We are a family owned Pizzeria that not only loves Pizza and Italian food, but we love what we do and love our customers and staff. This is why we only use top fresh ingredients that not only our customers love, but our family as well. We love what we do and have a little fun as well while we are doing it. Come and check us out and you will see that we are more than just a Pizzeria. You can also follow us on Facebook and Instagram.
New York-style pies, spaghetti & other Italian fare at a laid-back pizzeria with table seating. Based on 308 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
13518 Summerport Village Pkwy, Windermere, FL 34786
Phone: (407) 654-5291
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jonathan Herd
My wife and I wanted something low key but nice for a casual celebration at home of our six month wedding anniversary and decided to try somewhere new to us but right around the corner and could not have been happier. I’m sad how long I lived here before trying them out as the quality of food you get for the price point is very worth it. While we only entered to pick up not eat in, the environment felt like the kind of local spot that I want to support over large chains that live off their big name rather than their quality. We got fried mushrooms, chicken parmigiana with penne and a hangover pizza with zeppolis. Couldn’t be happier.
… more
Doug Stroud
A very nice family run pizza place! I had one of their daily specials which consisted of two slices with one topping and a fountain drink, I opted for bottled water. The pizza was quick fresh and delicious and they even had some Mikes hot honey to add to the slices! You could tell the family that makes pizzas together stays together. There was a very nice, polite young man who was attending the customers and taking the orders. The family who appeared to be maybe a dad or granddad who was the master craftsman, then his kids or grandkids were helping in the back! Anyways very nice to see and the food was awesome, the place was clean. Only thing is curb appeal as it is located in the strip area of cornerstone and they have a sign missing, but don’t let that detour you it was great!
… more
Pete N. (The EVP)
The pizza here is very good. Personally, I love reheated slices over fresh ones because the cigar gets really crispy. The pizza could use a little more sauce on it. But other than that, it’s really good pizza and I would really recommend it.
… more
Brittany B
I’ve been going here for about 7 years or so and I absolutely love their pizza but the thing that irks me so much hence my 3 star review is that when you order their spaghetti, they give you one little spoonful of sauce. It doesn’t even cover half the noodles?!? Then you have to pay $1.60 for extra sauce and that still doesn’t even cover it. Not having sauce that covers the whole pasta is unacceptable. We’ve ordered the spaghetti over 10 times and it’s always this way. We are finally done wasting our money on this. Also, they don’t offer curbside pickup during a global pandemic.
… more
Administration
I have to be fair and consistent with pizza ratings. If Antica Pizza in Maitland is a 5 star, then this is 2 star. The employees were very nice and the pizza was prepared on time. There is nothing personal with this rating. The dough was floppy (no backbone) and the slices were very oily (requiring a quick napkin mopping). The cheese and sauce tasted ok. So, nothing really wrong, just a very “bar pie” experience. If you need a quick pie resembling the NY style….go for it, but better pies in the area.
… more
I M
I ordered two 18” pies a Buffalo chicken pizza and a BBQ Hawaiian pizza. Overall, the tastes was okay. Not the best pizza I’ve had and it doesn’t really compare to New York pizza so I do think the name is misleading. But that’s just my opinion.
… more
Jonathan Robinson
Fantastic family owned shop! The best pizza I have ever had, extremely good service and atmosphere. We are making this a regular destination when we visit Disney or universal.
… more
Ramon Soto
This is one of the best slices of pizza I’ve ever had in my life!!! THE HANGOVER PIZZA IS A MUST TRY!!!! 10/10 Hands down
… more
fencewonders
Took way too long. The pizza is drenched in oil and doesn’t taste good. I got the grandmas pie and garlic rolls. Neither were good at all. Will not be going back. Not worth the time or the cost!! Also when I arrived they said 10 more minutes and it would be done, while 3 guests walked in behind me and were told 15-25 minutes for their stuff. I left and came back 10 minutes later and still not done and the other people were still waiting and all of them got there stuff before me, and I had to wait another 20 minutes!!
… more
Jennifer Garcia
Customer service is A+! Very nice friendly calm atmosphere.
… more
… View more