A family-run fixture since 1958, this corner pizzeria offers brick-oven pizza & traditional pastas. Based on 301 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
6001 Park Ave, West New York, NJ 07093
Phone: (201) 861-2000
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: originalprestospizzanj.com
Reviews
nandani madhukar
We loved this place that we went twice in a week…!
… more
Ixchel Says
Great Garlic knots, ok pizza. But the girl that was today upfront really has an attitude that kills your appetite customer service needs to improvement
… more
Cougarific
Just had a very unsatisfactory experience with an extremely rude woman behind the counter.
… more
Mauro Briceno
I am so disappointed of this place; I ordered a Medium Margarita Pizza and added Mushrooms. The price, $28.50 for a Medium Pizza . They took over 1 hour to Deliver the pizza, I still tipped the driver and gave him a pen because he didn’t have a pen and my pizza arrived cold.
… more
Damian Hernandez
Nice to see the cook and owner smoking right by the entrance of the pizzeria. NJ law is clear, 25 feet from the main door. I’m sure they don’t wash their hands either. I grew up eating at Presto’s back when the original owners managed the place. Then the son took over and it remained fairly similar because the mother would come and cook and oversee the business. Now, the current owner is hardly ever there. They serve you the pizza after grabbing coins and cash, against board of health policy. The quality of the food is poor, no parking available. No air conditioner during summer and in the winter you freeze. The place is just poor overall quality. Take the ride and go to Sal’s Pizza in Bergenline Ave. Better quality, service and parking available.
… more
Billi Bee
WHOA ! Easily one of the Best Veggie Pizzas I’ve ever eaten ! .. Before trying it I added garlic & pepper & it was PREFECT! Way better then one would expect from a veggie pizza
… more
Katie Ferrigno
My favorite neighborhood gem. Best margarita pie around. The sauce is delicious and the pesto brings it home.
… more
Tylor Clemons
This is my go-to pizza place. The slices at the counter are always great but make sure you get there early in the week if you want a Sicilian slice as they go quick for good reason. Most recently we got a cheese steak and their lobster ravioli. Cheese steak was good but the ravioli was great. And that sauce… Will definitely order again
… more
Brishell Aquise
Food is good as always but recently the service has not been good. 2 weeks in a row food has not been ready on time and has been way late.
… more
Mike Cummings
I never write reviews but to better explain this one i need to give you a quick background. My mother is 100% Italian and a phenomenal cook. She moved to Florida recently and actually opened an Italian restaurant .This had me searching for great Italian food locally. Last Night I was craving my absolute favorite, Eggplant Parm Hero. I’ve tried multiple places around the area to no avail. I decided to call Presto’s last night, (Original Prestos Pizza 6001 Park Ave. West New York, NJ) when I called and placed the order the person on the phone said I’m gonna love it. I told him no one makes a quality eggplant parm in this area, just my opinion. Turns out I was talking to the Owner Joe on the phone , super nice and friendly, assured me I was gonna love it and to call him back once I got it. When the order came it was so much better than expected. Still hot, bread toasted to perfection the eggplant was thin sliced and breaded not old and mushy. so Much flavor in the sauce and eggplant itself. It was so Delicious that I didn’t have time to take a picture, I kinda just devoured it. I called back Joe and told him he was absolutely right and now has a new customer. I’m excited to try more things on the Menu.
… more
… View more