Old City Prime is a modern-day, classic American steakhouse. The menu is a revival of ageless taste, from fresh oysters and chilled seafood, premium tableside salads, gourmet appetizers, and USDA prime aged steaks to breads and desserts from our in-house bakery. Our craft bar and entertainment venue, The Upper Lounge, serves classic cocktails and a boutique wine list alongside a variety of the region’s best musical talent. At Old City Prime, the supper club comes alive with elegance and modernity.
American restaurant & lounge with live entertainment including dueling pianos, jazz & tribute bands. Based on 630 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price $$$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
215 S Main St, Lima, OH 45801
Phone: (419) 227-7463
Website: http://www.oldcityprime.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday |
5–9 PM |
| Thursday |
5–9 PM |
| Friday |
5–9 PM |
| Saturday |
5–9 PM |
| Sunday |
Closed |
| Monday |
Closed |
| Tuesday |
5–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: oldcityprime.com
Reviews
Becky Compton
My first time here as I am traveling on business. The food was amazing. Highly recommend and our waiter has a beautiful singing voice! I heard him singing to a table who was celebrating a birthday!
… more
Geneva Brinkman
First off, The food here is absolutely delicious, and our waitress Jessica was very accommodating and sweet.
… more
Darren Fong
Seemed like a classic steakhouse, the food was really good and the service was fantastic. Restaurant was really dark, but is part of the theme.
… more
Elizabeth Abram
Three members of the party were from out of town (Chicago area) and have many choices in our area for a great steak/seafood meals in an upscale setting. Old city Prime did not disappoint. The tomato bisque soup was fantastic. The salads that the others got were very nice size. Bread was beyond good. My steak was perfect. Two others got fish selections, and the last got the roasted Chicken. All was outstanding. Was there for a birthday celebration and a staff member with a wonderful voice sang happy birthday and had sparklers in the dessert! My aunt was so happy. She felt so special and it was your staff that made that happen. We visit at least once a year and will be back every single time!
… more
brian kline
The wait staff was incredible and the food was fantastic. My wife and I shared our meals. We got the pork belly app, delmonico with baked potato, bacon wrapped meatloaf with truffle fries, bread pudding and creme brulee as well as a few cocktails. Everything was just amazing and the price was great.
… more
Steven Soricone
OUTSTANDING FOOD, DRINK AND SERVICE!
… more
Lindsey H
Absolutely phenomenal! Went here for the first time last night and was not disappointed. Had the bartender recommended a dessert red to go with the chocolate cake, it is now on my list of favorites! Going here again when I next get the chance.
… more
Nicole R
Classy, upscale restaurant with a great vibe. The staff were amazing, and worked to make sure we were well taken care of. The food was excellent, everything we ordered was beautifully done and delicious. We went to eat here before a show at the Lima Veterans Memorial Civic Center, and it was just a quick walk over after we were done eating. Scott, our server, was very helpful in making sure we knew exactly where we were going and was so kind and accommodating in every way. I would recommend Old City Prime to anyone who happens to find themselves in the Lima area, or even as a road trip to those a bit further away. We will definitely make a point of going again!
… more
Zach Blythe
Best food, portions, flavor, and service out of any restaurant. Would go again for any sort of special occasion.
… more
Denver “Doomsday” Williams
The Filet Mignon with demi glace was superb. Rich and tender, seasoned and cooked to perfection. The loaded baked potato and asparagus with hollandaise were also very good. Service was absolutely fantastic. The only issue I could see was that I could barely see. It is rather dimly lit and it took me a while to adjust to the lighting. Overall if you can afford it, it is well worth the cost to have a meal that fulfills every expectation of what you would want from a real fine dining establishment, all right here in Lima.
… more
… View more
