Based on 144 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
999 Montauk Hwy #22, Shirley, NY 11967
Phone: (631) 395-0555
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
julianna burriesci
They now use slice for delivery. Which is fine I have used slice before but I always knew I was using them and it was my choice to use them . I was not informed that there would be a 6 dollar deliever fee . If they would have told me I would have walked the 300 feet to pick it up . We have used this pizza parlor for 20 years it is a shame they don’t have better customer service. Not only that but bill came to 37 dollars add5 dollar tip . When going over my statement ,I was charged 54 dollar then was charged another 5 dollars. Will never go there again.and will tell everyone I know not to
… more
Chinh Chinh
Everyone is super nice and pizza is always fast and fresh. They even take special requests like a heart shaped pizza with a garlic bread crust for her 18th bday. I used to work there back in college and I’ve still been going here for years. Great place!
… more
Maria Isabel Maldonado
BEST pizza in town by far..Best crust…best tomato sauce!! FRESH food every day. This is a casual place, small, well lit and clean, friendly staff, soda fountain with cheaper refills, outdoor seating area in the summer…unisex restroom, extra seating in the back. I have been coming here for 14 years and is the freshest and best pizza around town. Desserts include cannolis and cheesecake, fresh zeppoles on weekends, get one free pie when you save 10 box coupons, soups, lasagna, baked ziti, spagetti, EVERYTHING FRESH!! My favorite pizzeria in town!!
… more
Karen Oresto
My granddaughter ordered a meatball parm again hero with the meatballs on the side so the bread wouldn’t get soggy. She always orders it this way at other establishments. The staff was rude and told her she was being charged for a side of meatballs and a small bread. We went here always for pizza. Now will never return!!
… more
Jack DeGennaro
The pizza is good but the service at night is terrible i called 6 times and they waited till the 7th time to tell me they dont wanna take orders thats why they werent picking up the calls. That is a terrible buisness model
… more
Aja Rapelyea
Was there today and omg I took one bite of the garlic knots and it was so yummy hmmm
… more
Mary R
Brought home 2 pies tonight. Very good. Pepperoni and meatball.
… more
Sue Laci
2 Sicilian slices and one small drink $11. If it was really good pizza it would be worth it. Elio’s Pizza from your grocery store is better.
… more
Theresa Fox
We go to this pizza parlor on a regular after shopping. Normally, as an overall, its pretty good. We ordered there last night and it was so bad that we could not eat it. The pizza was very overcooked and the chicken wings were undercooked. My daughter had two wings and became sick, that’s when I noticed it was under cooked. I have an illostomy that the pizza was so overcooked and gross that it made the stoma sick all over. I did not call to complain, we just decided to not go there anymore. I can’t give a 2nd chance from how sick we became.
… more
Valerie Taylor
My younger son and I love the penne ala vodka slice, and my older son loves the Buffalo chicken pizza. We all love the regular slices, and I also like the chicken caesar salad slice. My husband ordered a pizza with sausage and other meat on top and loved that too. We’ve ordered about a dozen times and were never disappointed.
… more
… View more