For Papa Johns Pizza in Evans Mills, NY, the secret to success is much like the secret to making a better pizza – the more you put into it, the more you get out of it. Whether it’s our signature sauce, toppings, our original fresh dough, or even the box itself, we invest in our ingredients to ensure that we always give you the finest quality pizza. For you, it’s not just Better Ingredients. Better Pizza. It’s a family gathering, memorable birthday, work celebration or simply a great meal. It’s our goal to make sure you always have the best ingredients for every occasion. Call us at (315) 629-4550 for delivery or stop by US Route 11 for carryout to order your favorite, pizza, breadsticks, or wings today!
Pizza take-out & delivery chain offering classic & specialty pizzas, plus wings, sides & desserts. Based on 162 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
26000 US-11, Evans Mills, NY 13637
Phone: (315) 629-4550
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kalista Albano-Gonzales
The pizza was fantastic as always. Unfortunately we ran into problems with the staff and our delivery. We had ordered our food and everything was great! We then get a notification that our order had been delivered. We checked outside and saw no one or our order. We attempted to call this Papa John’s several times, and we received no answer. I called and had my husband call as well. Anyways, since we didn’t get a call back and the app said it was delivered, we checked our neighboring apartments and no one had our orders. We then decided to drive to the Papa John’s just in case the order was delivered to another person. We got in and was greeted. We explained our situation and the employee attempted to call our delivery driver. She got no answer from him but continued to call. She was finally able to get ahold of him and he was at our apartments. She asked if we wanted him to come back or for us to meet him. We decided to drive back to meet him. My husband explained that this was sort of an inconvenience, as we were told it was delivered and since we could not find our order or the delivery driver, we had to drive back. She said something about having to clock the driver back in so he could bring another order to another house on the way to our apartment and that is why the app said it was delivered. My husband then continued to tell her that he understood what she was saying but that it told us that it was delivered and we had no order we drove back. Then I mentioned that both of us had called their phone number several times and received no answer and then made the decision to drive there. The employee asked what number we called and I showed her the number. She said that we must have called the incorrect number because they didn’t get any phone calls. The employee didn’t know the number. She had to look through receipts to find it and then continued to blame it on us and the phone call not going through. Unfortunately, there was nothing done on their end to make the situation better. The employee had a belligerent attitude the moment we tried to explain what happened. The delivery man, Micheal, was kind enough to wait for us and we appreciated it tremendously. He was very positive and had a kind attitude. He apologized for the situation. We thanked him for his kindness:-)
… more
Annamae Scheffy
I ordered pizza for an employee lunch with 1 hour 20 minute notice and paid over the phone. It never showed up. They explained that their delivery driver called in. If they would of called me I would of just picked it up. Ended up getting a refund as everyone on my team lunch was already over. Very disappointing.
… more
M Green
Ordered a pizza that was suppose to be well done. It was burnt. The crust was harder than cardboard and everything else was rubbery. Not to mention I did not get the extra garlic sauce I ordered.
… more
Ashley Litle
Cheesy stuffed crust with extra cheese, spicy Italian sausage, and olives. It was delivered in under 40 minutes and the driver was super friendly.
… more
MSJ
I placed an order for take out, it wasn’t a good experience. Spider on the window, lady screaming at the screen while making pizza to stop ordering, guy throws out a perfectly good pizza because wrong order.
… more
Morgan Owens
Horrible service, after waiting 1.5 hours we called to check on our order only to be told it would be there in 5-10 minutes. After another 30 minutes we called back after 2 hours of waiting only to be told they used door dash to deliver our pizza and had no idea where it was. If I wanted to use door dash i would have done so, i ordered from papa johns expecting them to deliver not to hand my order off to someone who never showed up.
… more
wolfenboomer
The entire staff was simply amazing. Even suggesting I use online ordering to find a supper meal coupon that would best serve my family. The instore atmosphere is warm and welcoming. The food hot and clearly made with passion and care. THANK YOU!
… more
John Trevino
Ordering online is convenient. Pizza is what you would expect from this type of chain. Delivery is available within a certain radius of the store.
… more
Al E
I’ve eaten here for at least 10 years. They have their pizza times down to a science. I’ve always had great pizza and appetizers from this location. Not much to say about this location. Courteous service. They always have the orders prepared on time, never messed up my orders and the food has always been good. The few times the pizza was going to be awhile, like Super Bowl Sunday, they let me know in advance when I ordered.
… more
DAWN Taylor
Placed order, an hour later still had not gotten it. Manager delivered to us 10 minutes after we called to find out where it was. All his help left and he continued to prepare the orders they had taken and deliver. Food was out of this world. Will order again
… more
… View more