Based on 37 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
18 1/2 Wolfhill Ave, Oceanport, NJ 07757
Phone: (732) 389-3333
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
David M. Dwight
Before leaving Oceanport swung by 18 Wolfhill Avenue to see if the rumor about Nicky’s Oceanport Pizza was true.
… more
Anna Whetstone
Amazing pizza, got the Billy’s special pizza and grandma pie and both we great. Love the sesame crust! Close to new brewery birdmouth so great to bring with, get delivered, or you or get after a visit there!
… more
Scott Emmons
Margherita pizza was fantastic! Also the sandwiches were out of this world. Pepperoni pizza well done with everything crust is so good. So nice to have a fantastic pizza place in Oceanport.
… more
Chris Michel
Get the pepi well done with everything seasoned crust. Best pizza I’ve had in nj. They’re doing it right
… more
VAUGHN CASTLE
I came to pick up an order For Uber eats I’ve been there before and the Spanish lady was working tonight who is always nice, and a Spanish male worker, and the owner. I came in there I said the name of the person I’m picking up for, they said oh can I see the phone. Okay, i go get it and I return. The owner said that’s because some people open up the bag and eat the food. I’m like well, I’m not that person I don’t do things like that. As I was walking out he made a negative comment That I believe his son repeated because he started to scold him for it. I don’t know if it was racial comment but the enitre situation made me uncomfortable, that I don’t think I want to return.
… more
Will B.
Been here a few times over the last couple months. Last time we ordered the Famous Pepi-Roni and when I got there they had made a regular pepperoni pie (which I’m sure was also delicious). The lady did not hesitate to apologize and begin whipping up the beast that I wanted, despite being right at closing. She tried her best to not charge me the difference between the pies, but she did not win that battle. Take my money. Keep taking my money. And I’ll keep coming back… like I’ll be in the next 35-40 minutes.
… more
kim chenoweth
Just ordered garlic knots, pepperoni roll and wings, everything was very good, except who gives out wings with no blue cheese!! That was very disappointing.
… more
P Newman
Great pizza so why only 1 star? Two of the five people in this tiny take-out were not wearing masks and one was the cashier. The pizza was prepaid using Slice and I included a 20% tip for a total of $38 for one cheese pizza with two toppings. It was so disappointing and unexpected that staff does not respect their customers and enforce that everyone wear a mask. No pizza is worth exposing yourself.
… more
catucha55
I work in Sales at Circle Hyundai and was just treated to this delicious pizza by the staff! Alfredo, Buffalo, white, general two’s, pepperoni, plain you name it they’re all so good! Best pizza I’ve had probably ever #thewholeteamisraving
… more
craig baker
Excellent food at reasonable prices. Big fan of the Sea Bright location and was very excited to see a new location right down the street.
… more
… View more