Based on 142 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
4134 Grand Blvd, New Port Richey, FL 34652
Phone: (727) 232-2474
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–4 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
8 AM–6 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 8 AM–6 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–6 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–6 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–6 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Michael Simila
AWESOME SHOP! The girls working today did a great job. It was super busy but they were still fast snd efficient. Did pick up, ordered 2 Tony Montanas and a Philly (forgot the rest of the name) .. everyone was pleased, sandwiches were delicious , highly recommend this little hole on the wall. Check er out , big portions , fast friendly service. Let’s go.
… more
William Cronin
Great little place, have only had their burgers, but they are GREAT. All are double patty (has to be well over 1/2lb meat, maybe 2/3!,) cooked to order, cheese and topping are generous, served on a huge lightly toasted bun. Any other burger would get lost on that bun, not here! Frankly, I have a very hearty appetite, and struggle to eat that burger. Oh, get this, prices $10-12!!! If you happen to go on a day they have mac & cheese, get it. Again huge portion, home made, a real treat! Owner/employees very friendly, make you feel very welcome and appreciated. 5 stars!
… more
Matthew Ware
This place is worth your time and money. Awesome little local shop. I’ve come probably a dozen times and every single time without fail the guys and girls working are extremely friendly, super quick and make amazing sandwiches. I live a couple blocks away and I usually call in my order and by the time I make it there it’s already done. Their Cuban (the Tony Montana) is freaking delicious. Definitely worth the try
… more
brielle budden
Goodfellas always treats their customers like family the minute you walk in! During spring break they made lunches for all of the kids for free! It’s amazing! We are so thankful for them
… more
Chris Mikelinich
Lucky enough to work next door, great place for lunch, friendly atmosphere and staff. You can tell the owner/cook puts his heart into his cooking. Would highly recommend the “bruiser” burger!
… more
Mason Flynn
Goodfellas is awesome! I stopped in today with my wife, and as we walked in the smell of delicious food hit our faces. Just that alone told me the sandwiches here are prime. I ordered the breakfast Cuban, and my wife got the regular Cuban. If I could give more stars I would. we will definitely be back!
… more
Michael Watts
First time coming to this restaurant & all the hype I’ve been hearing definitely didn’t disappoint. The food is fresh and so good & the customer service in their is on point.
… more
terry duerr
I’ve had quite a few subs from here today I got the Henry Hill Corned Beef on rye ! My new favorite loaded with corned beef lettuce tomatoes and Swiss cheese and spicy mustard. Absolutely delicious thank you
… more
Sarah Brooklyn
I went to another local deli and they were closed today, the Memorial Weekend Saturday which was amazingly depressing so I decided to walk into Goodfellas Deli. I was greeted by the sweet young girl running the counter, right followed by the gentleman cooking. I proceeded to ask them to give me any sandwich on the menu that will make me want to come here first next time and with full confidence he jumped into action. I like that he listened when I said I am not a picky eater and went right into action with a plan. He went straight to the VA, grabbed the meats fresh and went to work! I ended up with the Don Vito and let me tell you, I’m not even halfway thru my sandwich here and writing this review. The fresh meats, the homemade pickled onions, fresh veggies…. I’m in heaven and will definitely be back again!! The only thing I would change, I should’ve bought 2! Do yourself a favor and try this wonderful local business!
… more
Amy Robertson
This place is AMAZING! Everything I have gotten from here has been delicious. Super fresh, huge portions, and great variety. Was just introduced the their Meal Prep options, and once again, couldn’t be happier with the meals. Having fresh, healthy meals I can preorder or pick up anytime is a game changer in my busy life. The guys are great too. Always friendly and smiling!!!
… more
… View more