Based on 108 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price
✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No dine-in ✔️ No delivery
Address:
279 IN-60, Mitchell, IN 47446
Phone: (812) 849-6168
Hours
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–9 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Shadow Kane
Great location, not a big corporate business, owned by people that have lived in this town for well over 20 years friendly staff. owner works right behind the counter.
… more
Melanie G
We wanted to grab a quick bite while camping and Edna’s didn’t disappoint! It was even delicious the next morning reheated over the campfire. Definitely recommend.
… more
Glenn Strickland
The pizza was very good, topping galore. Loved it. Do recommend.
… more
Dave McClure
Fantastic pizza! The crust has great texture, crispy enough to hold up the toppings and light enough not to fill you up too quickly. The sauce is on point, not too sweet, not too much, not too spicy.
… more
Ashley Austin
Camped close by and wanted to grab pizza . Picked a local place , customer service was very poor . I ordered two pizzas and they only heard one . I wouldn’t have minded as much but we drove an hour and didn’t have any options once we got there . Lady behind the counter emphasized multiple times she repeated my order over the phone. Made no effort to try and fix the situation saying I’d need to wait an additional 20 minutes. If you are coming from out of town pick a different pizza place .
… more
Nikkie Blue Eyes
The lady working was pretty rude. While we were placing our order an angry customer called and she was yelling at him to call Edna. The food was good but customer service is lacking. I’m not from anywhere around there so I wouldn’t make up about the lady saying call Edna. Lady had long hair and glasses. She is probably the one replying to the reviews. I’ve read the other reviews I’m not the only one lady.
… more
Pam Leucht
We were staying at Spring mill state park in Indiana. We ask 2 different people who has the best pizza close by and they both said Edna’s pizza, so well called and ordered a large. I have had a lot of pizza in 60 years but Edna’s pizza is way way better than all the big name chain restaurants. And you just can’t bet the price. 24 dollars with 3 toppings with extra cheese, unheard of these days. Loved it so much I just had to call and let them know!
… more
Rick Phillips
When I called to order the pizza lady taking my order was rude, so I should have stopped there. But, I thought it’s been very good pizza so we’ll try again. Bad mistake! When it was delivered the pizza was room temperature at best. The crust was so very tough that you could hardly chew it. So, I called and spoke with the rude lady again which was Edna’s daughter come find out. I asked to speak to Edna and she said shes never had complaints. Which read your reviews Edna, its happening. Never again, it used to be good but now its terrible. Go to Speakeasy in Orleans IN or Chicagos Pizza in Mitchell or Mother Bears in Bloomington. A $25 lesson learned. Worst pizza my wife and I ever tied to eat !
… more
Abe Pagota
Our whole family agrees this is our favorite pizza in Mitchell. And we don’t agree on much. We’ve only had it 3 or 4 times but it’s always been a good experience. We’ll be back next time we’re in town.
… more
Jenn Gonzalez
Were just some city slickers hiking at Spring Mill but we found a permanent food spot for when we come down here. DELICIOUS SUPER CHEEZY PIZZA. Loved the place! Will be back to eat at this tasty small business. Edna knows her pizza!
… more
… View more