Counter-service Italian cafe offering pizza, heroes, pastas & entrees, plus delivery & take-out. Based on 226 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
673 Hillside Ave., New Hyde Park, NY 11040
Phone: (516) 326-7879
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–10 PM |
| Thursday | 12–10 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 12–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 12–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cathie G
So I ordered here through Uber eats just a little bit ago, and I’ve never in my life immediately went and wrote a review. But here I am. I ordered a large pizza, calzone, and buongiorno panini through Uber eats. There was literally nothing right with this order. The pizza was undercooked, and bland. Calzone was literally raw in the middle. And the worst part was the “panini” they sent. It was NOT even a panini! It was literally a sandwich on pita bread!! Not toasted and on pita bread. The description said it included prosciutto, which it didn’t. It came with what I’m assuming is prosciutto cotto, which is a fancy ham!! That is not what I ordered! They are completely different. I didn’t order a pita bread sandwich with ham… I ordered a panini with prosciutto. Worst pizzeria I’ve ordered from in years. Will not be reordering. Stay away.
… more
Peter
This pizza place does not skimp out on the dough or cheese, so you can get way more pizza per slice. The garlic knots aren’t rock hard or flavorless like at all the other places around. The prices are also the lowest in the area.
… more
venci karlic
Place is stuck in 1999. They still require a 10$ minimum to use debit/credit card. I only ordered a slice and didn’t have Cash, ended up walking out hungry and with no pizza and went back to work with no lunch. Avoid at all costs if you just want a slice and don’t have cash. When will businesses realize that the percentage the credit card companies take is the same percentage for all transactions and therefore the total amount of purchase does not matter? Wake up and smell the coffee.
… more
Adeela Choudry
I always love gigi pizza!!! Variety + quality!! Quality has been same for years I’ve been going. I always get pizza but got other stuff twice n it was good.
… more
Santia Gillette
Traditional pizzeria inside, seating area to eat in located towards the back and pizza/ordering right when you walk in. 2 folks ahead of us when we came in, service was fine. Nothing terrible but nothing outstanding either.
… more
Shivanie Arjune
Food was great, service was fast and atmosphere was comfortable!
… more
Colleen
I would avoid this place all together as they are unorganized, in addition to poor customer service. They are listed as a restaurant on Seamless so I placed an order in advance, but when I arrived to the restaurant, they looked at me like I was crazy. They said they are not on Seamless but if they had any sense of what was happening, they would realize they are, in fact, on Seamless. My order was confirmed and received a notification It was ready for pick up. They definitely need to learn to manage their business more efficiently and not act like the customer is in the wrong. Instead of being apologetic they were pretty rude. Of course at that point I had already unbuckled my two toddlers from their car seat and dragged them into the restaurant. They were excited, thinking they were going to get pizza. You figured at this point the restaurant would be nice and do something for me. But No! No apology nothing of the sort. Save yourself a headache. Go to Luigi’s on Union tpke. Authentic Italian cuisine and excellent service.
… more
aomaimah sayed
Worst ever experience I will never recommend to anybody I order vegetable pizza and they added chickennnnnnn in it so especially those who eat halal food or vegetarians avoid going there , I ordered 1 large half veg half regular pizza he took $30 and it was first not tast good enough and had chicken in it …. Second order was garlic knots and they were not fresh he just warm them but the moment u eat it one can feel it
… more
Tejas Dadarkar
We used to go here for our pizza years ago. I happened to be at stop and shop, so I figured i would go in and grab a slice or two. I’m so glad I did. The pizza is just as good as I remember, and the people there were so super nice! They have made a regular customer out of me again.
… more
Desi Relaford
Decent pizza but price is going through the roof. Over $5.25 for a speciality slice now! Plus the cash only is a headache sometimes.
… more
… View more