Based on 205 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
434 Pine St, Mt Holly, NJ 08060
Phone: (609) 267-7409
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: taptoeat.com
Reviews
Jay Frigon
It was pretty good food. Not my favorite tomato sauce, but overall good. It’s geared around take out, there are only 2 small tables.
… more
M. J. Young
My son use to rave about the steak sandwiches here, and we were in the neighborhood so we stopped. The mini steak was good, ample meat and a good balance of lightly fried onions and cheese on a very soft sesame roll. The onion rings have a crunchy panko breading, and are above average. The soup du jour was shrimp bisque, which I thought very good and my wife thought was the best soup she has ever had. It came with a chunk of thickly sliced French bread, soft and warm. Marinara sauce came with the onion rings, which my wife tried and said it tasted very much of tomato and could use salt and garlic. However, high marks overall, wishing it were closer to home.
… more
Natoya Coleman
I love there cheesesteaks so delicious and one of the very few places that still serve crinkle cut fries plz don’t ever stop serving them they perfect well with a delicious cheesesteak. Cheesesteaks are huge and meaty bread is so soft everyone knows a good cheesesteak has good tasting steak and the bread makes it or ruins it well they got it perfectly good job chefs
… more
Kiera Walker
I ordered a cheeseburger, and this is what I received. The person who took my order asked me questions about the size I wanted, which I did not understood. I told them a regular cheeseburger like you would get at McDonald’s. Mind you, when you order a cheeseburger there’s usually no confusion in what you mean! I should have checked my bag when I picked up my food but didn’t until I got home. I had to argue with someone on the phone about how I supposedly asked for a small burger so that’s what I got. I told him I’ve ordered there multiple times before and have never had any confusion nor received anything like this before. There was also someone on the phone playing a middle person. Whoever was in charge should have had the decency to speak to me directly! Instead of them accommodating me and having someone deliver me a proper burger with the refund from the difference in pricing, I had to drive all the way back just to be questioned about what we just spoke on the phone about! The man winded up giving me my money back with an attitude. This experience has left a bad taste in my mouth, and I won’t be eating from here again.
… more
James Miller
Im sick and tired of ordering no seeds on the rolls and getting seeds. We dont like them and they always do it. And the girl who answers the phone always does this. If you dont have seedless rolls fine, just tell us. I will not be ordering again from this place, i dont want the aggravation. The Lucky 7 has better hoagies anyway
… more
Harvey Brown (kiyo531)
Great food. Courteous fast service. Limited seating.
… more
slliks67
This is what i opened and low and behold garbaged chicken cheesesteak, where you have to ask for everything to be chopped toasted or what have you, the supposed hot peppers were so mild i thought they were green peppers i will never go there again the are doing a disservice to the gaetano name in a big way. Chicken tenders were to dry for smh crinkle fries were good and thats it. dont waste your money, now i know how gordon ramsay feels with these chefs who show no love in the culinary craft. fork this place. mt holly gaetanos is trash
… more
Samantha Park
Great local pizza shop. We order fairly often and everything is good. Wings are always large and we’ll cooked. White pizza has plenty of garlic, very flavorful. One of the best cheesesteaks in the area, order a large and you’ll be eating it for days. Skip the fries though, dry flavorless and soggy.
… more
Nico Morley
This is where I go if I want a cheese steak and fries. Don’t order the large unless you plan to share, or you’re a hero.
… more
Joel Barry
BE AWARE…they charge you 4% if you use a credit or debit card. I can understand a credit card but not a debit card. I didn’t see a sign that tells you that. I don’t know of any other restaurant or take out that does. I have been coming here for years and this was the first time I used my debit card. Needless to say, they lost my business. I’m sure they don’t care.
… more
… View more