Based on 155 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
6601 Traveler Trail, Windsor, WI 53598
Phone: (608) 846-9090
Website: https://www.papinositalianrestaurantmenu.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ben Voeck
Great pizza. Son of the GOAT Pietro! Family is from Sicily and know what they are doing. Love these guys!
Katie Roltgen
Papino’s is fantastic! When you’re craving for homemade Sicilian/Italian food this is the place to go! Not only is the food delicious, the atmosphere is so lovely. Kid friendly as well. While waiting for our food to arrive, our 3 year was able to play with a ball of pizza dough to keep himself busy! So clever! Joe, the owner, is so accommodating and friendly! We have had great experience with their delivery as well- hot and always perfect!
Phil Brown
Honestly not impressed at all for the price $20 medium stuffed pizza. Delivery time and customer service was great however the “stuffed” pizza seemed to be very undercooked. However the sauce was good. Personally a reg pizza from them may be better however you’ll be better off ordering pizza hut.
Kim Stefanowicz
We ordered a delivery order for 6 people and were beyond disappointed. Nearly $80 plus tip for the driver and they forgot 3 items. When we called back to notify them of the missing salad w/grilled chicken and 2 missing deserts they said they would get them right out to us yet the Manager failed to offer to comp us for their error or inconvenience. 20 minutes later the delivery driver came back out and delivered the salad (minus the grilled chicken) and only 1 desert. REALLY??? Made a third call to the Manager and expressed our total disappointment. Can you believe he STILL didn’t offer to credit our credit card or comp us on our current or future orders??? We have been repeat customers for the last year and a half and am completely appalled at how they handled things. We work hard for our money and when we decide to spend over $80 on a meal we expect it to at least be correct. I guess they feel that losing a few customers due to their lack of customer service isn’t important to them.
… more
Kyle
In my opinion this pizza is slightly above Chuck-e-cheese in terms of quality. The sauce is pretty sweet. The dough is undercooked and very bland. This pizza is probably great for feeding a bunch of kids, but if you’re looking for quality pizza I recommend looking elsewhere.
Kyle Saley
The extra thin crust pizza is very good. Loaded with toppings. If you’re feeding a bunch of kids who don’t know the difference between awesome pizza and the tasteless any large pizza for $10 deal then go to the chain. But if great food is important to you and you want your calories to be a treat go see Joe at Papino’s.
Lauren Trentadue
I LOVE Papino’s! We order from here on a regular basis and their pizza is the best pizza in a 10 mile radius! I’ve also had many other items from their menu and enjoyed it tremendously! I recommend Papino’s to everybody! On a side note** we don’t eat on location very often, but the take out service is always great!
rob ben
I have had the Stuffed Pizza; Thin crust pizza; a pretty good ravioli, and a really good lasagna. Waiting area is very limited to non-existent though I expect that to improve with time. Service was very good, but the kitchen got backed up with orders.
Denise Packel
I only give this a 4 star just because I think the crust could use an improvement. The cheese and toppings are excellent and you know you are getting high quality cheese and meat.
S S
Extremely disappointed. I hate to give a bad review to a home town business, but it is warranted. We got takeout tonight, received burned breaded mushrooms and burned pizza crust. We got 1/2 and 1/2 toppings and it was so messed up that you couldn’t tell which half was which. For the price, I would have preferred Pizza Hut at this point.
… View more