A small slice shop pizzeria. Specializing in specialty pizza. Always using top notch ingredients and always fresh. A local pizza place where we treat our customers like family. Located across the street from King Kone ice cream parlor on Middletown rd in Pearl River.
Based on 34 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
137 N Middletown Rd, Pearl River, NY 10965
Phone: (845) 735-1500
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Reviews
John MG
Nice Place well run. They were scrubbing clean wall and baseboard while I was there. The place is spotless. Refreshing to see a place that truly cares. Everything looked good. I had a chicken roll.
… more
Brianna Brass
Best pepperoni square I have EVER had!!!! So crispy, the pep chars were incredible, very flavorful sauce and crust. Get it well done with some Mikes hot honey on the side and you won’t be disappointed. This will be my new go to pizza joint for sure!!! Welcome to town guys !
… more
Stephen D
I have only tried the regular 18” cheese pizza, so can only comment on that. The amount of oregano in the sauce was overwhelming and tough to deal with for my taste. I also wish the crust was not nearly as thin. If you like a very thin crust with lots of oregano, them i guess it’s perfect. Pizza was made on time and the staff was very pleasant. I will definitely try again and check out some other menu items.
… more
Kyle Patriaco
Amazing pizza. Grandma slice is by far the best around. Great staff always make me feel like family when I come in. I come all the way from Westwood just to have their pizza! 100% recommend for anyone in or around town!!!
… more
MetfanBren
Finally got a chance to check out the new place up the block, and it didn’t disappoint. We ordered a large cheese pie (toppings are expensive at $5 each!) that was more thin crust than traditional. As a thin crust enthusiast I welcomed this, and it’s a nice change of pace from local pizza. I also ordered a sicilian slice that was good and quite thick. The cheese was good, and small crust was tasty. The sauce could have been stronger, which is why I’m not giving five stars. Overall the pizza was good and having different types of options is always a good thing!
… more
Kimmarie McGuinness
Delicious!! We ordered a cheese pie as well as a half meatball half sausage pie and they both were delicious! The sauce alone makes me want to try everything they make. Highly recommend!!
… more
James Rooney
Ordered an 18” pie, half pepperoni. Pizza showed up super thin, super greasy and practically falling apart. Wouldn’t have been so upset if it didn’t cost me $25.
… more
Vincent Matraxia
This is by far some of the best pizza you can find in the area. The options are all very tasty and the staff is amazing, great friendly service. I recommend the “vodkarita”, definitely my favorite.
… more
Lisan Santana
The grandma pie it’s the best!!! And the service awesome, thanks guys so delicious pizza!!!!
… more
Gabriel Medina-Moir
The gluten free pizza here might have been one of the worst I have had. The dough tasted like saltine crackers and they barely put any toppings on. The price was ridiculous, for two small gluten free pizzas it came out to $50. No pizza as bad as this should cost that much.
… more
… View more