Based on 172 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
364 2nd Ave, Niwot, CO 80503
Phone: (303) 652-3100
Hours
| Saturday | 4–8:15 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10:30 AM–1 PM, 4–7 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10:30 AM–1 PM, 4–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 10:30 AM–1 PM, 4–7 PM |
| Thursday | 10:30 AM–1 PM, 4–7 PM |
| Friday | 10:30 AM–1 PM, 4–8:15 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Nick Katsiotis
Delicious pizza! Ingredients were amazing. Pepperoni was excellent. Smell in the store was divine. This shop is a hidden gem in the nice town of Niwot. It’s not far out of boulder and is worth the drive if there is going to be a wait elsewhere. Pizza is more expensive but a small can feed 2 if you’re not too hungry
… more
Muthu
I recently had the pleasure of trying out this fantastic pizza shop and I have to say, it exceeded all of my expectations! The pizza was simply amazing – fresh, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. I especially loved the crispy crust and the generous toppings – it was clear that the ingredients were of the highest quality.
… more
Nick Ferguson
The pepperoni and Hefty pizza were delicious. Excellent crust. The team went above and beyond in helping us get a receipt, after we misplaced our copy. Thank you Lefty’s!
… more
RainBlayze
My boyfriend and I went for lunch on a week day and got two slices of pizza and rocky road ice cream. The slices are huge for a great price. They taste amazing and I told my boyfriend it was like eating spaghetti as a pizza. It was amazing. Nice and quiet atmosphere with very friendly workers.
… more
J C
So, this place is usually delicious. Today went for a calzone on patio, young girl at counter told me she’d bring it out to me. Sat outside for 50 min., had to ask about it- of course she forgot. Went home instead as the moment was ruined, only to find they took it out of the oven too soon- doughy calzone- terrible. The mother apologized for the delay, but now that I have to put this in the oven at home to hopefully get crisp bread, may not go back. Shame.
… more
Jared Alva
Good pizza and nice service. Didn’t really like feeling pressured to purchase the loyalty member discount or like that the young kid taking orders was either (he’s young dude and clearly this isn’t his forever career but really nice). I’m a firm believer that a product or promotion should sell itself. I imagine most people just do carryout or delivery considering there’s only 1.5 tables to sit comfortably at. But all in all it was a good experience and pizza. Oh and the strawberry cheesecake ice cream is really good, my daughter loved the cookies and cream.
… more
Scott Barto
I’ve been getting my pizza here every Monday for the past 20 years. Whether it’s deep dish, thin crust, or ice cream, this place is sure to satisfy!
… more
Roy Reker
I visited Lefty’s Pizza and it was divine. We brought our own beverages which was ok. The gluten free pizza was the best I ever had. Talked to the owner and he knew the history of the property where I was staying. This was the place visited by Dennis Collins on his you tube channel. Charming atmosphere, are outside. I will definitely take some home.
… more
Yakov Levin
After searching for a couple years, I finally found an authentically NYC pizza experience in (almost) Boulder. Delicious, crunchy, and cheesy pizza by the slice at a reasonable price. I’m rather flabbergasted at some of the other reviews; I have had nothing but pleasant interactions with the staff. Lefty himself is a fascinating gentleman to talk to if you catch him when they’re not busy. Very grateful to have such a nice establishment around.
… more
Charlotte Bassett
We stopped in on a weekday for lunch. Ordered calzones and so glad we did. They were amazing! We will definitely be back. Service was great!
… more
… View more