Based on 491 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup
Address:
3265 PA-115, Effort, PA 18330
Phone: (570) 629-1998
Website: http://www.mikes-pizzeria.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cynthia Herbert
I used to love ordering the pizza and calamari from here but I guess the new owners don’t believe in giving a full plate of food. Charging over $10 for this plate?!?! I thought this was a joke or a mistake on their part, but i had 2 other calamari orders and when I opened it all the other orders looked just as bad. I wish I would have opened this at the shop because I would have just left. And at that, the food was bland. No way to run a business
… more
Brenda Rand
I use to love their pies but ordered a “Taco Pizza” and 2 rice balls. Was a waste of $35. The pizza was overpowering with garlic. We could not even finish a slice it was so bad. Thr rice balls were a huge disappointment also. They were like balls of dough with very little filling, and where’s the rice? Definitely lost my business!!
… more
Sarah Kowalczyk
Used to love coming here until they put a rude woman at the front counter. I always would ask what slices were there with no problem, until I got attitude for it. Makes me not even wanna go in, sad.
… more
George VanderMeulen
Have only been here once…and I live .2 miles away. Like many of the other complaints…staff is rude…you stand there waiting and they won’t even acknowledge you. Food was average at best… And expensive. They nickel and dime you and cut corners. They took my $ once… Never again. I’ll give my $ to the Chinese place right next door…at least they are pleasant…and don’t charge 29 cents for a pack of soy sauce.
… more
Jennie Catherine Lyons
Best Pizza Around!! Wonderful Staff!! The pasta dishes are made to order every time and never disappoint. Consistently providing quality food that keeps you coming back for more!!
… more
West Jr
Went on a Sunday, only 4 tables of people and yet we stood around for 10 minutes without acknowledgment or being assured we would be sat shortly. Blank stares from the staff as we waited. This place is understaffed or needs better staff. Maybe people of color aren’t good enough to eat at this pizzeria in the middle of nowhere.
… more
Richard Mazzotta
Was in the Poconos with the boys on a golf trip, we landed on getting grub from Mikes, was a solid endeavor. Good take out is hit or miss in that area and Mikes didn’t disappoint. The order was timely and correct…wings, cheese steaks, let’s go.
… more
Jennie Catherine Lyons
Delicious Food Every Time! Best Pizza in this Area The Stromboli’s, the Pasta Dishes, the Zeppoles!!
… more
Ryan Scott
We used to live in this town and came home to vist my father. Mikes has been a staple in the area since the dawn of time. We decided to meet up here and have some lunch while we caught up on things. Upon arrival the place was a ghost town. We walked in and realized they were open for takeout only. This was the same for quite a few other places in the area. I’ve had some great meals at this place between both current locations and the old location on 209. Big time disappointed.
… more
Lee Fishman
Moved to the area from about 25 minutes away. We had Mike’s pizza randomly one night while we were moving. It’s the best pizza I’ve had in the Poconos, a sweet sauce and good quality cheese that doesn’t get super greasy. I would like it a little crispier, but that’s personal preference. I’m very picky about what non-healthy foods I eat, and I make an exception for Mike’s pizza every single time. I’m actually going to pick up a large pie with garlic knots right now haha. Ok bye.
… more
… View more