Based on 929 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
Address:
311 E Jefferson St, Tipton, IN 46072
Phone: (765) 675-8787
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Jess A
I can’t review much from here. I am absolutely obsessed with their salads though. It’s hard to find a good salad especially in this area. They are packed full and heaping. I drive 20+ minutes at least once a month for one. If you’re a salad person, you know what I mean. 🙂
… more
Jeramy Madlung
Buffet style pizza joint. Included though, they will make you a small pizza with whatever topping you want. They bring out fresh spaghetti, and table side drink service. There is also a salad bar. Everything I tried tasted great, definitely small town atmosphere and you get the feeling everyone knows everyone else and that is certainly one of my favorite parts.
… more
Maggie Sizelove
Food is excellent as always. Service is normally flawless, however, we had a party of 7 we were entertaining from out of town. The waitress did not remove one plate the entire time. We basically ate our meal in a trash pile. It was awkward and embarrassing for us as the hosts. we spent 70.00 that day and it felt like we were eating in a dumpster. we even bussed and stacked plates and bowls to encourage removal. I love this place, which is why I chose to entertain so many guests here. Its A novelty experience. The food is amazing! The owner has been top notch for many years. however, the servers are the face of the company. They can make or break an experience.
… more
Bob Philly
My wife and I I love Pizza Shack!
… more
Leeanne Etchison
Wonderful, family friendly place! The owner came out and teased my son about a bday spanking for his Nana’s birthday! Creating priceless memories and we’re so thankful for Pizza Shack!!
… more
Brittany Winfield
Gotta say it was a pretty good experience for my first time going there. Granted there was a little bit of a wait for my takeout order, but I feel like it’s a typical Saturday for any restaurant at lunch. Other than that the food was pretty good. Salad and toppings were fresh. The pizza and little cheese bread sticks brought it all together for a pretty good meal. It reminded me of the pizza in school.. basic but still good. I’d definitely bring my family to this place to enjoy the $11 buffet.
… more
Mary Statzer
This was our first time to eat at Pizza Shack and we will definitely be back. The salad bar was fresh, with lots of choices.The hot bar was constantly being checked and filled with a variety of pizza, even though it was late in the evening. All the employees were friendly and helpful. Glad we went!
… more
Freie Houston
Pizza Shack has by far one of the best buffets ever. Not only do they serve pizza but they will bring you Spaghetti with or without meatballs and garlic bread. The salad bar is supreme. Staff is very friendly and the price is very reasonable.
… more
Sayder Quadriad
A great family friendly pizza buffet ran by local young adults. Enjoyable atmosphere and good pizza. Would have given 5 stars but the seat spacing is a bit tight on the booths the tables in the booths are to close for the heftier customer so I would recommend sitting at a table not the booths.
… more
Steve Sitzes
They keep the pizza buffet well supplied and you never have to worry about asking for more to drink since someone is constantly going around with pitchers to refill your cup. No skimping and toppings either. Great all around pizza place.
… more
… View more