Plum Tomato Pizzeria is an authentic Italian restaurant fresh all made to order. New York hand-tossed pizzas, authentic pasta dishes, chicken wings, calzones, desserts, salads, appetizers, and more. Fresh bread made daily: we offer Beer and Wine, delivery is available.
Gourmet pies, hoagies, calzones & classic Italian fare served in a relaxed setting. Based on 755 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
1988 Pinellas Ave, Tarpon Springs, FL 34689
Phone: (727) 944-3330
Hours
| Saturday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
Closed |
| Tuesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Elena Chinea-Ivani
Took my kiddos here for dinner and we all loved it. Service was wonderful and food was delicious. Great value.
… more
Cullen Haskins
Nice small restaurant. The outside location does not give the best first impression. The Servers were welcoming and nice. The food was good but could have used some more seasoning. For the price it was a good. One suggestion for the ambiance: We sat at a booth close to a service station that contained the phone. It rang too loudly. I would recommend moving or turning the ringtone down or placing something to reduce the ringtone going into the dining space. We will be back. Thank You
… more
Trish Acampora
A great neighborhood Italian Restaurant with lunch specials, dinners and delicious pizza. They offer delivery and take-out. My favorites are the lasagna and chicken parm you get a house salad and fresh bread. I’m a big fan of their desserts too The canolis and chocolate cake will not disappoint. Yum
… more
Hannah-Rose Monegro
Amazing food! Amazing service! Clean and comfy atmosphere! Probably one of the best Italian food places I’ve had in quite some time 🙂
… more
Susan Carroll
This was the best Italian restaurant, family and I have been to. The service is fantastic. The food delicious. This is a very small place, but always full of customers. You get a huge bowl of Penne Alla vodka was perfect. Enough for two people. The same size bowl for their pasta dishes, huge!
… more
Joseph (Rockstar)
Nice family run Italian restaurant in a small retail strip center. Foods seem to all be fresh and made to order. The lasagna had a nice sauce but seemed overcooked with the noodle texture and the char on the meat. The Alfredo sauce is very heavy with fresh cheese and cream. So be prepared for a heavy homemade Alfredo, a plus if that’s what you seek but for me was too heavy. The alla Vodka sauce provides a better balance of flavor and eliminates the extreme heaviness of the Alfredo, yet is still on the heavy side. The flavor profile on the alla vodka also lacked the little zing and boldness I seek, so some extra oregano and some crushed pepper was added by me. Overall this place is worth a visit since while just an okay place by my taste buds. I could also see how someone could rate this establishment both lower or higher than me.
… more
smcfarland2426
Best pizza around, try the vodka fries or a glass of wine with your pizza . Fresh ingredients really makes a difference. You can watch them make your food and you can see how clean the kitchen is. Makes me and the family feel safer. Great staff, Melissa, Dawn and GG always on top of things….. never an empty glass!
… more
Purpletravelgrrl
It’s a very small place but the food was really good. The chicken pot pie soup and fresh baked bread were fantastic. The Mediterranean Chicken was good but the lemon flavor could have been stronger. The lemon cake was amazing.
… more
Dawn Knowlton
We order takeout at least once a week, always have veal francese and eggplant rollitini . Plus another item . Enough for 2 dinners . Food is fantastic! They have their own drivers , that we now know and are great ! Never a problem…..try them
… more
Ed Igoe
Good food. Generous portions. Our waitress was excellent, but the other constantly yelled and carried on with her regular customers which spoiled the mood. The room is small… Basically a bar.
… more
… View more