Based on 137 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.8 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
15910 OH-37, Sunbury, OH 43074
Phone: (740) 913-0694
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday | 4–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
mark matheis
The Other Guy Pizza is close to our place in Sunbury and this is the first time having it. Ordered the meat lovers pizza and it was done and ready on time (about 25 minutes) . The toppings and sauce had an excellent taste and the amount of toppings was just right. The crust was also very good and I’d rank that part higher but we tend to like Neapolitan style crust that places like Paulie Gees and Sextons have but for a non-Neapolitan style, this crust was very good and I felt it was a better crust than a number of places that have a “Columbus style” pizza crust. Excellent pizza and not quite 5 stars for us only because our personal preference in crust. Don’t take that to mean , we didn’t like the crust , just like a Neapolitan style crust a bit better. Appreciate having a privately owned pizza place like this so close to home…We will definitely be back!
… more
Z
Best pizza by far anywhere near Sunbury and arguably Ohio. Owned and operated by the nicest individuals you’d ever meet. The absolute definition of a locally owned proud local business. Please support this business as often as you can. This is exactly what makes America a great place to live. Quality product from a high quality owner. We are fortunate to have them in our community and I personally thank you for your contribution to our area . Keep up the great work !!!
… more
Patch Wetzel
Love the folks here! Consistent in flavors we crave. It’s our go-to when we’re lazy to cook. Thank you, Rocco! ❤️ such a loving and caring people! We’re always well taken care of!
… more
Bryce McDermaid
So far I have only tried the Meatball Sub which was quite good and at a fair price! Despite its inconvenient location, I actually quite enjoy it since you can get your meal and sit outside on a nice day and set your gaze upon the soy fields yonder and pretend you are deep in the countryside.
… more
Joseph Y
Is it good? Let me put it this way: I drive past four other pizza shops to eat here. Rocco uses quality ingredients, the dough is made fresh, and his cannoli are excellent.
… more
Sara Smith
We’ve ordered carry out several times, always thought it was solid. The Dine in experience was even better. Excellent pizza, subs and service.
… more
Eric Ison
Awsome food and service! The two young men I interacted with were super friendly and polite. Will definitely be back!!!!
… more
jeremy johnson
Simply amazing edge to edge pizza!
… more
B Gregory
My sons and I like to try non-chain pizza places when we go on vacation. I was looking at different ones online and found The Other Guy Pizza. We stopped Wednesday afternoon, August 3rd, and ordered a pepperoni pizza and garlic bread. Let me just say this, the next time we are in the area we will be back! Hands down the best pizza we’ve had in quite a while!!!
… more
Pete Edgington
Chesse pizza was the best I’ve tasted. Deluxe pizza was very good with generous toppings.
… more
… View more