Casual NY Style Pizzeria serving Slices, Salads, Pastas, Heros, Wraps, Soups, Oven Baked Dishes, Classic Chicken, Veal, Eggplant & Seafood Dishes, Desserts, and of course a large assortment of hand crafted specialty pies or build your own. Delivery-Take Out-Catering. Beer & Wine Served. Fast and easy to use ONLINE Ordering system for delivery and pick up orders.
Standard Italian eats, bacon-topped pizzas & other specialty pies stand out at this informal eatery. Based on 531 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
17 Vanderbilt Motor Pkwy, Commack, NY 11725
Phone: (631) 499-7000
Hours
| Tuesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–9:30 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 10 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Mike G
Weird order experience. Never been to a pizzeria in NY that requires payment before they will start your order of 2 slices. Hefty HEFTY price tag at $18.79 for a margarita slice and caprese slice and 2x 20oz bottles of soda. Cashier had no idea that it was a caprese on a slice and we had to go over that it was Mozzarella tomato balsamic basil on the slice. cheap cheese causing a lot of grease to pour out of the corner of the box making a mess. The margharita slice tomato sauce apparently uses tomato paste in it, and they didn’t hydrate it enough and it was bland. No snap to the crust under the pizza. Has some good flavors, but this needs to be done right to bring them to surface. Won’t be back. They need to cut their prices AND improve their food. It’s a good thing this pizzeria isn’t in NYC with the price and the taste. Maybe the pasta is better.
… more
Daniel C.
Pretty good pizza! But when I asked for half of my pizza to be spinach, I just got soggy spinach on half of a cheese pizza instead of traditional spinach pizza (white sauce, etc).
… more
Chappy
Completely missed the mark !
… more
Bri Talia
The food here is pretty good but it’s not consistent. I love vodka pizza and ordered the “drunken Sicilian” and it was so bad. It was dry, flavorless, and gave my family a horrible stomachache.
… more
Real G
The prices have become so ridiculous that I cannot in good conscience go there any longer. I went because it was convenient. Certainly not for the food quality or prices. It appears to be gouging at this point and not “inflation.” I compared their menu to another local place “MT’s” (that has far superior food compared to Mario’s mediocre at best food. Mario’s has NEVER been anything more than mediocre). Chicken parm hero at Mario’s is 13.95. At the other place it costs 9.90. That’s a 40% difference! Chicken Francese entree at Mario’s is 24.50. At MTs it’s 18.95. 33% more! Large 16 inch pie at Mario’s is 20.50. 16″ at other place is 16.50.
… more
Pat Bocchino (KelvarGarth)
Mario’s is one of those places that totally reinvented itself during the covid shutdown. They vastly improved their menu offerings and their website ordering and rewards system is as good as you will find out there. I highly recommend them.
… more
Gianna Borrelli
If I could give 10 STARS, I would!!! Jonny, the manager, was so incredible to my group who came in for a Heart Shaped pizza for Valentine’s Day. We ended up order a few other menu items which were amazing as well. The staff was incredibly helpful and so accommodating. It’s been a while since I’ve had a good slice of pizza and Mario’s KILLED IT. Even the interior of the restaurant is so beautiful and SUPER CLEAN. I can’t wait to recommend this spot to all my friends and family. Thank you for everything, can’t wait to come back!
… more
Lizette Quiles
Prices are reasonable, the atmosphere friendly & most of all the food is very good. The meatballs are “meat” not majority breadcrumbs. The chicken parm,,the Hawaiian pizza all are very good. Plus,the free fountain drink refills is a nice touch
… more
Arton Fetahaj
Way over priced! Not worth it. 12 inch is a medium and priced at 30.00 for just mozzarella and garlic? ! No meat. When I called nobody seemed to care when I expressed my disappointment
… more
Tiffany Macartney
Our margarita pizza was delicious.
… more
… View more