Papi Grande’s Mexican Restaurant and Cantina Menu – Amherst, NY

Type : Mexican restaurant

Location : Amherst, NY

Based on 639 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.6 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery

Papi Grande's Mexican Restaurant and Cantina 14226

Address:
4276 Maple Rd, Amherst, NY 14226

Phone: (716) 836-7274

Website:

Social Profile:

Hours

Saturday 11 AM–10:30 PM
Sunday 11 AM–8:30 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–9:30 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–9:30 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–9:30 PM
Thursday 11 AM–9:30 PM
Friday 11 AM–10:30 PM

Menu

Menu
Brussel Sprouts
generous portion of crispy fried brussel sprouts tossed in our signature smoky orange vinaigrette and served with our house made bang bang sauce
$9.99
Chips And Salsa
Housemade salsa, warm tortilla chips
$2.99
Chips And Guacamole
made fresh daily, smashed avocado with our own blend of seasoning and homemade pico de gallo
$9.99
Papis Famous Queso Dip
our house made famous queso dip with corn chips. bacon +1 / chicken +2 / steak +3 / beef +2
$9.99
Birria Egg Rolls
mexican stewed beef, onion, cilantro and cheese in a flaky golden brown won ton served with birria sauce for dipping
$10.99
Papi’s Nacho’s (Chicken Or Beef)
mountain of won ton chips, queso, lettuce, pico de gallo, pickled jalapeno, black olives, sour cream
$15.99
Primo’s Poutine
French fries, ground beef, queso, lettuce, pico de gallo, crema
$9.99
Flight Of The Amigos 3X
fried flour tortillas served with bowls of queso, salsa verde, street corn dip
$11.99
Nashville Hot Buffalo Cauliflower
coated in a spicy nashville breading, fried and served with a side of ranch
$9.99
Mexican Street Corn Dip
fire roasted mexican street corn, queso with chili peppers, lime, cilantro and cojita cheese served with tortilla chips
$9.99
Grilled Mexican Street Corn
seasoned and grilled corn on the cobb, brushed with house aioli and topped with cojita cheese, cilantro and lime
$4.99
Papis Famous Kicked Up Queso Dip
our house made famous queso dip blended with chipotle peppers, served with corn chips. bacon +1 / chicken +2 / steak +3 / beef +2
$9.99
Birria Nachos
Tortilla chps, birria, drizzled queso, cilantro, onion, queso fresco
$16.99
Mami’s Nachos
Wonton chips, carnitas, slaw, pickled onion, guacamole, crema, queso fresco, cilantro lime vinaigrette
$15.99
Arabe
grilled fajita chicken, cucumber, pico de gallo, diosa verde dressing on a flour tortilla
$4.50
Gringo
Taco beef, shredded queso blanco, lettuce, chipotle ranch on a flour tortilla
$4.00
Cancun Fish Taco
sauteed amberjack yellowtail, topped with pineapple mango salsa, avocado, mojo sauce on a flour tortilla
$6.00
Cancun Shrimp Taco
sauteed shrimp topped with pineapple mango salsa, avocado, mojo sauce on a flour tortilla
$6.00
Tropical Bang Bang Taco
beer battered shrimp tossed in our signature bang-bang sauce with lettuce, pico de gallo and tropical crema on a flour tortilla
$6.00
Stinger Taco
hot chicken tender, carne asada, queso, lettuce on a flour tortilla
$6.00
El Smoky Vegano
plant based taco meat in smoky orange vinaigrette, mango fire roasted pineapple salsa, pepper and onion blend, avocado on a corn tortilla
$6.00
Carnitas
Pork Carnitas, guacamole, salsa verde, crumbled won tons on a corn tortilla
$5.00
General Tso Taco
tempura chicken tossed in tso sauce, fried rice, green onion on a flour tortilla
$5.50
Buffalo Bison Dip Taco
potato chip crusted chicken, shredded queso blanco,pico de gallo, green onion, spicy bison dip on a flour tortilla
$5.50
BBQ Pulled Pork Mac N Cheese Taco
our famous queso mac n cheese, bbq pulled pork, bread crumbs on a flour tortilla
$5.50
Nashville Hot Taco
chicken tender, nashville hot sauce, cabbage, pickle on a flour tortilla
$6.00
Chicken Finger Taco
chipotle bbq chicken tender, lettuce, tomato, cojita cheese on a flour tortilla
$6.00
Philly Cheese Steak
skirt steak, peppers and onions, queso, flour tortilla
$6.00
Fiesta Veggie Taco
black bean, corn medley, cilantro, lime, rice pico de gallo, cojita cheese, chipotle mayo on a corn tortilla
$5.50
Chicken Fajita Taco
grilled fajita chicken, peppers and onions, fajita sauce, cheese, flour tortilla(steak or shrimp +1)
$5.00
Pittsburgh Taco
carne asada, cajun tossed fries, lettuce, cheddar cheese, drizzled with honey mustard, on a bbq flour tortilla
$5.50
Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch
grilled fajita chicken, lettuce, tomato, bacon, chipotle ranch on a flour tortilla
$5.50
Hibachi
fried rice, steak, shrimp, green onion, teriyaki sauce on a flour tortilla
