Chain eatery specializing in thick-crust pizzas, also offering calzones, sides & desserts. Based on 62 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.2 stars. Price $$
Address:
1804 E Central Ave, Estherville, IA 51334
Phone: (712) 362-5872
Website: http://godfathers.com/
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Daren Koenck
Huge improvement! We haven’t been to Godfather’s in a few months, but went last weekend. We ordered a large original taco pizza and breadsticks. The breadsticks came out within 10 minutes, hot and fresh! The pizza followed about 10 minutes later. That was hands-down the best taco pizza I’ve had there in years! This is a huge improvement from the last several times we’ve been there. I heard they’ve made several changes, and its definitely for the better.
… more
Kyle Dalton
To start off I love the food here, but what makes everything better is the crew that is working here. In my past visit every single crew member had a smile on there face even though it was fairly busy when I was in. I also love the Buffet Everything is fresh and orginized. In the last several month I’ve noticed some change in the staff and in the reastaunt in general all good changes keep it up and keep filling up my belly with your amazing food.
… more
Paige Grove
Got a thin crust pizza with bell peppers onions and tomatoes got an all meat “deluxe no mushrooms no olives “ it also didn’t have bell pepper onions or tomatoes . Also the breads sticks I ordered were doughy .when I called to late them know I got the wrong pizza the girl tried making me feel like it was my fault and wouldn’t even address the burnt crust. I will NEVER GO T THIS godfathers EVER again . Save your money go somewhere else there are a lot better places in town .
… more
Christian Sjourney
Got a burnt thin crust pizza delivered and called to report it. The store said it would send out a free one next time to replace it. About 10 days later we ordered the free replacement but the store said there would be another $2 delivery charge. I complained that we already paid the $2 to have the first burnt pizza delivered but Jane (the manager-on-duty) insisted that we had to pay it again. I wonder if Jane would have expected us to pay the double delivery charge if we’d wanted the replacement brought out immediately. Clearly, customer satisfaction is a low priority for her. What a shame for Godfather’s, when so many better people are looking for jobs. Felt awful about not tipping the 2nd driver but Jane apparently thought the store needed the $2 worse than he did. 2 strikes. John Skrepak 4/10/2014
… more
Laurie Caswell
If I had to base it on today’s experience I’d never go back but this place has always been a go to when visiting Estherville for 30+ yrs… Hope our next visit is much better. We got the buffet 45 mins before it ended, was empty of choices, lettuce was wilted nothing was added in 45 mins so we got our money back…
… more
ann coffman
They stopped refilling the buffet early so we only had couple of old pizzas to choose from. The salad bar was tiny, almost no real veggies, some premade stuff like macaroni salad. LOTS of dirty tables too
… more
Jeffery Minton
Buffet? Not so much! Full restaurant and nearly empty warming tables do not a buffet make. No chicken for the first 15 minutes, then they bring out 7 pieces, gone in a New York minute! Employees spent far more time socializing than working. The guy I presumed to be the manager was constantly on his cell. Poor customer service I’d as under statement! We won’t be back.
… more
Katrina Lutzow
This was a horrible experience! The buffet was almost empty, and the food that was there was so hard, my son and I could hammer it on the table without it crumbling or breaking. Also, the tables were dirty, the staff was rude to a small child and his father who were there together. Awful!
… more
alzeppelin
Only reason they get one star is because a zero isn’t available. Most pathetic excuse for a buffet I have ever seen. You are lucky to see one new pizza put in the tiny warming area every hour. Plenty of workers standing around though.
… more
bacon pope
They were out of potato wedges, but were still great.
… more
… View more