Looking for the best steak house in Buena Vista and Salida, Colorado? Look no further than Mary Murphy Steak House!
Our steak house offers a unique dining experience that combines mouthwatering steaks with top-notch service. Our chefs use only the finest ingredients to create delicious dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings.
Whether you’re in the mood for a juicy ribeye, a tender filet mignon, or a flavorful New York strip, our steak house has you covered. Our menu also features other delectable options such as fresh seafood, chicken, and vegetarian dishes.
Based on 141 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
15870 Co Rd 162, Nathrop, CO 81236
Phone: (719) 395-2447
Hours
| Saturday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8 AM–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: resy.com
Reviews
Kaitlyn
We were not planning on eating here during our stay at the resort, but when we arrived, we did not feel like going back out to go to dinner. This was one of the best steaks I’ve had – perfectly seasoned. Definitely on the pricey side, but it was a great meal with attentive waitstaff.
… more
Douglas
Duck and trout cooked perfect. Beet and mushroom salad starter and apple crisp desert. The wait staff is up to the standards that the chef sets. Total enjoyable dinner.
… more
Isaiah Thomason
Great staff, great vibe. My wife is an Advanced Sommelier and was extremely impressed with the wine selection, and equally delighted to see the price especially given the location, we were told Sara is the author! Kudos! Food menu is eclectic and expertly prepared. Very, very impressed! We have been back multiple times while we explore Chalk Canyon
… more
Benny B
Was very excited about going to try this restaurant as the online presence and menu seemed great. Host sat us down without any silverware, Waitress wasn’t very attentive, soup came out cold, along with risotto that came with the rack of lamb. Myself got the goat cheese pasta and it came with a completely different pasta than listed on the menu. The chicken on the pasta was extremely dry and flavorless, and the alfredo sauce was not smooth and creamy as it should be for a $37 dish. Nothing came out hot. Warm at best.
… more
Joshua
Let me start by saying I wish we could go somewhere between 4 & 5 for our diner experience. The price reflects the lack of availability of other options so don’t be surprised there.
… more
Jillian Downing
This was my first time dining here. Service was subpar, and the restaurant was not busy. It took 15 minutes for our drinks to arrive at our table. We had to get our waitresses’ attention twice. Our food was brought out by the kitchen staff and was very obvious it had been sitting. The short ribs were yummy! The shrimp scampi was flavorless, cold, and clumpy noodles for $30. No bread or grated cheese was offered with the scampi. Overall, it was a disappointing dining experience.
… more
Debra Johnson
Service was great. Dinner was good. My dinner salad was “okay.” My burger was amazing. It was cooked perfectly with no pink but was still tender and juicy. The steak my husband had was very good. The sweet potato mash was very flavorful as the steak was placed on top of the potatoes and it allowed the sauce to mix with the potatoes. The view was good. There were beautiful fresh flowers on the table as well as hand sanitizer.
… more
Tamara Bailey
My husband and I are staying at Mount Princeton for our first anniversary and we had lunch this afternoon at Mary Murphy Steakhouse. The food was superb and our waitress, Susan, was so kind and gave us such an amazing experience there. I highly recommend Mary Murphy Steakhouse!
… more
Tom Frazier
Nice selection of appetizers and salads to start your dinner. I had the the fish and chips but the kicker was it was walleye which I’ve never had with fish and chips it’s usually cod. My wife had the 14er steak very good also.
… more
Jackie Claux
This restaurant is located inside of the main area of the Mount Princeton HotSpings resort. We had the Hanger Steak and it was fabulous! The wine, the views, and the service were phenomenal! Our server Randy was great!
… more
… View more