Based on 207 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
943 E Johnstown Rd, Gahanna, OH 43230
Phone: (614) 269-7355
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–9 PM |
| Thursday | 3–9 PM |
| Friday | 3–9 PM |
| Saturday | 3–9 PM |
| Sunday | 1–7 PM |
| Monday | 3–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Derek Putman
Pizza was delicious and ready when I ordered for pickup via their website. The crunch on that crust is next level. Our pizza wasn’t cut very well, but that’s not that big of a deal.
… more
bryan rooth
Our family loves pizza and follow Dave Portnoy, found this place because of him and disagree with his 8.1…….it’s definitely higher, more like an 8.3-8.5! This place is awesome, LOVE the crunch on every bite, the cheese isn’t greasy, and the pepperonis are perfect. We are going to make this place a weekly visit. All the staff was super friendly and the pizza came out fast. We always dine in, and the place had great music also. They even gave our kids cookies after we were done. Can’t recommend this place enough. I’m already looking forward to our next pizza. The wife enjoyed the draft beer….forgot to ask if they fill growlers.
… more
MRBARBQ 1
Decided I was going to finally check this place out. First thing to know is they only have large pizzas. Ordered a pepperoni and cheese pizza. The dough is made perfectly, nice and airy with the slightest char to it. They use a medley of cheeses on it that melts nicely. On to the pepperoni, for me it wasn’t cooked enough but that is my opinion. I am used to cooking with Ezzo’s Cup and Char pepperoni. If they made different sizes I might return but everything I’ve read online from them that isn’t happening.
… more
mrhenryb
Definitely and I mean MOST DEFINITELY one of the top notch pizzas I’ve had ever !! The Kevin Bacon My god delicious the pie has just the right amount of char and cooked to perfection. If you haven’t tried don’t wait any longer This is the way to start a weekend off right . OH also they sell the best sweets from Tudie’s Cookies & Sweets the Oatmeal Cream Pie is as big as a softball and delicious
… more
Æyrton A
We all knew Sextons was legendary before David Portnoy visited. The Gahanna location still has the comfy dive feel. Staff is quick to ask if you want a pint from the tap. I would recommend one of the local brews, especially now since the wait is 50 mins for a pie. No frills location. Drink a beer, wait on an amazing pie. ENJOY!.
… more
Kimberly lDavis
Excellent customer service. The young gentleman explained everything on the menu. He gave us his favorite pic’s. Food is fresh and delicious.
… more
D Jackson
Had a great slice here. They only had cheese and pepperoni (I was told they did a specialty slice each day but apparently not), so I got the pepperoni. Good old school pepperoni that curls up when you eat it. $3 for the slice was a very fair price. The to-go container could use some work so the pizza wasn’t bent, but this was a good stop for me.
… more
Gauge Adams
Got the Kevin bacon NY style and have been dreaming of it ever since. Flavors perfectly melded together. Delicious crust that reminds me of home. *Philly
… more
Nitra Marshall
Ugh. I was so excited for this pizza after seeing some of the good reviews on here. We ordered the Smokey Robinson pizza. The pizza is very cold, stuck to the box, and all of the sauce and toppings are in the middle of the pizza. The taste is good so I can tell on a good day this can be good pizza. Some slices didn’t even have sauce on it. I was going to call to return this pizza but they are now closed, so we have to settle for this. I’ll probably never order or recommend eating here.
… more
Mike Royer
Great pizza! Sexton’s has a lot of speciality pizzas that you won’t find at other places. In addition, they aren’t shy with the toppings! Our pizza was cooked nicely. Everything we ordered tasted great! The staff was very friendly. The garlic knots were some of the best we’ve had! This might be my new takeout destination!
… more
… View more