Based on 133 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1976 Granville Rd STE B, Newark, OH 43055
Phone: (740) 326-4560
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jaylynn Fiedler
We drove here from Dayton because of this pizza from our friends hometown near Shadyside. This location was closest for us to get to. We needed a fixing for our cravings. Very good would recommend !
… more
David J. Selby
Lots of toppings. Very good crust. Friendly staff. Good service. Place is easily overlooked due to Granville’s signage laws. I have driven past this place dozens of times and never saw it. I’ll be back in the future.
… more
Aja Tverbut
We ordered 4 pizzas total. Two pepperoni and extra cheese and two everything. All with thick crust. And two bombino breads. Everything was excellent! I know this pizza place from the Ohio valley, and I was excited to try this location. Super clean, easy app ordering, nice service, and delicious food!
… more
Stuart Poe
Ok, im from Shadyside and have been getting this awesome pizza since 1982. For a long time, we would drive back to St. Clairsville for DeFelice Brothers, now I don’t have to. I’m a fan
… more
Tonya D’Amato
It was our first time trying this pizza today. We got an XL pep n cheese it was just under 19 bucks. I wish I had known how much sauce they add to it wowza! The sauce was the part I most disliked, I find it tomato paste like and plain and waaaaay too much when not requested. The pepperoni was not crispy or flavorful either.
… more
Lauren Snyder
Heard a lot about DeFelice and we finally had an opportunity to try it! We really enjoyed the pizza, it was definitely saucy. Only downfall was the cost – seemed a little on the pricey side. Overall, we were happy and will likely order again!
… more
J G
Great pizza!! It’s nice to have a new pizza place that has a different taste that isn’t like any other around. I’ll definitely be going back. Only hiccup is the advertised price on the website. From what I understand though that’s an issue that they aren’t able to control. I do think $14.50 for a large pepperoni pizza is a better price point. When the price for a large pepperoni goes above that it just seems like one debates on do they really want to spend that much on a pizza or just get it from some place else or something else all together.
… more
Jasson Farrier
The crust is fried. Kinda like Pizza Hut style (but way better). I wish they had baked crust, especially a thin crust option. The thick style pizza is not my jam. However they have the best sauce in the county imo.
… more
Brian Crowthers
What can I say, this pizza is delicious.
… more
Rupert Everington
Fantastic thick crust pizza!! Definitely get your money’s worth.
… more
… View more