Trader’s Mill Grill & Bar Menu – Indianapolis, IN

Type : Bar & grill

Location : Indianapolis, IN

Typical sports bar with burgers & classic tavern eats in a warehouse-style space with plenty of TVs. Based on 780 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.0 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery

Trader's Mill Grill & Bar 46278

Address:
5650 W 86th St, Indianapolis, IN 46278

Phone: (317) 334-1226

Website:

Hours

Sunday 11 AM–11 PM
Monday

(Labor Day)
11 AM–11 PM

Hours might differ
Tuesday 11 AM–11 PM
Wednesday 11 AM–11 PM
Thursday 11 AM–11 PM
Friday 11 AM–11 PM
Saturday 11 AM–11 PM

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Ben Thomas
Food and atmosphere fine. Bartender complained to me at least 10x about how his other tables didnt tip and asked “are you going to tip?” before even taking our order – only to forget multiple drinks in our order and disappear for some time. Was stomping around irate complaining, even followed me to other end of bar to complain about his other parties not tipping as I avoided him after we closed our checks. Still tipped regardless. Make some adjustments and we’ll be back.

… more

Tamanika Morrow
Went to meet my sister for lunch after I had hard day. We sat at the bar, was greeted by the bartender who was nice. She took our drink order after handing us our menu’s. She made our drinks to perfection!!! Placed our order food came out hot, fast and DELICIOUS! Definitely would recommend and will be returning!!!

… more

Ethan Francart
The food is okay and there is plenty to do. however, I’m a good tipper and come frequently, so when I get blatantly ignored by servers who would rather shower attention to a single patron, I feel a bit hurt.

… more

Scott Conrad
Geez! If the bartender spent any time paying attention to the customers you’d think the place would be more popular or get more 2nd visits. It took me over 20 minutes just to pay my tab so I could finally leave!!

… more

Zeenat Joshi
It was a quiet night. Jus one other couple. The regular drinks . Clean n neat. Outside seating. Didn’t eat there. Hopefully busy during the weekends.

… more

Jenny Owens-Cripe
We recently went for lunch on a random day off. I just wanted a mother lunch so I ordered pita & hummus and a salad. Plus a beer, of course! Our server was friendly, food was good, and it wasn’t too busy so that was nice as well. I’ve been here for dinner before & the only difference is the busyness so I would definitely recommend lunch if you just want a nice spot to enjoy some good company!

… more

Jozef Watson
Great service, friendly and quick, beer was cold and food is tasty. Would recommend and will be back again. Clean inside and location is convenient.

… more

Brad T
Trader’s Mill makes excellent tenderloins. The pork is a nice thickness where you can taste the pork. There’s a good pork to breading ratio with a crispy, crunchy breading. The grilled tenderloin was a bit dry, tough and overseasoned. It was a good thickness but just shy of perfection. The onion rings have nice thick onions with a crispy batter. Again a good ratio of breading to onion. The fries were crispy with a light seasoning. I don’t usually like seasoned fries but this was light and not over powering so you still got a nice potatoey flavor

… more

James Rogers
Chad was awesome. Totally cool dude and super attentive. Loved the mushrooms and the gyro was pretty good.

… more

Eric Cheever
Amazing food….Great Service…the appetizer sampler is amazing I had the deluxe BLT and it was awesome…great selection of adult beverages..beers and wines..highly recommended

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions