Longtime locale for Italian fine dining featuring traditional dishes with housemade pastas. Based on 355 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
3935 Merrick Rd, Seaford, NY 11783
Phone: (516) 804-9280
Hours
| Tuesday | 12–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 12–9 PM |
| Thursday | 12–9 PM |
| Friday | 12–10 PM |
| Saturday | 2–10 PM |
| Sunday | 2–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
michael lapadula
Do You like Chicken Marsala!? I like it too! How do you like your Chicken Marsala regular, creamy or aldente. Just regular I guess. Regular! Cara Mia in Seaford makes a delicious Chicken Marsala. Perfectly seasoned chicken in very tasty marsala sauce with suculant mushrooms! The stuffed Rigatoni was also a flavorful dish! Its no surprise its considered one of the best Italian restaurants in Seatown baby!
… more
joanne lotempio
Omg, what a great little Italian restaurant tucked in a row of stores. Their “al fresco” tables are delightful. Caesar salad was delicious, dressing tasted homemade, my flounder was perfect, husband’s choice of Zuppa di pesce over linguine was MASSIVE, could have fed the 4 of us, my friend had the grilled salmon over sautéed spinachand her husband had shrimp monachino with linguine. My only issue was the bread. It was dry. Thank you to the chef
… more
Alexandra Swayne
My mom threw my baby shower here yesterday and I’m so happy with how everything went! She couldn’t have chosen a better place. The restaurant is beautiful! It’s on the smaller side and has an intimate ambience to it. The food is delicious and the portion size is very generous. The staff were also so kind! Sergio and the rest of the staff were so accommodating and helpful with the set up of the event as well as throughout the entirety of the party. Would highly recommend this place for hosting a party or even just for a meal out!
… more
Mark Douglas
I took the family to dinner on a Sunday night to celebrate my daughter’s birthday. The restaurant is a little hidden off of Merrick Road but was very nice. Not a big place but comfortable. I had the veal saltimbocca it was tasty. My son-in-law had veal sorrento he gave it a 8.9 lol. My daughter’s had pesto rigatoni which they really liked. The service was terrific as we had a party of 8 and 4 kids it could be demanding but the waitress was top notch.The birthday girl had a dessert of creme Brulee cheesecake which I never saw and it was delicious. The portions were big all around we took a lot home. Overall a very nice place will visit again
… more
Joseph Lanzarotta
Wow was this place amazing! The staff was so nice and the food was top notch! Probably had one of the best eggplant parms I ever had! The garlic bread parm and the egg rolls with sausage broccoli robe and mozzarella were incredible! Everything was amazing and I can’t wait to go back!!
… more
Maggie Isaacs
The food here was really outstanding, not to mention inventive. Italian egg rolls filled with sausage and broccoli rabe? FANTASTIC!
… more
Long Island Wine Dad
UPDATED 30 APR 2021 One more fine meal see liwinedad.blogspot.com for details.
… more
Anthony Bruzzone
Our go to spot for casual drinks that turn into a meal. All the dishes we have eaten have been great. Their espresso martini is amazing. Never disappointed.
… more
Raven Helfrich
Ordered the spaghetti and meatballs, and pet me tell you these have been the juiciest, most delicious meatballs I’ve ever had from any restaurants around me. Loved the kick of pepper in them. They are reasonably priced because I think from this dish alone they gotta be one of many best restaurants on the island. Keep it up.
… more
Matt Goncalves
If I could rate more stars I would! This place is just phenomenal! Everything on their menu sounds incredible and from what I’ve had so far is incredible! They have the BEST burrata… every time I come here I’m a happy customer! Amazing service, good vibes, and overall one of the best restaurants on the island!
… more
… View more