For over forty years and three generations our
family has served the Rochester area with some of the finest we have to offer.
As one of area’s last great taverns our management and staff always strive to make your experience here a pleasurable one. We love to cook to order so feel free to ask. Our goal is that our guests go home satisfied with the food, atmosphere, and service that we provide. (Fat and Happy!)
Based on 377 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1549 Lake Rd N, Hamlin, NY 14464
Phone: (585) 636-4104
Website: http://www.thetavern19.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | Closed |
| Wednesday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Thursday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Friday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–12 AM |
| Sunday | 12–8 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Kim Southard
The last time we were here we had a great experience, and delicious shepherds pie. Unfortunately this time was not the same. Terrible experience today. We ordered a fish dinner, chicken wing pizza and hamburger meal for pick up. We only got half the fish dinner, the fish was slimy, the coleslaw had lettuce in it, the fries with the burger were undercooked and the chicken wing pizza was completely forgotten about. When we finally got the pizza the chicken was so tough it couldn’t be chewed. My husband called the place to tell them they forgot part of the fish fry and they hung up. They called back and offered a $3 refund. He told them no, we just won’t eat there again next time we are in the area. Also when we were waiting for the food, we thought we’d have a beer, it was flat. Co2 issues. This dinner take out was just a series of unfortunate events.
… more
Miss Alisha
Now this staff is full of hard working non stop moving people. Not sure if they were short staffed but just watching them hustle to get tables sat, cleaned and accommodated was impressive. Food came out relatively quick and everything was good to the taste and the pocket. Service was good we sat promptly and needs met throughout service. Would return and recommend
… more
RNryder
Stumbled across this gem while on a camping trip. After setting up, we decided to grab a quick bite as it was getting too late to cook. We arrived at 8pm and were thankful you were still serving dinner. We were greeted promptly and seated right away. The interior was beautiful and clean. Our server was efficient and the menu itself had alot to choose from which we don’t see often these days. We started with the jerk wood oven wings…omg! They were sooo good! I had the chicken parm and it was unbelievably delicious! My Mr. Had the roast dinner and he said it was tender and the mash potatoes were ” real” and also delicious. Everything that was served to us was piping hot and the serving sizes were huge…enough for lunch the next day. I wish we lived closer as we would love to frequent this establishment.
… more
Nathan Bantle
Overall the food was okay. Honesty I was pretty disappointed paying $13 for a ‘black & blue’ burger to have it come as a plain burger with a small cup of very running fake blue cheese on the side. If you going to put nothing else on your burger (first time ever not getting bacon on a black and blue) at least have real and good blue cheese! Didn’t even taste like blue cheese. Mozz sticks were and my wife liked her chicken French. Looks like a nice place to sit down and eat at someday. Edit: Also my wife’s $20 dinner didn’t come with a side. No veggies or anything like that. That was also a surprise. I guess I just gotta read the menus better!
… more
Sharon Johnson
Recommended by our Captain from charter, this place was incredible. The food was awesome and reasonable. Everyone left well satisfied, just wish weed had room for dessert.
… more
Scott Garland
So the front door was locked when we arrived. They answered when my wife knocked and the hostess was friendly. It took 30 minutes to get a beer, and my wife had to go get it off the bar. My beer was flat and sour, so I sent it back and drank water. My wife asked for a side salad, which was listed on the menu as being $3 with a meal, but we were charged $7. The pizza was ok, but the crust was not crisp and the olives were black instead of green as advertised.
… more
Sarah Hallifax
Orderd last night and it was simply amazing!!! Huge portion, steaming hot, and delicious!!! Order some and make your tummy happy whilst supporting local. I have been the restuarant a number of times and everything has been delicious! Can’t wait to go back!
… more
sarah jopson
Overcooked, bland, gluten-free CBR pizza. Ranch/BBQ sauce basically only on the middle part of the pizza. Dry over the rest of the pizza. Very disappointing $20 pizza. We have been frequent customers since the start of COVID. The quality has changed. :/
… more
Jimmy Massa
Horrible got a 32 dollar steak cooked med came out bloody and was all fat also the waitress didn’t give us our change back on the dollar 92 cents..
… more
Efrat Petel
Nice local place
… more
… View more