$6.00
Birria Taco
savory mexican stewed beef and melted cheese on a corn tortilla topped with queso fresco, cilantro and onions. Served with birria sauce on the side for dipping.
$6.00
Hermano
beer battered chicken, pimento cheese, pickled cabbage, bbq sauce on a corn tortilla
$5.50
Felipe
marinated skirt steak smothered in queso on a flour tortilla
$5.50
South Of The Border Cobb Salad
chopped romaine, fajita chicken, shredded queso blanco, black beans, corn, avocado, pico de gallo, cucumber, sliced egg, chipotle ranch. shrimp +4
$12.99
Baja Bowl
choice of protein, mexi-cali seasoned rice, black beans, fire roasted corn, avocado, pico de gallo, pickled onion, creamy cilantro and lime dressing. steak +4 / fajita chicken +3 / grilled shrimp +4 / vegano +4
$9.99
Taco Salad
shredded lettuce, taco beef, corn, pico de gallo, black olives, shredded cheese, sour cream and salsa served in a fried flour tortilla bowl. guacamole +2
$12.99
Chimichanga
choice of taco beef or shredded chicken, crispy fried tortilla smothered in our famous queso topped with shredded cheese and pico de gallo. add kicked up queso +1 / carnitas +4 / steak +4 / shrimp +4 / vegano +4 / guac +2
$17.50
Enchiladas
4 oven baked beef and cheese enchiladas, red sauce, shredded cheese topped with lettuce and sour cream. carnitas +4 / steak +4 / guac +2
$16.50
Burrito Grande
flour tortilla, beans, rice, cheese, loaded with choice of shredded chicken or beef, lettuce, pico de gallo and sour cream. add kicked up queso +1 / carnitas +4 / steak +4 / shrimp +4 / vegano +4 / guac +2
$16.50
Quesadilla
grilled flour tortilla stuffed with shredded chicken or beef, peppers, onions, pico de gallo and shredded cheese, side of sour cream. carnitas +4 / steak +4 / shrimp +4 / vegano +4 / guac +2
$15.50
Tres Tacos
flour tortilla or hard/soft corn tortilla, choice of shredded chicken or beef, lettuce, cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream. carnitas +4 / steak +4 / shrimp +4 / vegano +4 / guac +2.
$15.50
Margarita Carne Asada
8 oz new york strip steak marinated in our house made marg mix, topped with mojo citrus lime sauce and served with mexican street corn and baja seasoned rice
$19.99
Sizzling Fajitas
a hot cast iron skillet served with a bed of peppers and onions, fajita chicken, lettuce, cheese, pico de gallo, flour tortillas, sour cream. carnitas +4 / steak +4 / shrimp +4 / vegano +4 / guac +2.
$19.50
Churros
cinnamon sugar coated fried pastry drizzled in chocolate topped with whipped cream
$6.00
Fried Ice Cream
Vanilla ice cream covered in sugar cinnamon cerea fried. drizzled in caramel and chocolate sauce with whipped cream
$6.00
Apple Empanada
2 house made apple cinnamon filling fried and tossed in our cinnamon sugar blend topped with whipped cream and caramel drizzle
$6.00
Spanish Rice $2.00
Refried Beans $2.00
French Fries $3.00
Sour Cream $0.50
Side Of Guacamole
*Does not come with chips. For chips order the Guacamole appetizer
$3.00
Side Of Queso
*Does not come with chips. For chips order the Queso appetizer
$3.00
Side Of Salsa
*Does not come with chips. For chips order the Salsa appetizer
$2.00
Diet Pepsi $2.99
Pink Lemonade $2.99
Loganberry $2.99
Unsweetened Iced Tea $2.99
Sweet Iced Tea $2.99
Ginger Ale $2.99
7UP $2.99
Dr Pepper $2.99
Pepsi $2.99
Root Beer $2.99
Taco With Rice
choice of cheese, chicken or beef
$7.99
Ninos Nachos
served with beef, cheese, lettuce and sour cream
$7.99
Mac & Queso
pasta shells smothered in our famous queso
$7.99
Taco In A Bag
bag of doritos, beef, cheese and lettuce
$7.99
Chicken Fingers And Fries $7.99
Margarita
tequila, triple sec, marg mix.add a flavor for $1
$9.00
Bulldog
margarita of your choice with a mini corona.add a flavor for $1
$12.00
Margarita Pitcher
a pitcher has about 4 margaritas in it.add a flavor for $4
$32.00
Blue Margarita
tequila, blue curacao, marg mix
$10.00
Green Tea Margarita
tequila, peach schnapps, marg mix, 7UP
$10.00
Tequila Sunrise
tequila, orange juice, grenadine
$8.00
Mexican Mule
tequila, ginger beer, lime juice
$9.00
Arnold Papi
jim beam, deep eddy lemon, iced tea, lemonade
$9.00
Bahama Mama
dark rum, orange juice, pineapple juice, grenadine
$9.00
Mojito
white rum, fresh mint leaves, lime juice, simple syrup, soda.add a flavor for $1
$9.00
Sex On The Beach
vodka, peach schnapps, pineapple juice, cranberry juice
$8.00
Cosmo
vodka, triple sec, cranberry juice
$8.00
Blue Lagoon
vodka, blue curacao, marg mix, pineapple juice
$8.00
Papi’s Fruit Punch
cherry vodka, orange vodka, pineapple juice, orange juice, grenadine
$9.00
Papi’s Lemonade
strawberry lemonade svedka, cranberry juice, soda
$8.00
Streetcart Punch
mango pineapple svedka, pineapple juice, cranberry juice, 7UP
$8.00
Mule
vodka, ginger beer, lime juice.add a flavor for $1
$9.00
Red Sangria
house cabernet, triple sec, orange juice, pineapple juice
$10.00
White Sangria
white zinfandel, peach schnapps, orange juice, pineapple juice
$10.00
Margarita Tower
88oz tower of house made margaritas. add a flavor for $5
$50.00
Take Out Boxes
Enchilada Pack ~ Feeds 5
6 beef enchiladas in red sauce and 6 chicken enchiladas in green sauce. Served with lettuce, 12oz Spanish rice, and an order of our famous chips and queso
$60.00
Taco Box ~ Feeds 5
5 beef tacos and 5 shredded chicken tacos stuffed with shredded lettuce, pico de gallo, shredded cheese and sour cream. Served with 12oz Spanish rice and an order of our famous chips and queso
$50.00
Quesadilla Pack ~ Feeds 6
3 beef quesadillas and 3 shredded chicken quesadillas stuffed with peppers, onions and pico de gallo. Served with sour cream, 12oz Spanish rice and an order of our famous chips and queso
$90.00
Appetizer Pack ~ Feeds 4
Papi’s Nachos(chicken or beef), birria egg rolls, 2 orders of chips and queso and 12oz Spanish rice
$45.00
Fajita Platter ~ Feeds 4
Steak and chicken fajitas (equal to 4 orders) served on sauteed peppers and onions with lettuce, cheese, pico de gallo, sour cream and soft flour shells. Served with 12oz Spanish rice and an order of our famous chips and queso
$70.00
Cinco Grande Fiesta ~ Feeds 10
5 beef and 5 chicken tacos, 2 beef and 2 chicken quesadillas, Papi’s Nachos(chicken or beef). Served with 1 quart of Spanish rice and an order of our famous chips and queso
$150.00
Birria Box ~ Feeds 4
6 birria tacos, birria egg rolls and birria nachos
$60.00
Dip Box ~ Feeds 5
1 quart of salsa, 1 quart of queso, 1 quart of guacamole, served with corn tortilla chips
$45.00
Specialty Taco Box ~ 10 Or 20
Choose 10 or 20, Feeds 5 or 10.BBQ Pulled Pork Mac & Cheese / Chipotle Chicken Bacon Ranch / Tropical Bang Bang Shrimp / Cancun Shrimp / Cancun Fish / Birria / Philly Cheese Steak / Buffalo Bison Dip / El Smoky Vegano / Chicken Finger/ Chicken Fajita / Shrimp Fajita / Steak Fajita / Fiesta Veggie / Nashville Hot / General Tso / Pittsburgh / Hermano / Carnitas / Hibachi / Stinger / Felipe / Gringo / Arabe
Brunch Menu
Bottomless Mimosas
$15 per person with food purchase(2 hour maximum)
$15.00
Bloody Mary
vodka, bloody mary mix, cholula, cracked black pepper, celery salt, topped with green olives, celery and pepperoncini
$10.00
Sangria Flight
$15 for the flight or $9 for one:Peach Sangria, Blood Orange Sangria, Red Sangria, White Sangria
$15.00
Blackberry Champagne Mule
vodka, champagne, fresh blackberries
$8.00
Raspberry Mimosa
champagne, orange juice, fresh raspberries
$8.00
Avocado Toast
sourdough bread, smashed avocado, cherry tomatoes, feta, served with fresh fruit
$7.99
Breakfast Taco
flour tortilla, bacon, lettuce, pico de gallo, scrambled or fried egg, taco beef or chorizo / steak $2
$3.99
Brunch Burrito
scrambled eggs, bacon, taco beef or chorizo, shredded cheese, pico de gallo. served with home fries and fresh fruit / steak $4
$15.99
Papi Con Chorizo
Mexican brunch skillet with home fries, taco beef or chorizo, scrambled eggs, diced onion, cilantro and covered in queso. served with fresh fruit / steak $4
$14.99
Breakfast Quesadilla
scrambled eggs, taco beef or chorizo, shredded cheese, pico de gallo, peppers and onions. served with home fries and fresh fruit / steak $4
$14.99
Breakfast Enchiladas
soft corn tortillas, scrambled eggs, shredded cheese, peppers and onions, smothered in queso. served with home fries and fresh fruit / steak $4
$14.99
Churro French Toast
sourdough bread dipped in egg and cinnamon sugar. served with home fries and fresh fruit
$10.99
Steak & Eggs
8oz strip steak topped with mojo sauce, scrambled or fried eggs. served with home fries and fresh fruit
$19.99
Hangover Fries
fries smothered in queso, topped with shredded cheese, taco beef or chorizo, lettuce, pico de gallo, jalapeno, two fried eggs / steak $4
$10.99
To-Go Alcohol
Gallon Bag Of Margarita
You read that right! An entire gallon of our freshly squeezed lime margaritas in a bag with a carrying case. Pour over ice or slap the bag!
$69.99
Margarita Quart
Buy a quart of our fresh squeezed lime margarita premade with our house tequila and triple sec. All you have to do is pour over ice!Make it a flavored Marg for $3.99 more! Strawberry, Raspberry, Mango, Peach or Blood Orange!
$25.00
Single Margarita
Traditional Lime Margarita on the rocks. Add a flavor for $1
$9.99

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Amber Wilson
Pretty low key place nice outside seating with large tent. Our waitress was amazing and helped us choose our tacos for taco Tuesday During our dinner someone with the restaurant kept messing with the music system and the speakers outside kept going down in volume and then would make a loud screeching sound. It made our dinner uncomfortable and my ears were hurting Everytime after the screech… This happened 3 times to many.

… more

Anetka Sosa
Love the atmosphere, food, drinks and staff! Everytime I’ve come here the wait staff has been wonderful, drinks have never disappointed, sangria’s are delicious, so are the mimosa’s. Try their french toast for breakfast or their hibachi taco! Go see my girl Katie!

… more

Lynnette Mourning
Food and service was very good. Wednesday is trivia night so decided to give it a try It was alot of fun. These were appetizers Birria Egg Roll, and Mexican Street Corn

… more

S Burns
Went for a drink before going to the movies. The one bartender with the colored contacts was moody. Caught a peak of the kitchen. Made me second guess coming back to eat. The mop bucket was disgusting and the floor looked filthy.

… more

Stephanie Nemmer
Delicious food and very accommodating to dietary restrictions!! I am both vegetarian and have celiac disease, so I called to check if the meal I wanted (Vegano bowl and chips and queso) would be safe for me to eat. The woman I spoke to was very sweet and even read off the meatless crumble ingredients to me to double check. My meal was incredible with no cross contamination issues! (^:

… more

Teelittle Giant
I had the best Chicken Nachos that I have ever had, the chips were light with great flavor, the toppings were perfect and it came with a container of Queso. The order was huge we had 5 meals from it. We also ordered Chicken Queasdillas they were very good I would order them again!

… more

Derek Rumpler
The food was passable (although the fries tasted like cardboard). I likely won’t eat here again. Our waitress was nice. She knew we came from the theater and never asked to see our tickets, though. I forgot to bring it up which means we didn’t get the free chips and queso. There are much better Mexican restaurants in the area (and they freely provide chips and salsa without asking). There is even a nearby Taco Bell which I will likely go to instead.

… more

Mahdi Hodaei
The food was enjoyable, especially the Mexican dishes which were particularly tasty. The staff was friendly and accommodating. However, I deducted one star from my review because they did not offer any hot drinks. Additionally, the location was not ideal as sitting outside meant seeing a constant flow of people going to and from the nearby AMC theater, which detracted from the ambiance.

… more

Thomas W
The chicken tacos were a bit dry, but ok, the chicken fajitas were amazing, and we enjoyed the atmosphere. Barely saw our server, had to go inside to get napkins and utensils off another table after our food was delivered. Saying that, I don’t think this would be a common issue.

… more

Lynne Saunderson
Pretty expensive. Food was pretty good though. Decor was a little shabby and all the silverware was cloudy. They collected payment before printing a receipt, which I thought was weird. The server waiting right there while you figure out tip. Then once I paid and requested a receipt, come to find out they charged me extra for my meals instead of what was listed on the menu. That’s lazy.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions