Casual restaurant offering NY-style pizzas, subs & pastas, with delivery available. Based on 783 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
825 Seaway Dr, Fort Pierce, FL 34949
Phone: (772) 460-6022
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Tj
The store was extremely well kept and clean. The pizza was very good and my kids loved it. prices were decent and staff was friendly. i suggest calling ahead to order it can get busy. will definitely be back!
… more
Stacy Andersen
We had the taco pizza it was amazing.
… more
Tyneshaa Gerald
Last night I called in an order which was completely wrong, when I called them up to inform them, they were closed. Today I called to speak to a manager Alfonso or Alfredo something like that. I told him the situation, he advised me with a hostile tone “because it happened last night there was nothing I could do, most people call back when their order is wrong” I let him know they were closed I called at 10:10pm and no one answered. He also told me “it’s Friday and I’m super busy” I don’t recommend.
… more
linda harms
Last time I throw my $ away paid 2.70 per topping for one olive 1 mushroom a piece of onion cold under cooked pizza called talked to manager he said next time I order will give me free topping I won’t be ordering from Goodfellas on seaway drive again! We Tj yo yard yo throw away $30
… more
Jeff Combs
Good pizza, but a very poor app. Offers you the option to pre-order for a specific delivery time, but pizza comes as soon as it’s ready, regardless of what time you choose ((. And twice now after creating an account, my account disappeared.
… more
Christy Davis
We ate there twice while on vacation. Food was great!
… more
Chris tinnel
Repeatedly asked for 2 ketchup and some salt to be added to my delivery of a steak bomb sub. Finally on last sub I ordered I received 2ketchup packs. But still no salt. When I order food as expensive as they are I expect to get what I order. $17.75 for sub plus I tip driver $3. So 14.75 for sub and fries. I don’t penalize driver for order taker failure. Plus they used less meat on my last delivery 4 days ago. Step up guys. Or my business goes back to five guys. Prefer their fries to yours anyway. Meat lovers pizza was delicious . Have a blessed day
… more
Chrissy Tate
I ordered two slices of pizza. Received them and they were old slices where new toppings were added. Pizza was extremely greasy. I called in and was told that the food could be replaced. I get there and he makes me repeat again what’s wrong with pizza and essentially belittled me saying things like “well, it’s pizza, not salad, it’s gonna be greasy”, and when I’d start my response he’d interrupt and say “but it’s okay, I’ll replace it, what do you want, what do you want?” Just rude to say the least. I was tempted to ask for my money back. I’ve ordered from this company many times and I’ve never had an issue, but from the customer service I received today, they will never get a red cent out of me again. HIRE BETTER MANAGEMENT WHO KNOW HOW TO SPEAK TO CUSTOMERS. Forgive me for not wanting recycled pizza.
… more
Audra Lewis
Best pizza on the island! So many varieties to choose from and a lovely ocean view with amazing customer service! As well as a clean place to dine. Will most definitely be back! Highly recommended
… more
Amarilis Rodriguez
Good food. Rude cashier. She was rushing (the place was not busy). Not paying attention to what we were ordering. Which caused her to miss things and when we went back to re order she had already forgotten that she had JUST taken our order. Not focused not paying attention not good for business.
… more
… View more