Based on 205 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
82685 Overseas Hwy, Islamorada, FL 33036
Phone: (305) 664-1404
Hours
| Saturday | 5–10 PM |
| Sunday | 5–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
5–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 5–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 5–10 PM |
| Thursday | 5–10 PM |
| Friday | 5–10 PM |
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: stoneoven.pizza
Reviews
jeff klein
The pizza here was excellent. It came out hot and could speak the sauce was very good and tasted homemade the homemade. We weren’t that hungry when we went in but it smelled so good that we definitely ordered way too much. If you’re looking for great pizza in the Key Largo area,this is the place to go.
… more
Frank Dunlap
This is the best pizza I have had in the keys so far. The cauliflower crust is great and the cheese is just amazing. I don’t know how you make mozzarella taste so wonderful.
… more
Mark Lanyon
Pulled over here on the drive back to Miami from Key West at our kids request. Not a family friendly place. It was empty save for 10 very loud, hard at work day drinkers with no bartender or employee otherwise present. We waited a good five minutes and decided to leave but I allowed my kid to use the restroom. Big mistake as we were heading out the door and suddenly a bartender lady comes rushing out from a backroom yelling “THANKS FOR USING THE BATHROOM AND NOT STICKING AROUND!!!!!” . . . .nice.
… more
Bryan-Maureen Swafford
We arrived late on the first night of our second trip to Islamorada and settled on pizza. Unfortunately, we had passed our favorite pizza place in Key Largo and didn’t feel like turning around. After checking into the hotel, we went to search for pizza nearby. Starving and exhausted, we turned into a parking lot that looked like it had a decent amount of customers. Unlike the last trip, we hadn’t gone looking for reviews.
… more
Destani
Is there online ordering or no? Everytime I try to click on it, I get redirected continuously to different pages. Always end up going in, I recommend the pizza side over the bar, I’ve only gotten chicken tenders & onion rings. Both very good, but takes close to an half an hour to an hour for anything.
… more
Robert Busch
Best pizza in the area. Had three people recommended this place, and it didn’t disappoint. We had 5 orders and were out in 25 minutes.
… more
Mirandajo Suarez
This pizzeria had the best reviews so we thought why not! We ordered garlic knots and supreme large pizza & it was Y U M M Y. The cheese was even delicious and I’m not a huge cheese eater. (I prefer not cheesy lol). The young gentleman that was cooking the pizza did an awesome job. The woman who was are server was killing it even though they got slammed. I want to give them a round of a applause for getting the orders in and out in a timely manner and not forgetting about us. If you’re looking for some good pizza & beer this is your place!
… more
Dan Frye
The pizza is great. Do it! You won’t regret it. The Margarita pizza is my favorite. You can get cauliflower crust here as well.
… more
Brad Evans
I love all food. I would never leave a review good or bad for anywhere but this was just appalling. Called in an order. Told us it’d be ready in 15 minutes. We walked down to the store and they said it wasn’t quite ready yet. We waited another half hour and some other person came back into the store with our pizzas. The store then offered said pizzas to us. When we refused they remade them, waited over an hour, no compensation, we arrived home and found half our pizza missing all toppings upon requesting one ingredient be omitted. One star for taste, if I could leave less based on service I would.
… more
Brian Gordon
Dark, loud and no service. I just wanted a quieter place. This is not the one. Pizza was decent.
… more
… View more