Based on 71 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No delivery
Address:
2763 Eggert Rd, Tonawanda, NY 14150
Phone: (716) 834-4404
Website: http://www.rizzoscasadiitalia.com/
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Sarjay Panesar
One of my best experiences at a restaurant. The food was delicious and service was one in a million by Judy. Ordered the mozzarella slabs which were out of this world with the home sauce on the side. Got Buffalo chicken pizza and it was the closest thing to actually eating wings. Also had the Brasciole and it was melt in your mouth. Even the bread and garlic butter was fresh flavourful. Glad we were able to find this gem in Tonawanda
… more
Christina Tomassi
This was quite possibly the worst dining experience I’ve ever had in my entire life. We came in for restaurant week. Appetizers were subpar, but the entrees were horrible. My lasagna came out ICE COLD like it came from a freezer. I didn’t touch a bite of it. The server did not come back to check on us, so I was unable to ask for it to be heated back up. When the server came back, she apologized and said the manager won’t do anything to compensate. So I paid for a meal I didn’t touch. The server was nice and tried to compensate by giving us extra dessert….. but this is the dessert that came out for us. Not sure what to even say about it… it’s literally crumbs. I have no idea how this place is busy. Horrible management and terrible food. It’s a disgrace to call this an Italian restaurant. I WILL NEVER RETURN and I’ll be sure to tell family and friends to never step foot in here.
… more
Duane Price
This was recommended and it did not disappoint. Our server Greg was phenomenal. We really enjoyed our time there. The food was delicious. The chicken parm was everything and more that I was told. Go I promise you’ll enjoy it
… more
Robert “Bud” Booth
Great specials on weekdays. Very good food and reasonable prices. Decent wine list and beer assortment. Friendly service , clean and contemporary decor.
… more
Kyle Matesic
Been going here for awhile now on Thursdays for trivia. Food has gone down hill and pretty quick. Pizza is awful wings are eh. I’d recommend going elsewhere
… more
Chris H
Don’t normally write reviews but, this is worth mentioning. Great food, great portions, friendly waitress. Great experience, will definitely be back in the future.
… more
Brian Moeller
Didn’t record our reservation, but they were able to seat us anyway. Neglected to mention that they were operating on a very limited menu, which we found out when the server approached us. It was not what we were looking for. We did not stay for a meal.
… more
Patty Crescimano
We had a great waiter named Adam but for the first time I was extremely disappointed with my meal except for the house salad with blue cheese which was delicious. I ordered the artichoke appetizer again because the first time I had them they were beyond delicious. This time they were on the dry side and heavily seasoned with red chili flakes I was not expecting. Then I ordered the stuffed shrimp scampi, the shrimp were over cooked and chewy. I didn’t complain but I gave my husband a bite to make sure it wasn’t me he said the same thing. Adam didn’t hesitate to take it off the check. We did find out they were short a chef so I hope they can get back to the delicious food they had before. I would like to give them another chance.
… more
Phil Migdalski
My wife and I are always on the search for authentic food. This place was it. Definitely top five on my list for Italian. Vodka sauce was perfect. Pasta was perfect. Meatballs were possibly the best I’ve ever had at a restaurant. Food and drinks are reasonably priced (all things considered). Service was awesome thanks to Judy. We’ll be back for sure.
… more
Deborah Telaak
It was restaurant week and only Thursday at 5PM. I called for a reservation, we waited at the door for at least 10 minutes before we were approached by an employee. We sat down waited at least 15 minutes before someone came by and said they took your order right? We said no, no one has been here at all. They were sold out of a few things. The chicken with spinach risotto was not good, the chicken was not good and the risotto was flavorless and texture was very mushy. There shrimp scampi was not good, very dry and barely any moisture on the pasta. The brisket had no flavor and the polenta was awful. Three of us had dinner and none of us liked our dinner. The service was extraordinarily slow, although a table near us that set down after us had their drinks, apps and food before we even had our drinks???? They definitely knew somebody!!! We were regulars at Rizzo’s years ago. Hadn’t been there in a while. Would not go back!!
… more
… View more