Family-owned, lakeside pub with comfort food & craft beers, plus live local bands & outdoor seating. Based on 736 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
631 Limecrest Rd, Newton, NJ 07860
Phone: (973) 383-7577
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Wednesday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Friday | 11:30 AM–2 AM |
| Saturday | 11:30 AM–2 AM |
| Sunday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
| Monday | 11:30 AM–12 AM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lauren Twyford
Hosted my mom’s 70th birthday over the weekend with my family and everything was great. The food was delicious, the two servers we had were quick and accommodating. Since we were a large party (20+), we had the back room which ended up being a perfect area to socialize and not bother other patrons. Overall great experience!!
… more
Anne Matrone
I attended a bridal shower in their party room and it was very nice! The room has large windows overlooking the lake and it was so picturesque and bright. Even though there was a huge bar with a crowd of people eating just steps away from where we were, inside the room felt very private and intimate. The food was very good, we had brunch. They served buffet style and it was plentiful and hot. We had bagels and danish, delicious quiches with breakfast potatoes, chicken and waffles, amazing salad, penne vodka, chicken fancese, and sliced beef in a brown mushroom gravy. All delicious! In the bar restaurant there were many families there besides what looked like regulars and the food they were eating looked really good too. Overall a great place to hang out for a casual bar experience, as well as a great event space for a small 30-40 person party!
… more
Michael Bell
What could possibly be better on a gloomy January day than having a pint with some Steamers and a Reuben at “the best” locally known Irish Pub in North New Jersey? I’ll wait… ☘️ #thehungryagent #sheridanslodge #lakeilliff #andovernj #sussexcountynj #localseatbetter #steamers #reubensandwich #irishpub #localrealtornj #listingagent #buyersagent #njrealtor Sheridan’s Restaurant and Tavern The Addison Group
… more
Rebecca Lerner
The boom boom shrimp has just the right amount of heat. The fish and chips are good!
… more
Dewell Javier
Well what can I say? Appetizing seafood chowder and sirloin steak that melts in your mouth certainly met my expectations of this incredible dining experience yielded by a very friendly and welcoming staff especially the owners who ensured I was taken care of. For a busy night I was served relatively quick and my steak was cooked exactly as I had desired. This is one of the few establishments that actually cooks steak medium rare so that is a major plus. I have never felt so welcomed despite not being from this area. Definitely looking forward to future visits to this amazing establishment. Thank you so much.
… more
Patricia English
Just had a yummy lunch on the porch overlooking the lake. The chowder was delish and my pork tacos were so good! Different than most tacos, a little messy but so good!
… more
Kevin Crawley
Sheridan’s Lodge was a pleasant surprise for us. We were looking for a restaurant halfway between our home and our closest friends.
… more
Rich Ball
A nice lakeside restaurant. Good food, good service and nice wine and beer selections.
… more
Adrian Douglas
Great place looking out over the lake. Wasn’t too busy when we went around 6pm. Great food and service!
… more
Ash GR
Nice place with good lake view. It’s a good place to hangout after work for drinks and appetizers. I have been there thrice and was never disappointed so far. the wings seemed a little dry to me, but the other like nachoes, fried calamari, chicken entrees are good.
… more
… View more