Based on 186 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
132 E Main St, Palmyra, PA 17078
Phone: (717) 641-3363
Website: https://thegumbascompany.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | Closed |
| Thursday | 5–9 PM |
| Friday | Closed |
| Saturday | 5–9 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
| Tuesday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
punk 2008
Gave it 5 stars but never been to this place. Rating it 5 stars based off of my experience eating at this family’s restaurant in the 1980s and 1990s in Lebanon, PA on Maple St. The grandmother of this family had an outstanding Restaurant with great Italian food and later her Grandson started a pizza shop in the same building and they had great subs and Cheesesteaks and loved their Sicilian Pizza. Don’t know what happened afterwards because I moved out of Lebanon County for the past 2 decades and live in York County in Dillsburg, PA. I see that this family has a restaurant in Palmyra, PA and I would bet that they still make great food. Can see why they don’t have a restaurant in Lebanon, PA anymore because that city is a dump in my experience anytime I go back to the area to visit. It use to be a very nice city a few decades ago but turned into a dump with high crime.
… more
Melissa Hartman
Amazing food! Very clean. Everyone is very friendly and treats you like family! No mask necessary, unless you want to wear one. I’ll definitely be back!
… more
J A
5star place. Food is good and owner is nice guy. I would highly recommend.
… more
Patrick Green
Excellent food! We had a very early dinner and everything was delicious! The owner was very nice. We could not have asked for better! BTW … their sauce is addicting. We purchased several jars to take home with us.
… more
goodboiswag 12
Decided to eat here while visiting friends and I definitely would not suggest eating here. If you want mediocre Americanized Italian food, go to olive garden. Nonna would disown me if I took her here (PS….I think its interesting that every negative comment is denied by the owner. Thou dost protest too much?)
… more
tracey bemis
OMG, thank you for the wonderful meals. We will absolutely be back soon.
… more
Wendy Chambliss
We drove an hour and a half to support this business. We were not disappointed! Even though they were very busy at the time, the family was very welcoming and accommodating. The sauce used in their entrees was amazing! If you cant frequently dine in, it’s worth picking up Gumbas sauce either at their restaurant or in the grocery store! The kids loved their food and it’s not easy pleasing my picky eaters!
… more
Tara Cluck
Food was excellent! Our subs were huge! Marinara sauce with my cheese sticks was very good! I love marinara & they gave me a huge ramekin of it! The family that runs Taste of Sicily is so friendly & inviting. Will definitely re-visit in the future.
… more
Dawn Dunlap
Awesome food…best Spaghetti ever…best Alfredo ever…amazing bread…clean environment and pleasant atmosphere… but the absolute thing that makes this place so special is the people that own it and work there…from the moment you walk in, you are made to feel like you just walked into your own kitchen in your own home…you feel welcome and know they are happy to have you there…you are greeted with enthusiasm and a positive attitude…such absolutely wonderful people…if you are thinking about giving this place a go…do it…don’t be surprised if they offer you a bed and Italian breakfast!
… more
David Gifford
Meh food. Has been a place of controversy for years. Not a pleasant place to eat. There are many better Italian options in the area. Skip this one.
… more
… View more