Airy, colorful pizzeria with a modest patio & menu of thick- or thin-crust pies, pasta & subs. Based on 246 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Drive-through ✔️ Delivery
Address:
224 W Cottage Grove Rd, Cottage Grove, WI 53527
Phone: (608) 839-3102
Website: http://www.papajimmys.com/
Hours
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Elizabeth
Edit: After posting the below review we did receive a call from the owner apologizing for the treatment we received and hand delivered a refund check to us, which was greatly appreciated. We aren’t the type of people to make a big deal of things in general, but felt we needed to say something in this situation. We did very much appreciate the owner reaching out to us to try and make things right. Besides this incident, we have enjoyed this restaurant since moving to the area.
… more
B_Rad
Usually like papa Jimmy’s, tonight’s call ahead order not so much. Waited 10 mins for someone at the drive up despite honking. Then asked to drive around to park and wait on bread sticks for another 10 mins and counting. Not a great experience today. Update- finally called them and waited another 5 mins. Just over 30 mins. Got home and surprised to see our 2 pints of ice cream was barely 1.5 pints. Very disappointed, taking off one more star…. update, good service and food on our first revisit, 7 mo later, adding back a star.
… more
Makenzie Rosol
I’ve had delivery and picked up from here several times and the food is awesome! The mac n cheese pizza and the chicken tenders are my two favorites. The ice cream is really good as well! Great local place!
… more
Michael Viney
Great small town family run pizza, pasta and sandwich place. Heated ham sandwiches on hoagie are my favorite sandwich. Their thin crust pizzas especially the Badger is our favorite. Staff is always friendly and the environment is always clean. They have a small outside seating area too. The final plus is they have ChocolateShop ice cream.
… more
Andrew West
My wife and I had the pleasure of trying Papa Jimmy’s Pizzeria tonight.
… more
Mikayla Brager
First time here – super cute atmosphere, lots of variety. I love the set up! Please don’t ever change
… more
CJ Wilson
My new favorite place to eat. The customer service was great, the food was ready quickly, and hot, oh, and everything taste amazing!
… more
Stanley Griffin
Excellent food, excellent service, happy employees, what more do you want? Go see them at Papa Jimmy’s!!!!
… more
michael glenn
So I am not sure how this place is rated highly? Maybe because its main local competitor was Pizza Hut, which sucks. I have tried to give this place chances since I moved to Cottage Grove. But the pizza here is not very good. It always amazes me that people open and invest in restaurants not realizing their food is trash. This place is a miss. I will just drive the extra 10-15 minutes to better options. Pizza shouldn’t be that hard, especially when you charge what this place does. Plus, the employees working here are not the greatest. Tonight, the last night I visit this place, the girl at the drive thru was not friendly or polite. And I regret adding a tip pre-paid on the order.
… more
Akim Nilausen
We stopped in to try something new and wow we were not disappointed. Great pizza, great service, and a wonderful atmosphere. To top it off we had some Chocolate Shoppe ice cream. Definitely adding Papa Jimmy’s to our list for repeat visits.
… more
… View more