Based on 63 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1276 Fairport Rd Suite 4, Fairport, NY 14450
Phone: (585) 673-2020
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–8 PM |
| Saturday | 4–8 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | 11 AM–8 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
kyle alt
Pizza delivery guy double parked sideways out front. Guy working the front had no idea what my order was. Pizza tastes great. Salad and wings taste like nothing which is weird. Inside looks run down and dirty. One and done. Place has potential. Just seems not very well managed.
… more
Lindsey Jenkins
It’s rare I dislike food- especially pizza and wings but this was not good. I ordered pickup and went to the drive thru which was convenient, however the wings were given to me in a pizza box so the sauce was just all over. The opposite of crispy and just reeked of vinegar? Strange. I ordered half half medium & country sweet but I only got given country sweet. I ate a few after putting them in my air fryer and putting other sauce on them before deciding just to toss them. I also got a “slice” of pizza which looked like just half of a personal pizza and didn’t taste good either.
… more
Ben Beavers
Friendly staff great food best cannoli any where! And try the “goodfellows pizza” it’s exceptional. Been back several times always a delight. This small pizza place rank at the top of my list for all-time best pizza and it is the top of the list for best cannoli. We drive 35+ miles to eat here. It’s worth the drive.
… more
Kassandra Degus
This pizza is amazing! The Goodfellas specialty pizza is our favorite. My husband says they have the best wings he’s had in a long time AND they give you cut veggies on the side – something most area places have stopped doing. They’re also open on Mondays, so if you’re struggling to find a place for dinner that’s actually open, here it is!
… more
Carl
We ate all the pizza and forgot to take photos. This pizza is really good. Even when you order it normal and not well done the crust is good and crunch and lasts past when it cools down which is hard to find.
… more
Brian Coe
My neighbors told us to try the pizza from Pizza Mafia and they raved about it. I had not eaten here since they took over from the previous pizza shop that was here. We ordered a sheet pizza and it was delivered quickly and piping hot. The sauce and ingredients were delicious but the crust was the real stand out. Fantastic pizza and best of all, the kids loved it better than any they had before. We will definitely order from here again.
… more
Jason Rex
Best meatball sub of my life! Good bread, huge delicious meatballs, along with other meats as well. On the menu, Specialty Sandwiches – The Big Chooch. Sooo Good!
… more
Ryan Bates
This is our second time getting pizza from here. Really fresh tasting and the cheese tasted fresh and creamy. We will be getting pizza from here again soon. The chicken wings were actually really good too.
… more
Mark Faustoferri
Pizza did not taste good. Wings were okay, but you could tell the oil hasn’t been changed out recently.
… more
Jay Daigle
Some of the best pizza I’ve had. I love the Good Fellas pie! The owner is nice and very proud of how good his pizzas are (and he should be!)
… more
… View more