Based on 36 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
1228 Chestnut St, Nelsonville, OH 45764
Phone: (740) 753-3015
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Wednesday | 3–10 PM |
| Thursday | 3–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Saturday | 3–11 PM |
| Sunday | 3–10 PM |
| Monday | 3–10 PM |
| Tuesday | 3–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rachael M
Always there for us when we don’t want to cook. Go far out of their way for delivery in my opinion which is absolutely amazing for us. (Other restaurants in town cry about delivery radius when we spend $60-80 minimum). We don’t want their inconsistent cold food anyways. We are grateful for this place and always yummy and hot. If there ever is an issue they go over the top to correct it. The guy giving a bad review for outside appearance and no gloves needs to just cook at home and stop being a girl in life overall Thanks for all you guys do and coming out to us!
… more
Phillip Merrick
This is hands down my new favorite pizza place!
… more
Buffy Riffle
Needed a place for some quick food after arriving to our campsite a little late. Called the office here at Jelly Stone Campground and they pointed us in right direction. Im sure glad they recommended us to the Pizza Stop. The taco salads and fried pickles were great. They were able to send my Schnauzer some grilled chicken. I’ll definitely be back.
… more
Rick Cullison
There have been at least three different pizza places in this location and since the first (Ramano’s and JJ’s). We had the Taco pizza and a regular pepperoni pizza. While the pepperoni was adequate, all I was able to taste in the taco pizza was refried beans. It completely overpowered the rest of the toppings. I don’t mind a little bit of refried beans on a taco but it has to blend harmoniously with the rest of the flavors. As for the pepperoni, it was a very basic pizza and nothing to write home about. Ramano’s was the gold standard of pizza in Nelsonville and JJ’s was pretty darn good too. It’s sad to see what this has become. The service was fantastic though. Very nice staff.
… more
Whitley Nicole
Pizza isn’t the greatest but the deep fried food is good. Broccoli cheese bites are amazing!! Better order ranch tho because it doesn’t come with it.
… more
Mark “Teddy” Sims
First of all i came to this place because of the of the few good reviews i seen despite what the place actually looked like but nevertheless when i walked in to this house turned pizza shop there two chairs a small table and a drink cooler with absolutely no drinks but i proceeded to order anyway when i got to the window i looked into the kitchen and no one was wearing gloves and two guys were hand picking toppings and shredded cheese off of a pizza as if the ingredients were not good or bad …i could be wrong but after i seen that i canceled my order and walked out
… more
angel huff
Idk what happened to the hospitality and customer service that they once had is gone and the employees are disrespectful it used to be such a great place to order from friendly workers and great food now it still has great food but the employees aren’t what they used to be!
… more
Michelle Khatri
Exceptional pizza shop! Loved it just a basic pepperoni & banana peppers it was wayyyy better than I expected!! I will definitely order from them over the chain restaurants any day! 5 plus starts!!
… more
Sherry Lewis
Best pizza place ever in Nelsonville I tell all my neighbors and friends to Order from Pizza Stop
… more
Penny Patton
First time I was not happy with my food. Miscommunication I think. The owner usually took my order but he wasn’t there and the nice girl didn’t know what I wanted but as I said it just was a case that she didn’t understand my order. I called and told the manager on duty and she was very understanding and made it good. Very good bunch of people.
… more
… View more