Unassuming destination for East Coast-style pies, liquor, cigarettes & deli goods. Based on 137 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $$
✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1086 A St, Hayward, CA 94541
Phone: (510) 582-3333
Hours
| Friday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
11 AM–9:30 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lobo Ahriman
I always forget this place exists until I happen to drive by it, such a hole in the wall. Probably my favorite pizza around here, been coming for years and never disappointed. One time my slice was a little burnt, but the personnel were tied up with kids causing chaos in the store so that’s understandable. Just an fyi: this is a thin crust style pizza like they do in New York. That’s why it’s called New York Pizza. Not sure if these folks are actually from NY but this pizza is definitely NY style.
… more
Emerald Gomez
I ordered a large combination pizza and let me tell you Round table pizza is next door and I probably won’t visit there again it’s not about the price. The quality of the pizza here was so spot on krispy Crust.
… more
Alexandria Torres
Purchased pizza and cheese bread from here ! And will never purchase again!! Pizza was super greasy and super thin and hard. Hours after eating I got sick to my stomach and was throwing up!!
… more
Karen Arteaga
Um where do I start! I just received my pizza about 10 min ago and was ready to eat !!!! Well that’s not going to be happening sadly !! the pizza is extra thin!!! no type of Crust Or any tomato sauce not sure how they are in business!! It’s like I’m eating cardboard.. literally so confused in how anyone can order from here.. ugh so annoyed I just wanted a pizza a REAL PIZZA!!
… more
J Singh
What is this? Their toppings and crust are made separately? This is not good.
… more
James Brogan
Thin slices the way I like it. Vegetables always fresh. No fault of anyone but the pizza is made in the back of a liquor store – nowhere to sit and wait/eat. No big deal. Until another customer comes and orders. Then, one of you has to stand in front of the magazine rack I guess made up of these poor women with nary an article of clothing. Young (barely legal) and older into wildlife (cougars). ONLY to be polite, I’ll sacrifice my comfort of being FORCED to stand in front of the slightly more cramped space. Since I’m there anyway… I hear the articles are interesting. I started to read one where I learned one could get taller (“add a few inches”) Good thing I’m comfortable with my height. But, time seems to fly by, and never able to finish (reminds me of another article. Not being able to finish. Its either a time management issue or it’s about being neighbors with Sweden. I think). Need to read up more about lonely women nearby barely making ends meet not able to afford much clothing. Being a nice guy… (ok. I’ll stop). Reminds me. I guess I could eat pizza again for the 7th day in a row… I always seem to go at the bustiest, I meant “busiest” time. For some unknown reason…
… more
lakhi singh
They make awesome pizzas,salads,desserts.i never get this taste on another place.i would say try this awesome pizza from Newyork pizza.they are very respectable persons.
… more
HK C
We have ordered pizza many times from here. I wasn’t sure if I should give a two star or three. This USED to be an almost five star place. We used to love the fresh hot pizza delivered to our house. Now it takes over an hour to arrive and the pizza is not hot. Tonight we actually microwaved our “fresh, not so hot pizza”. This was sad and disappointing. NY Pizza has been our go to pizza place for years. I’m not sure what changed. I can say… the toppings, cheese and crust is still as good as it was before. It’s just much better when it does not arrive cold.
… more
Baaz Singh
Best for the price. Very consistent every time.
… more
Spencer Ching
Medium prices for a giant single slice of pizza. They make each slice fresh by pre-making the dough and cutting only what they need for topping each single slice order so that every customer has a fresh single slice. Fair warning the fresh pizza has burned my mouth many times so let it cool for five minutes before ingestion.
… more
… View more