Formaggio's Pizzeria Menu

Welcome to Formaggio’s Pizzeria, home of real authentic, Brooklyn-style Italian cuisine, conveniently located in the heart of Madison, NJ. When you dine at Formaggio’s Pizzeria, you’re eating fresh ingredients that are prepared to order! Our traditional, Brooklyn-style Italian cuisine is prepared with you in mind. We pride ourselves on having tasty entrees and the most amazing pizza that Madison, NJ has to offer. Our family-friendly environment invites you to bring the whole crew along to enjoy a meal together. Check out our menu and get ready to experience a whole new way to eat Italian!

Based on 29 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Formaggio's Pizzeria 07940

Address:
36 Main St, Madison, NJ 07940

Phone: (973) 377-7161

Website:

Hours

Tuesday	11 AM–9 PM
Wednesday	11 AM–9 PM
Thursday	11 AM–9 PM
Friday	11 AM–9 PM
Saturday	11 AM–9 PM
Sunday	12–9 PM
Monday	11 AM–9 PM

Best Sellers
Cheese Pizza Classic cheese or create your own pizza.	$10.95
Soda	$1.50
Mozzarella Sticks	$7.95
Pizza
Cheese Pizza Classic cheese or create your own pizza.	$10.95
Sicilian Cheese Pizza Classic cheese or create your own pizza.	$18.95
Gourmet Pizzas
Upside Down Sicilian Pizza Mozzarella cheese on the bottom & sauce on top.	$21.95
Buffalo Chicken Pizza Buffalo chicken, mozzarella cheese,shredded cheddar & drizzled with ranch or blue cheese.	$21.95
Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza Mozzarella cheese, Monterey Jack cheese, breaded chicken, bacon & ranch.	$21.95
White Pizza Mozzarella, ricotta & Parmesan.	$18.95
Grandma’s Pizza Thin crust, hand-stretched pan pizza with fresh herbed San Marzano tomatoes & mozzarella.	$21.95
Drunken Grandma Pizza Vodka sauce & cherry tomatoes topped with fresh mozzarella.	$22.95
Meat Lover’s Pizza Meatball, sausage & pepperoni.	$22.95
Veggie Pizza Eggplant, onion, tomatoes, zucchini, broccoli & mushroom.	$22.95
Hot Honey Pepperoni Pizza	$18.95
Bruschetta Pizza Topped with basil, onions, garlic, tomatoes & mozzarella.	$21.95
Margherita Pizza Crushed tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & basil.	$21.95
Philly Cheesesteak Pizza Topped with steak, peppers & onions.	$24.95
Paisano’s Special Pizza Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onion & mushroom.	$22.95
Brooklyn Pizza Mozzarella cheese topped with our famous sauce & Parmesan cheese.	$16.95
Stuffed Pizza Sausage, pepperoni, pepper, mushrooms & onion with another dough on top.	$24.95
Pizza Fina Very thin crust.	$7.95
Cauliflower Crust Pizza	$14.95
Gluten-Free Pizza	$14.95
Hawaiian Pizza Ham, pineapple, mozzarella & no sauce.	$21.95
Chicken Caesar Pizza	$21.95
4 Cheese Pizza Ricotta, mozzarella, provolone & parmesan cheese.	$22.95
Pizza By The Slice
Cheese Pizza Slice	$2.50
Sicilian Pizza Slice	$2.85
Gourmet Pizza Slice	$3.50
Appetizers
Sausage	$7.95
Meatballs	$7.95
Chicken Fingers Served with French fries.	$10.95
Fried Calamari Crispy calamari served with a side of sweet or hot marinara sauce.	$12.95
Mussels Marinara Served in sweet, medium, or hot marinara sauce.	$12.95
Mozzarella Sticks	$7.95
French Fries	$3.75
Cheese Fries	$4.75
Buffalo Fries Fries tossed in hot sauce & baked with mozzarella topped with blue cheese.	$5.75
Hot Wings Spicy chicken wings served with a side of ranch.	$10.95
Garlic Knots	$3.50
Garlic Bread	$3.95
Garlic Bread With Cheese	$4.95
Zucchini Sticks	$7.95
Rice Balls Filled with rice, chopped meat & peas.	$12.95
Bruschetta Toasted Italian-style bread topped with a medley of chopped tomatoes, fresh basil, onion, garlic & balsamic vinaigrette.	$7.95
Broccoli Rabe With Garlic & Oil	$9.95
Broccoli Rabe With Sausage, Garlic & Oil	$12.95
Shrimp Peeps Served with spicy marinara sauce	$12.95
Fire Cracker Calamari Tossed in hot cherry peppers with a side of marinara sauce.	$14.95
Soups
Tortellini In Brodo Soup Cheese tortellini in rich chicken broth.	$6.95
