, I feel pretty comfortable sizing a place up. For me- these guys nailed it on ALL fronts. They have a fantastic whiskey and beer list. Every dish I have tried has been full of FLAVOR, and honestly some pretty unique flavors, at that. Salmon sandwich! All of the staff have been fun, warm, and down to earth. I’m pretty sure I saw the owners, and it is very clear they do not hesitate to dig in and work hard right along with their staff. Really great addition to the area and awesome job to all of you!
… more
West Haven
Love this one place. We came on a rainy Sunday and it was a great experience. Steve was our waiter and he was excellent-friendly, informative and just a great guy. We had the soup special- broccoli and cheese-it was home made and delicious. Next were the nachos with chicken-loved them and the chicken quesadillas-just spicy enough with plenty of chicken. We ended with the brisket and cheese grinder- just delicious. The boutique beer (Whaler’s rise ) was great and the wine was exactly right.
… more
elena ford
Went to JMH after a nice 5 mi hike at Chatfield Hallow State Park. The service was amazing and speedy! It was our first time and we were lucky enough to get Steve as our waiter. This man is amazing! He truly cares about his service. The truffle fries were one of the best I’ve ever had. Absolutely lovely meal. 100/10
… more
Krissie Sward
Don’t Walk…RUN to this new Eatery! The wings and cheese board were delicious, the presentation was perfect. The burgers were mouthwatering, & chicken sandwich was yummy. Top it off I applaud the staff, their smiles were contagious. Owners Angela & Frank (an awesome couple)took the time to speak with us & made you feel right at home. We found our new happy place, and cant wait to go back. Bravo
… more
Angie Alaconis
Possibly the worst restaurant experience I’ve had. From walking in and not being greeted for 10 minutes, to waiting another 10 minutes for a food and drink menu, this place failed in every aspect. They have owned this place for 10 months and have no clue how the flow of a restaurant goes. It took them 45 minutes to present me with a “medium” burger that was raw in the middle. While it seemed there was a lot of staff, there was actually only one waitress for all the tables. For someone who trash talked every restaurant in a 25-mile radius for 15 minutes, the owner’s only excuse for bad service and mediocre food was, “well you came at a rush.” Will be returning when the next owners step up
… more
… View more