Based on 149 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 5.0 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
91865 Overseas Hwy, Tavernier, FL 33070
Phone: (305) 396-7240
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 12–6 PM |
| Sunday | 12–6 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 12–6 PM |
| Thursday | 12–6 PM |
| Friday | 12–6 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Alexia Davila
This pizza place is insane! Must go if you’re in the keys! The hot honey pepperoni pizza was SO good. The pepperonis got perfectly crisp and so did the edges from cheese. It was fluffy inside with crunch on top and bottom. The sauce was fresh and you could taste it in every bite. The owner and his wife were very kind and inviting. The atmosphere was fun with good music. The decor is very modern with a gorgeous mural.
… more
Brian Stormo
So glad we stopped after checking out the barstool video, on our way to key west. The pizza was honestly some of the best Sicilian-esque I’ve had. Fresh ingredients, good proportions, good sauce. The burrata salad was fantastic as well. The real story here is the owners. Super down to earth and passionate family trying to make it work( (and absolutely nailing it!)
… more
Archit Mishra
Best best best best Pizza I ever had!
… more
Cassandra T
This pizza is delicious. The crust is perfectly made , the toppings are great, typing this review makes me sad they are so far from me. I highly recommend this pizza , not only is it scrumptious but the owners are a delight! We love this place and can’t wait to make a day trip out there again.
… more
Amy Rushforth
Amazing pizza and service! We were so happy we stopped here for dinner while visiting the Keys. We got the pepperoni with hot honey and the Classic. The sweetness of the honey was a delicious combination with the savory pepperoni. The crust was delicious, airy and absolutely perfect. The Classic was yummy too. Plus the owners were super friendly and accommodating! If you’re in the Keys. This place is a must stop!
… more
Loyda Riley
Enjoyed every bite! Pizza was amazing, chicken wings with a kick & pies to indulge in. All delicious! Great atmosphere & great people. Thank you. Recommend.
… more
J S
Great pizza and ambiance. It’s a husband and wife business. Went in with ours kids and we loved it! Pizza was hot and crispy, the pepperoni with hot honey is a must. The Oreo pie and cannoli’s were delicious. Best pizza we have eaten in a while. I’m from Jersey and good pizza is a must. Will definitely be returning.
… more
Kristopher Charlz Rodriguez
The best square pizza I have ever had. Unbelievably light and airy with super fresh ingredients. The pizza is fluffy with crispy bottom and edges. Pretty much a pan pizza hybrid between Detroit style and Sicilian. If you have never had this style pizza please do yourself a favor. I could not believe I was having this quality pizza in the keys. The desserts and salads are also amazing!
… more
Rhoda Levitt
The pizza is TERRIFIC!!!
… more
Reef Tourer
Best restaurant in the keys! The salads & house made dressings are so fresh! Infact, everything is made right there in house. Hands down some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. 10/10 recommend. A MUST STOP IN THE KEYS.
… more
… View more