Based on 89 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.7 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout
Address:
64 New York Ave, Halesite, NY 11743
Phone: (631) 271-1374
Website: http://carusositalianfinefoods.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Wednesday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Thursday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Friday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Saturday | 8 AM–7 PM |
| Sunday | 8 AM–5:30 PM |
| Monday | 8 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Fish Fellas
Best Italian fine foods in Huntington and all of Long Island! I Absolutely love this place everything is always fresh! I haven’t visited in awhile as I stopped working in that area. I remembered the place and decided to take a ride for lunch and I’ve been returning weekly with family for lunch and dinners. This is an Old school spot for Everything Italian! I love the hero’s, the bread is like getting it from a bakery..the fried chicken cutlets are like butter very tender and they have a great marinara sauce! I Love the fried eggplant super thin and always crispy never soggy. I eat it by hand no bread. Check out their hot meals, all freshly made daily..shrimp, chicken cacciatore, pork chops, sausage n peppers and so many more. Soooo delicious, tastes homemade. They also have fresh mozzarella, rice balls, potato croquettes, meats, steaks, sausages, fresh & dry pasta, ravioli, cookies, canned goods and my favorite chips “Charles potato chips” I haven’t seen them in years and they carry big bags. Another favorite they sell is ice cold Manhattan Special soda in the glass bottle an Italian American espresso soda, a Brooklyn favorite and hard to find in stores on Long Island! The family that owns Caruso’s and work here are warm and friendly they deserve all of our business. Check them out and thank me later!
… more
Lisa Moffa
The food we ordered was delicious especially the fresh canolis!
… more
Meghan Polis
As soon as I walked in the door I immediately knew it was a good last minute lunch decision. The classic chicken panini I ordered to go was absolutely delicious! With an assortment of hand selected Italian snacks, fresh pastas, and other delicious items, there was plenty to choose from to grab and go.
… more
Terence Ward
Fresh bread, pasta, all the usuals you would find in a good Italian Deli and a few others. Lots of homemade goodies! They also make a very good sandwich!
… more
Madeleine Giraldi
Always friendly, great salads and sandwiches. I get their house made Italian sauce, great for a quick meal, boil your favorite macaroni and add the sauce, don’t forget to pick up the Italian bread, it’s really good.
… more
alcides gonzalez
Love this place, food is fresh and delicious and the staff are always ready to help you by making great recommendations and providing excellent service.
… more
Robert Oberle
Went today for an Italian hero. The best in town. It was 12:30 and I was the only one in the store. I stood there being ignored by both of the guys behind the counter. One cleaning the meat slicer the other doing whatever. No , “hello I’ll be right with you “… nothing ! After standing there for two minutes feeling like a fool I walked out. This was not the first time I felt like they were doing me some kind of favor by taking my money.
… more
Kyle Smith
Steak sandwich made with actual steak, peppers, onions, melted motz, jalapeños on a garlic buttered toasted hero is incredible. Be prepared to wait a little bit while your there but the food is well worth it. Genuine Italian ran and operated deli
… more
Charles T
You should definitely get the Gigi sandwich. It was awesome. All the other sandwiches are awesome to.
… more
Al Gabrielli
Since you opened we have been patrons of your store, especially at Thanksgiving, Christmas, and Easter and we always order the stuffed breads and sometimes other products. The products are always fresh and extremely tasty and the hit of the day. However, for at least the past five years, every time we order stuffed breads and other products for the holiday, you always seem to lose our order and look at me like I am lying. In today’s marketplace, there is no reason to lose an order for whatever reason, especially during a holiday. Please try to upgrade your order taking which appears haphazard rather than streamlined.
… more
… View more