Based on 923 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
205 NE Commercial Cir, Keystone Heights, FL 32656
Phone: (352) 478-8140
Website: http://www.brooklynboyskeystone.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Sunday | 12–7:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8:30 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brittany
Loved everything about it! The shot was a special and delicious. Can’t remember the name but super minty and so good. Love all the signs. Love the giant fan. I with they would screen in the big rolling doors and let in some more light but over all its a great place with lots of fun people. The right kind of people
John V
A little hidden gem in Keystone, this is not your average pizza place. A large variety of menu items to include what you would expect from a pizza place. Plus a full bar to order from. Also unique atmosphere, with humorous wall posters and signs. Friendly and attentive staff.
Hh Ll
The food was great and I know to get the small colzon next time lol, the large is huuuuuge
Claudette Hendricks
So we were visiting my brother’s new place and thought we’d check out this place, I’ve got to say it was very disappointing! We really wanted a sit down meal that didn’t require us to visit St. Augustine. Yes we understand that they sell pizza but they also had Italian meals, so that’s what we ordered. The appetizers we ordered were pretzel bites and fried calamari. The calamari was VERY FISHY tasting and the pretzel bites were made from obviously frozen ones that you can buy in the grocery store. We each ordered different meals, one meal was shrimp tacos that we asked for no blackening (for child) and no siracha, seriously it came with mango salsa that was on the side that was very oniony and no slaw on the tacos. So basically my granddaughter got shrimp on tortillas. The next meal was the shrimp basket, this meal was old dried out overcooked shrimp. The next meal was seafood crema Diablo, it came out as fra Diablo and the waitress said she ordered it wrong and took it back, the correct dish came out with the cream sauce with tortellini, shrimp, scallops and peppers but it was disgustingly fishy tasting. The other meal was chicken Alfredo, it was too cold to eat so had to be remade. It came back with some better freshness but no kidding the chicken looked boiled not grilled and tasted that way. The braided bread that came with the meals was good, that was the only good thing we received. The service was excellent, but the food needs serious work! My dogs ate good tonight!
… more
Chefy Momma
This was our first time eating here. Now I know what we’ve been missing. Their food is phenomenal!! Worth every penny. We will be back! My son that barely eats anything ate two adult size portions of spaghetti with meat sauce! Win win!!
Jennifer Tennant
I love getting their 2 slice special. Two slices and a drink. Today he didn’t have a cheese pie made so he made me a personal one for the same price because he knows it’s my usual. Thank God I finally got my NJ/NY style pizza in Keystone Heights!
mark manning
My wife and I shared a salad and a stromboli stuffed with good eats called the “garbage stromboli”. Food was great, and the people were friendly. We found the conservative, patriotic, America loving decor refreshing. We will be stopping by again when in the area.
Susan Coppinger
First time today. Excellent food and service. Didn’t think I would find good Italian food in a small town. Definitely going back!
Jay Baker
A group of us often do a bike and eat to Brooklyn boys from the nearby Palatka to Lake Butler paved trail. We usually eat outside where we can keep an eye on our bicycles. Great Stromboli!!
April Turner
Great place, food and people!!!
… View more