Cafeteria-style pizza joint since 1970 with Italian mains, sandwiches & weekly kids’ night. Based on 215 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
42 Lincoln Pl, Madison, NJ 07940
Phone: (973) 377-9515
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: romanellispizza.com
Reviews
Lisa Hatala
Not only does Romanellis serve authentic Northern NJ pie, a rarity in itself, but rarer still, a variety of *vegan* meat and cheese options! Tasty vegan cheese, vegan pepperoni, vegan sausage crumbles, and vegan chicken cutlet are all on the menu. We were surprised and delighted today when we received, along with our vegan pie, a delicious vegan chicken sandwich topped with balsamic and arugula; this item was listed as simply a “chicken cutlet” under the Side Orders section of the web takeout menu. We will definitely be ordering again soon!
… more
Meg Mullin
We went for dinner at Romanellis last night to support a local organization (they do a ton of these fundraisers for local groups) and I had a fan favorite – the Caesar salad – and my daughter had the penne Vodka. The best thing about the Caesar are the croutons – made from breadsticks! And my kids would eat the penne vodka every day if they had the chance.
… more
Chuck Mound
Scouting Morris County Pizza for the Pizza Hunters App and ended up at Romanellis Pizza. Now this place is a prime example of how a restaurant has been in business for 50 years and they rest on their laurels and don’t produce what I am sure was great Pizza at one point. I have to be honest, the pepperoni slice that was presented was not good. I should give 1star, but out of respect, I am chalking it up to. Bad day. It was all grease, thin slice that flopped, no sauce with little cheese. Very Disappointed, was expecting a lot more for 50 years. The server was nice, and outdoor seating was fantastic. Cannot speak on other pasta dishes, only Pizza.
… more
Jackie Outwater
Sorry, I have to change my review. We order food from here twice a week and always are treated very well by Danielle. Today I ordered a sandwich that was so spicy my mouth is on fire. When I called, someone answered the phone and he said he was a manager. He offered to replace it, but gave me a very hard time, demanding I return the sandwich, so he can “examine it”. Then he nastily “it’s a thing called quality control.”.., condescending and rude. Whoever this was should not be answering the phone or dealing with any customers. We order from there 2 to 3 times a week and now I’m not comfortable. What a shame!
… more
O
Decent food. However, staff is a bunch of kids who don’t know the prices. They tried to overcharge me 10 dollars until I showed them the correct prices clearly on the menu board behind them. They could care less. Not cool after spending 40+ dollars already. Hire adults guys. My 5th time here and this is the second time the kids working there didn’t know your own prices.
… more
M Rog
Went to this place countless times since I was a kid. Just a solid high-quality pizza place and Jersey style Italian food. My only complaint is that if you get used to the type of high quality NJ pizza like they make here, if you ever leave the state (like I did) it will be almost impossible for you to like the local “attempts” at pizza. Hope these guys stick around forever.
… more
Christopher Halasz
Oh, these people do great Italian dinners. Pizza is good but it’s all about the sausage and peppers, chicken cutlets, and all the dinner entrees. We come from Chatham and pass about 5 other pizza joints on our way here because nobody does it like Romanelli’s
… more
Ethan Yoesting
I went there as my as my friend suggested it, and the customer service was friendly and the pizza was alright, not the best in the area but wasn’t terrible. Though I also ordered an eggplant parmigiana and it was barley edible and gave me food poisoning.
… more
Trevor Monk
I love this place! Great food and service!
… more
Nick Tsikitas
My first time there. The pizza was more of a little kids size and flimsy. The sauce was good and the crust was crunchy which gives it the 3 stars.
… more
… View more