Pasta E Fagioli Soup	$6.95
Salads
Antipasto Salad Lettuce, tomatoes, olives, salami, provolone, ham, giardiniera, peppers & eggs.	$12.95
Mozzarella Caprese Salad Sliced tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & house-made roasted peppers, drizzled with balsamic.	$9.95
Caesar Salad Made with traditional Caesar dressing & homemade croutons.	$7.95
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Our traditional Caesar salad is topped with freshly grilled chicken.	$12.95
House Salad Lettuce, tomatoes, olives, oil & vinegar.	$7.95
Grilled Chicken House Salad Our traditional House salad topped with freshly grilled chicken.	$12.95
The Alexa Salad Grilled chicken, black olives, tomatoes, fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers.	$12.95
The Olivia Salad Pepperoni, fresh mozzarella, cucumbers, tomatoes & black olives, all chopped up.	$10.95
Buffalo Chicken Salad Bed of greens topped with breaded buffalo chicken & blue cheese dressing.	$12.95
Greek Salad Feta cheese, cucumbers, tomatoes, black olives, red onion & lettuce, all chopped up.	$12.95
Mixed Green Salad With fresh tomatoes & mozzarella.	$10.95
Chef Salad Ham, turkey, provolone & American over a house salad.	$10.95
Cranberry Romaine Walnut Salad Romaine, sweet dried cranberries, fresh mozzarella & house dressing.	$10.95
Family Salad Lettuce, tomatoes, olives, carrots, peppers & onion mixed with house dressing.	$10.95
Chopped Family Salad Same as a family salad but chopped.	$10.95
Mixed Green Salad With Salmon	$16.95
Strombolis & Calzones
Cheese Calzone Ricotta cheese & mozzarella.	$8.95
Ham & Cheese Calzone Ham, ricotta cheese & mozzarella.	$10.95
Pepperoni Roll Pepperoni & mozzarella.	$9.95
Stromboli Sausage, pepperoni, peppers, onions & mushrooms.	$8.95
Sausage Roll Sausage, peppers, onions & cheese.	$9.95
Chicken Roll Chicken cutlet & mozzarella.	$9.95
Spinach Roll Sauteed spinach & mozzarella.	$9.95
Buffalo Chicken Roll Chicken cutlet tossed in hot sauce with mozzarella.	$9.95
Hot Subs
Meatball Sub	$8.95
Sausage Sub	$8.95
Meatball Parmesan Sub	$10.95
Sausage Parmesan Sub	$10.95
Eggplant Parmesan Sub	$10.95
Buffalo Chicken Sub Chicken cutlet tossed in Buffalo sauce, topped with lettuce & ranch.	$10.95
Belly Buster Sub Steak, French fries, mozzarella sticks & chicken fingers with lite tomato sauce & melted mozzarella.	$12.95
Grilled Chicken Sub Freshly grilled chicken with lettuce, tomatoes & onion.	$10.95
Chicken, Broccoli Rabe & Provolone Sub	$10.95
Sausage, Peppers & Onion Sub	$10.95
Cheesesteak Sub With peppers & onion with French fries.	$12.95
Grilled Chicken Sub With Fresh Arugula Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers, drizzled with balsamic glaze.	$12.95
Grilled Chicken Florentine Sub Sautéed spinach with melted provolone cheese & balsamic glaze.	$12.95
Eggplant Sub With Fresh Mozzarella Fresh mozzarella & roasted peppers drizzle with balsamic glaze.	$12.95
Chicken Parm Sub With Vodka Sauce	$12.95
Chicken Parmesan Sub	$10.95
Veal Parmesan Sub	$10.95
Cold Subs
Fresh Mozzarella Sub With Arugula With house-made roasted peppers.	$9.95
Turkey & Cheese Sub Provolone or American.	$10.95
Tuna Sub	$10.95
Tuna Melt Sub	$12.95
Chicken Cutlet Sub With lettuce, tomatoes & mayo.	$12.95
Jimmy’s Special Sub Ham, salami & provolone.	$9.95
Burgers
Hamburger With lettuce & tomatoes.	$8.95
Cheeseburger With lettuce, tomatoes & cheese.	$9.95
Bacon Cheeseburger With lettuce, tomatoes, cheese & bacon.	$12.95
Wraps
Grilled Chicken Caesar Salad Wrap Tossed with Romaine lettuce & Caesar dressing.	$12.95
Buffalo Chicken Wrap Grilled chicken with lettuce, tomatoes & blue cheese dressing.	$12.95
Turkey Wrap Sliced breast of turkey with bacon, tomatoes & mayo.	$12.95
Tuna Wrap Fresh store-made tuna.	$12.95
Grilled Chicken Wrap Arugula, roasted peppers, fresh mozzarella & balsamic.	$12.95
Pastas
Pasta With Tomato Sauce	$8.95
Pasta With Meatballs	$14.95
Pasta With Sausage	$14.95
Pasta With Butter Sauce	$8.95
Pasta With Marinara Sauce	$10.95
Pasta With Garlic & Oil	$10.95
Pasta With Meat Sauce	$14.95
Pasta With Broccoli Garlic & Oil	$10.95
Cheese Ravioli Ricotta cheese & mozzarella.	$10.95
Penne Alla Vodka Homemade creamy vodka sauce.	$12.95
Penne Vodka With Chicken	$14.95
Cavatelli, Chicken & Broccoli Made with sauteed broccoli in a garlic sauce.	$14.95
Fettuccini Alfredo Fettuccini tossed in rich cream sauce.	$12.95
Pasta & Pesto Sauce Fresh basil, pignoli & Parmesan cheese.	$12.95
Puttanesca Sauce Capers, garlic & olives in a light marinara sauce.	$12.95
Cheese Tortellini In Tomato Sauce	$12.95
Cheese Tortellini In Alfredo Sauce	$14.95
Cheese Tortellini In Vodka Sauce	$14.95
Pasta Carbonara Bacon & onion in a cream sauce.	$14.95
Pasta Primavera Vegetables in a pink vodka sauce.	$14.95
Pasta Formaggio Garlic, cherry tomatoes & sun-dried tomatoes in light garlic oil sauce.	$14.95
Baked Pastas
Baked Stuffed Shells Stuffed shells, covered in mozzarella & baked.	$12.95
Baked Manicotti Ricotta cheese & mozzarella.	$12.95
Baked Ziti Ricotta cheese & mozzarella.	$12.95
Baked Ravioli Covered in mozzarella & baked.	$12.95
Lasagna Layers of pasta with meat & ricotta cheese.	$12.95
Eggplant Parmesan Pasta	$14.95
Eggplant Rollatini Homemade eggplant stuffed with ricotta cheese, tomato sauce & melted mozzarella.	$16.95
Entrees
Veal Parmesan Red tomato sauce in melted mozzarella cheese.	$16.95
Chicken Francese Lemon white wine butter sauce.	$16.95
Chicken Parmesan Red tomato sauce in melted mozzarella cheese.	$16.95
Chicken Marsala Chicken in a Marsala & wine mushroom sauce.	$16.95
Chicken Piccata Chicken in a lemon caper sauce.	$16.95
Chicken Murphy Chicken breast sautéed in lite white wine sauce with potatoes, hot peppers & onion.	$16.95
Chicken Scarpariello Chicken breast sauteed with sausage, potatoes, vinegar, onion & peppers.	$16.95
Shrimp Scampi Pasta in a lemon white wine sauce.	$17.95
Shrimp Marinara In spicy red sauce.	$17.95
Chicken & Broccoli Pieces of chicken & broccoli sautéed a white wine or red sauce. With spaghetti or penne.	$16.95
Chicken Olivia Chicken breast with eggplant, fresh roasted peppers & mozzarella in a Marsala sauce.	$16.95
Chicken Alexa Chicken tossed with penne in fresh marinara sauce.	$16.95
Chicken Pizzaiola Chicken breast sauteed with onions, peppers, black olives & mushrooms in a red sauce.	$16.95
Linguine With White Clam Sauce	$17.95
Linguine With Red Clam Sauce	$17.95
Seafood Tarrentino Mussels, clams, shrimp & calamari served in a light tomato sauce.	$24.95
Desserts
Fresh Filled Cannoli	$4.95
Nutella Pizza	$14.95
Beverages
Soda	$1.50
Gatorade	$3.00
Catering Appetizers
Chicken Fingers Catering	$40.00
Buffalo Wings Catering	$35.00
Mozzarella Sticks Catering	$40.00
Mussels Marinara Catering Chafing trays.	$45.00
Catering Salads
Caesar Salad Catering	$30.00
Caesar Salad With Grilled Chicken Catering	$45.00
House Salad Catering	$35.00
Chef Salad Catering	$30.00
Cold Antipasto Salad Catering	$40.00
Catering Sandwich Platters
Party Sub Platter Catering Choice of ham, salami, turkey, provolone, or American cheese with lettuce, tomatoes, onions, oil & vinegar.	$69.50
Catering Pastas
Baked Ziti Catering	$45.00
Stuffed Shells Catering	$45.00
Pasta Vodka Catering	$45.00
Pasta Primavera Catering	$45.00
Lasagna Catering	$45.00
Manicotti Catering	$45.00
Penne With Broccoli Rabe & Sausage Catering	$45.00
Penne With Grilled Chicken In Light Marinara Catering	$45.00
Penne With Broccoli In Olive Oil & Garlic Catering	$45.00
Catering Our Specialties
Sausage & Peppers Catering	$45.00
Homemade Italian Meatballs Catering	$45.00
Eggplant Parmigiana Catering	$45.00
Catering Chicken
Chicken Francese Catering	$50.00
Chicken With Broccoli Catering	$50.00
Chicken Marsala Catering	$50.00
Chicken Piccata Catering	$50.00
Chicken Primavera Catering	$50.00
Chicken Parmigiana Catering	$50.00

