Easygoing option for slices & pies along with sandwiches, pasta dishes & starters such as wings. Based on 478 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
303 N Main St, Elmira, NY 14901
Phone: (607) 732-3647
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: munchoneats.com
Reviews
Catherine C
Update 6/2023
… more
Denise Long
Ordered pizza and wings for delivery when visiting our son and daughter-in-law. Way over priced. The pizza was overcooked. The wings were good, extra crispy as requested. I’m surprised the owner would let that pizza leave the building. Years ago that was the best pizza in Elmira. Maybe its under new management or ownership. If so, it shows. Definitely disappointed and will not order from there again.
… more
Tristan Jacobucci
11 bucks for a nice, juicy in the best way Stromboli Plenty of pep, salami, onions, ground assuage and banana peppers all wrapped up inside! Just wish it hade some garlic butter on top, next time, though. Only wish was that the red sauce was thicker
… more
Glenn Ewing
I am new to Elmira and ordered from Vincenzo’s tonight. I ordered a Lg. Leonardo and requested to switch out the pepperoni for garlic. I Have to say hands down the Best Pizza I’ve had in a LONGtime. I will most certainly be ordering from Vincenzo’s again soon. I give this Pizza a well-deserved 5stars.
… more
Roman Salvador
Definitely got the New York pizza mom and pop shop feel. And the food lives up to the cliche. Meatball sub and calzones are amazing. Staff is really friendly which adds to the mom and pop feel.
… more
Rena Banks
We were passing through Elmira on a road trip and stopped to grab Subway. We saw Vincenzos beside Subway and a guy walking out with a sub so we decided to stop in there instead. Best decision ever! We had an Italian and a tuna sub. We didn’t know they were coming with fries so that was an awesome surprise. The subs were so delicious! The bread was warm and crispy and was my favorite part but the tuna I had was also so good. 10/10 would go here again if I ever find myself in that town again!
… more
Tim Luzier
Very friendly service. Great pizza and cheesesteak with pepper and onions delicious
… more
Stephen Ruggiano
I almost feel bad leaving such a poor review but I feel even worse about the pizza I just received. Almost no cheese and no flavor. Just look at the picture- not appetizing at all. Truly, this is possibly the worst pizza I’ve ever tasted. It’s not as though it is cheap either, as I paid $25 with tip for a large cheese(less?) pizza.
… more
Tee G
Always friendly staff, if it’s not busy willing to include you in their conversation while you wait. Not to mention best pizza and tiramisu around!
… more
Monica Orosz
Pizza’s okay. Better than dominos, but not authentic New York style. I wouldn’t get the pepperoni pizza, the pepperonis have an off flavor and ruin the pizza. Also, they make you wait in line to pick up a pick-up order, which kind of defeats the purpose of ordering ahead. And while I was waiting in line for my pick-up order, I noticed the cashier put a slice of pizza in the oven without gloves, knowing they weren’t washing their hands in between handling money.. Pietro & Son is a good option for pizza as well, it’s cheaper, and they have huge portions and a better takeout system.
… more
… View more