Formaggio’s Pizza is your number one source for the best pizza in Valrico, FL. We are an Italian restaurant that specializes in a variety of items including pizza, calzones, and much more. Our chefs use the freshest ingredients to ensure that you are completely satisfied. We offer pick up, delivery, and even catering options. For great service in Valrico, FL, order at Formaggio’s Pizza.
Lively, group-friendly joint for creative pizza, classic Italian pastas & calzones in relaxed digs. Based on 178 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4356 Lithia Pinecrest Rd, Valrico, FL 33596
Phone: (813) 689-1744
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday |
12–9 PM |
| Sunday |
12–8 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
12–8 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday |
12–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
12–9 PM |
| Thursday |
12–9 PM |
| Friday |
12–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: formaggios.com
Reviews
John Alvarez Jr
Hey Friends, trying another pizza joint…Formaggio’s Pizza. You think authentic New York Pizza, right? The name is Italian and means cheese. Come on… Nope, it was far from a New York style pizza. The Mrs. and I ordered 8 wings dressed in garlic BBQ, garlic knots and a Buffalo Chicken Pizza. The wings weren’t anything special. Frozen, thawed wings drenched, I mean drenched in some kind of sauce…I don’t know what… It looked like syrup truly. The garlic knots were uncooked and no crispy. They were true dough but the amount of butter/oil was 2x’s the amount of garlic. So, last but not least, the pie. The pie was cooked evenly, the dough wasn’t bad. Chewy but had no flavor. The buffalo sauce was from a can, no spice. Burn my mouth please with real buffalo sauce! There was no heat…There was no blue cheese, typical mozzarella. The chicken… This was the line. Prepackaged frozen but thawed chicken pieces. They were white, maybe microwaved and added the pizza. Come on, use breaded fresh chicken pieces..spice up the blandness. We paid close to $50, I’m disappointed. I wouldn’t recommend the place because I want value for what I’m paying for and decent food. Just not my cup of tea, I know NY Pizza being a former New Englander. You decide. Remember Friends, Enjoy what you eat! Peace!
… more
David Rainone
Based on other reviews, I had high expectations. I ordered cheese pizza with sausage – was expecting slices of sausage as menu indicated. Got sausage crumbles instead – not the same crispness.
… more
Sue Me
Pizza is very good. We got a large with the works. We found a new pizza place. Carry out only!
… more
Charles Mark Butler
Very thin, floppy crust-hard to hold or fold to eat. Not much sauce and sparse toppings. I make better homemade pizzas! Domino’s is preferable. Disappointed. Expected more per online descriptions and website. Will keep looking for good custom pizza in Valrico.
… more
Lynsey
This is genuinely some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten! Very unique pizza topping and its very apparent care was put into making this pie.
… more
John McIntosh
Well on the hunt for another place for pizza…
… more
Shauna Thomas
Hands down, BEST Philly cheesesteak! Boneless Buffalo wings, delish. Salads are enough for 2 or 3 meals. Favorite pizza is BBQ chicken bacon. Service is fast and friendly! Love the people, food, and location. They also offer delivery, also fast and friendly!
… more
Baby Girl
so dirty and average. I seems that there is no adult there 75 percent of the time. These high schoolers do not care about quality. The whole thing is just so average. Garlic knots are pretty good though.
… more
Deborah LaCalamito
We went due to rain and the springs closing. Our pizza was fantastic, and the zeppoles were so good!!! Definitely try it if your at the springs for the day!
… more
Alexander Zubreev
Best pizza for me.
… more
… View more
