Based on 513 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
11203 Sheldon Rd, Tampa, FL 33626
Phone: (813) 926-6969
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Saturday | 10 AM–11 PM |
| Sunday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
10 AM–10 PM
Hours might differ
|
| Tuesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 10 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 10 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Rich Pentony
This is a great pizza shop serving hood NY Style pizza. Being from the NYC area, this pizza is super comparable to what I would expect when visiting home. The owners were super nice and the slices are double sized. I typically eat 2 slices but one here was filling. Check them out if you want a quick slice of pizza to eat outside there or take to go!
… more
Sara Ferry
Stumbled upon this little pizza place when I went to the Circle K next door and WOW, this pizza is awesome! Big slices, real mozz and the crust is slightly chewy and crunchy, it’s perfect. Love local pizza shops, I will definitely be back.
… more
Sue Anne
Pizza and wings are excellent! Girls working there are friendly, never had any issues with the food or service.
… more
Mo
The cheese pizza was amazing it taste similar to whole food pizza but I prefer the NY pizza. It’s definitely better than other big franchises. Only complain that don’t expect a tip for picking up my order. Also there was a black paint on the inner side of the box.
… more
bigbad dt
Tonight was the worst pizza experience I can remember. It might be a tie with Little Ceasars. They actually gave me an old pizza. I ordered 2 pizzas and the cheese one was clearly a left over they didn’t sell off of the by the slice counter earlier in the day. It looks like they put it back in the oven and the outer part of the pizza was sort of melted and the middle was matted down like the left overs that you would pull out of the fridge the next day. It wasn’t even hot. The other pie, while was a little more recently cooked, it had garlic chunks the size of almonds throughout. I would have gone with 1 star, but gave 2 for mercy due to having had a decent pizza in the past from here. I won’t be back as this is more like strike 5 and not my first unsatisfactory experience here.
… more
Rafael Rivera
Ok, pizza is a big deal for me. I grew up in Jersey, so I know pizza. Lol. Had NY / NJ
… more
Scott Smith
They have by far the best pizza with multiple locations. I’ve been to 5 different locations and all of which are perfect.
… more
Michele Muslusky
Got a pizza for carryout. Not the most flavorful but we liked the topping availability. People seemed nice, carry out transaction was quick. It’s a crazy small place, seating it outside between the building and neighboring gas station.
… more
Melanie Khioukhom
We ordered through Uber and it said it was ready. They had difficulties with their wifi so did not get our order. They said to give them 7 minutes.. which stuff happens, I was willing to wait. I went back in 15 minutes later and it wasn’t done. Still understandable. I was willing to wait. But this is what we waited for. It was soggy. Barely any pepperoni on it. A whole lotta grease…. by far worst pizza we’ve ever had. This pizza alone was $17.25
… more
Rosalinda Love
I went for the first time I was really feeling that pizza. I’m Native New Yorker .It was so good. I felt like I was back in New York. Also made a cell order. All I could do is think about the pizza once again, I had to go back. I’m so happy I found this place everyone’s friendly and nice very professional. If you’re looking for great pizza, New York style this is the one to go for . I’ve been looking for this style of pizza for years. Here in Tampa. all I could do was just dream about it .I’ve been here 35 years. those flavors are hard to fine .thank you New York, New York, Pizza. Shout out to Sheldon Road location
… more
… View more