… View more

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Chris A

Pizza was fine, nothing to really complain about but there are some local spots i like better..

… more

D Luttinger

Had a delicious dinner right before close, service was great and the food was delicious

… more

Peggysue Parella

What a great place. Pizza was amazing. Staff was so nice. Owner came over to see how everything was. Great place !

… more

Valentina Solorzano

I was so pleased to find out that this pizzeria is under new management/owner. The atmosphere has become much more welcoming. The new owner provided exceptional customer service, and all the employees were kind. Most importantly, the food was DELICIOUS. The Drunken Grandma pie was scrumptious, and the mushroom pie was also great. I have been back twice since the first time I tried it three weeks ago. All in all, a great place to eat at for a casual dinner with family or for a nice night in eating pizza and watching a movie.

… more

Tyler Juhl

Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had! Staff was great and super friendly. Highly recommend.

… more

J. H.

Amazing, friendly, attentive staff. Absolutely perfect pizza. Seriously the best I’ve had over 30 years across the tri-state. Best meatballs we’ve ever had too. Eat here and you’ll be ruined for anywhere else.

… more

Rick

I did not enjoy this pizza. I felt rushed while dining it. Other places in the area are better

… more

Lisa Juhl

Best pizza around! Chicken parmigiana was also delicious. They even have Nutella pizza if you want a sweet treat. Highly recommend.

… more

Jessica D

food was so good! place was so clean and the service was great! also the chickenparm sandwhich was really good!

… more

Pat Meola

The best chicken parm I’ve ever had. The Sicilian pizza was delicious also. I will be returning here

… more

… View more

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Formaggio’s Pizzeria Menu – Madison, NJ

Hours

Menu

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Related:

Leave a Comment Cancel reply

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions