Why Barnstormers? Barnstormers were BOLD, DARING & UNIQUE pioneer pilots, just like our PIZZAS which are handmade & crafted with love.
We cold ferment our dough 72 hours for a rich taste and bite. We hand-blend our sauce with fresh basil & the best plum tomatoes from California. Toppings are sliced fresh daily. It takes six hours of prep each day to make your pizza. That’s a lot of pride & care!
Our trained delivery drivers ensure quality from production to delivery, unlike others that use a 3rd party company.
I promise YOU’LL LOVE your pizza. If not, call us within 10 min. of receiving and we will exchange it & make it right. If we can’t, I’ll refund your money, every last penny!
Ready for your pizza adventure? Call or order online.
Based on 154 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.6 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
4031 M-139, St Joseph, MI 49085
Phone: (269) 281-0022
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday |
4–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
4–8 PM |
| Thursday |
4–8 PM |
| Friday |
4–9 PM |
| Saturday |
4–9 PM |
| Sunday |
4–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Brent Helgoth
Great pizza! The flavor combinations are wonderful and the crust is fantastic (we always get the hand tossed). We have tried all the flavors and they are all very good. The Crazy 8 Cubano is my personal favorite.
… more
Joshua Hawkins
We kept hearing about this place and it didn’t disappoint . The pizza and loaded fries were great. Staff was also very
… more
Olivia Davis
I have to update my review. Everytime we come here, I love the pizza even more! The staff and owners are SUPERIOR. You must try this place!!!
… more
Alice Kress
Great service and food! The voyager, Cubano, and Garlic cheesy bread were delicious – no pics of the wings or turkey ribs as we devoured them!
… more
Kathy Martin
Went to Silver beach for our family beach day. Silver Beach pizza had over a 3 hour wait. Did a Google search and found this gem. What a great place! Pizza was fantastic and the staff were so friendly! If you find yourself in St. Joe check them out! You won’t be sorry! Wish we lived closer but we will be back!
… more
Caitlin Hampton
Just ordered 4 pizzas (Puddle Jumper, Loop to Loop(the kids favorite!), Taildragger, and the Plain Plane) a salad(Hangar) and two subs (pushback tugs with the balsamic vinaigrette dressing. YUM!) The food was DELICIOUS as always and the service is phenomenal. the food was so hot the boxes were still steaming when we got home to eat and we even got there after it was finished cooking! The whole menu is amazing, it makes it difficult to decide on what to order.
… more
Jordan Bushert
Great tasting cheese & pizza. Loved seeing two BBQ sauce based pizzas (my fav) at the top of the menu & was satisfied with the taste of the ingredients and dough but please see if someone can ask the cooks cutting to please cut a little harder because I’m a delivery driver and I had to tear it apart but that’s fine, still a 5/5 experience. My stepsister Jen is smart to call her favorite pizza place!
… more
Elizabeth Kibby
Small pizza shop in St. Joseph that opened up just 2 years ago. Staff is very friendly and energetic. Pizza was just a basic pepperoni and sausage which had good flavor. Three tables inside but not fully designed for sitting down dining. Large storage room which appears to be under construction for a dining space. If back in the area I would return.
… more
Glen Head
Barnstormer pilots were bold, daring, and unique…just like the pizzas at Barnstormers Pizza in St. Joseph, Michigan.
… more
Leo Gomez
Barnstormers was always amazing when my boss ordered pizza for us but my personal experience ordering was especially exceptional. I wanted to introduce my best friend to Barnstormers so we ordered The Flying Circus, which was incredibly delicious and my new top favorite right after the Crazy 8 Cubano. The service we received when we arrived for pick up made us so feel appreciated as a customer that I was ready to order another pizza in that instant. The wonderful cashier handed us some hot sauce samples to try which ended up complimenting our pizza so well we each shared an impressed eyebrow raise. The truffle hot sauce is particularly pleasing and both sauces offer a pleasant heat that doesn’t overpower their amazing pizza. Highly recommend as always and so excited to try more!
… more
… View more
